Could not have said it better, this is how you are going to create differentiation, personally, I could care less if...
- Crosby, Stamkos, Ovechkin, and all the top 7 to 10 players are 95 overall and up
- the hard nosed players that score(like your Kreiders your Benns and Tomas Holmstrom guys) are at an applicable range, Benn at like a 90 Kreider like an 85 and Holmstrom I couldnt rate cause he is no longer in the league, but nonetheless play a style that is very net crasher heavy
- and finally, your scrubs, fourth liners, and scratches, in the range from 65-75/80. These guys are not very good and I would only rate them highly if they are young and after time progresses if they do not perform either their overall fluctuates or slowly declines. These are some routes to go to create some skill differentiation
This could improve the game a boat load by using a super large range instead on 60 to 95, because the overall scale starts at a point higher than that... 36. They might as well make the scale 1-63 if they're just going to start at 36(and sorry if botched math there but I am not good with numbers lol)