Madden NFL 12 - Top Ten Rookie Ratings

[JayInSaratoga]

Quote: Originally Posted by TexasBorn1

Cam Newton not in the top ten? Surprising

I'd imagine he has one of the higher potential ratings though.

[spfhelmiii]

Blech. The Prince Amukamara rating is ridiculous - the guy was picked 19th. EA's ratings czar knows the skills of Prince better than the teams that passed on him?

I can see some subjectivity as far as initially downgrading guys who are all about potential/upside (Cam Newton) and initially upgrading guys who are supposedly "polished" as far as college prospects, but this one's a stretch. I will be making some changes in my franchise mode, for sure, even if only to downgrade certain rookies that EA is in love with to line up better with where they were drafted.

[ir2proforu2]

patrick peterson SWEET! cardinals will be a blast to play with

[brettmickey]

I think this would be my top 10 (I'll just use the same 10 players they use to keep it simple):
1. Peterson
2. Dareus
3. Green
4. Miller
5. Jones
6. Amukamara
7. Watt
8. Ingram
9. Pouncey
10. Quinn

[ssryry29]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Amaizen Blue

First move in franchise mode... acquire Prince Amukamara...

Luckily I don't have to do that. I might just go get Peterson.

[Wilson24]

ITs lame how franchise mode would even let you trade for these guys.....it just never happens and if you really want to it better be for a 1st,3rd and a high rated player

[Chrisksaint]

Sweet Ingram as a 79 and with PP7 I'll just start a Cards franchise instead of pulling off an unrealistic trade for him

[scottyo60]

The worst thing with the Cards will be trading for a qb