[brettmickey]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeah...THAT Guy

If you think McCoy is only #5, you should read this: https://www.profootballfocus.com/blo...-gerald-mccoy/ He's closer to being the #1 DT than he is #5.

Yeah that's pretty impressive. They are all within 2-3 overall points to me so it isn't a big deal in my eyes exactly how these 5 players rank specifically. It isn't hard to make great arguments for most of them as being higher than others but I know personally I have Geno Atkins pretty firmly at 1st and the rest are almost interchangeable between 2-5.

My rankings I made (which are in no way concrete) were basically trying to show that 1. Atkins last full season was nothing short of remarkable and he was on track for an encore performance and 2. Suh is "overrated" in the fact that his name carries a little more value than his actual performance/production. The rest all have their strengths and value depending on scheme and what you value most in a d-lineman. Again, they are all within 3 overall points to me so I can't go wrong with any of them in my eyes