I agree with all of this post except for the last couple sentences. Madden's franchise is a joke, and I would like to see some changes on the field. That said, I feel like the elite players stand out, as they should. There is a huge difference using a bad quarterback compared to elite. HUGE. And there is a huge difference using lower rated WR versus elite WRs. I think the big separation in skills with players on the field is one of the few things Madden does well.
On 2016, I think its going to be a massive year for The Show. I loved 15, and with 16 being the third cycle on the PS4 I think there will be a big improvement on what is already a great game.