Its a baa post, if it wasn't overly critical and completely off the mark it just wouldn't be baa. Personally having rented Tiger 08 & 09, the game play to me this year easily warrented the 60 dollar purchase. From club tuner, to precission putting, to Tournament Challenge being tons of fun. Add in the Live tournaments and a full fledge season mode and its easy to say its the best Tiger yet imo. I'm digging Tiger 10 far more than any previous incarnation of the series so far.