Really guy, really?
Come on now, Nostalgia is a wonderful thing, but this is because you don't want to enjoy other games.
Huh? After reading your short preview on it, it sounds EXACTLY like RTTS, and not "a different approach".
This guys sounds "out of touch".
Ok I read enough. IGN, get a guy who values sports especially baseball, cause this guy seems to care less, and the coolest feature to him is "fast play" (The Show). Really now.
That is the only letdown from these big corporate sites that are not genre focused like Operation Sports. You get the guy who isnt into sports games, hanging on to nostalgia when there is many sports games after that game just as good, if not better, doing previews/reviews. Gamespot is guilty of this too.