OOTP6 FOFC League: Draft Poll

[RPI-Fan]

please vote if you're signed up (or are considernig signing up)

[Z²+]

My other vote:

General Mike's idea about a dispersal draft with a protected list of maybe 3 players from the original team.

[Bearcat729]

My vote being the same as Z

[Ragone]

I like General Mike's idea as well.. however.. i'm wondering who the pirates will protect :P

[MizzouRah]

I that or 2 pitchers, 2 position players..

1 pitcher has to have gold stars (generally a vet)
1 pitcher has to have blue stars (a rookie)

the same with position players...

[General Mike]

Other - My idea. And as far as 3 players, thats just a general number to throw out their, because I figure even the bottom teams have 3 guys they would like to keep. And it's not like you have to protect 3 major league players. A team could protect 3 hot shot prospects, or 3 top veterans, or mix and match.

[Z²+]

Originally Posted by Ragone

i'm wondering who the pirates will protect :P

Even the Pirates have at least 3 players to protect

If only I could find a way to let OOTP let Lloyd McClendon be my utility outfielder

[JeeberD]

I would prefer no draft, but if we go that route I really like being able to have a three or five man protected list...

[Masked]

Originally Posted by Z²+

My other vote:

General Mike's idea about a dispersal draft with a protected list of maybe 3 players from the original team.

I love this idea. It allows the people who got a team they really care about to keep a couple of key guys to keep some attachment, and for the rest of us, we can choose a couple guys to mold our teams around.

[mtaystl03]

I say 2 protected pitchers and 2 protected offensive players.

[MrBug708]

No draft, but if we did, I'd say any combo of 7, but no more than 5 at either position or pitcher

[Ragone]

Why jeeber? half your team is gonna be applying for aarp cards after first year anyway

[JeeberD]

Berkman? Hildago? Oswalt? Lane? Miller? Hernandez? Ensberg?

Yeah, so Bags and Bidge and Clemens and Kent are old-timers, but the Astros have plenty of young talent as well...

[SackAttack]

Hildago? Does that mean you'll be leaving Hidalgo unprotected?

[RPI-Fan]

It sounds like there is some real merit to considering the "partial" draft idea - I, of course, would rather do it in full, but that would be a nice compromise, I think. Hopefully before too long we can get some kind of board to have more formal voting or whatever.

[Ben E Lou]

I normally would be in favor of a full draft if possible, but it just so happens that I only have one weekend between now and mid-June that I'd be free enough to participate in a live draft. If people would be willing to do a "slow" live draft, I'd be all for that.

[RPI-Fan]

I'm not sure about this, but what we might do would be "medium-speed" draft - you get 20 minutes or so to pick during the day or you can do a list pick, and optional picks are at night. And after a couple of rounds of that, you can start some 3-5 round mini-draft live sessions, and since it's past the first couple of rounds, drafting via list wouldn't be that big of a deal.

Obviously this is just speculation, but it seems a plan like that might be suitable for all involved.

We'll still need to work out whether there really is interest in doing any kind of draft though.

[General Mike]

Originally Posted by MrBug708

No draft, but if we did, I'd say any combo of 7, but no more than 5 at either position or pitcher

MrBug, no offense, but 7 is a ton of guys to protect, maybe too many, especially for the top tier teams.
Yankees for example - ARod, Jeter, Posada, Vazquez, Mussina, Rivera, Giambi/Sheffield
Oakland for example - Chavez, Crosby, Kotsay, Hudson, Mulder, Zito, Harden
San Diego for example - Giles, Burroughs, Klesko, Loretta, Peavy, Lawrence, Eaton

Maybe 3 major league players, and 3 prospects (no ML experience) is a good compromise.

Picking a good roster set, is a key as well.

[MizzouRah]

Originally Posted by General Mike

MrBug, no offense, but 7 is a ton of guys to protect, maybe too many, especially for the top tier teams.
Yankees for example - ARod, Jeter, Posada, Vazquez, Mussina, Rivera, Giambi/Sheffield
Oakland for example - Chavez, Crosby, Kotsay, Hudson, Mulder, Zito, Harden
San Diego for example - Giles, Burroughs, Klesko, Loretta, Peavy, Lawrence, Eaton

Maybe 3 major league players, and 3 prospects (no ML experience) is a good compromise.

Picking a good roster set, is a key as well.

I have the CBLCardinals v1.3 roster set, and most of it seems pretty darn good to me.

I was thinking today, since there are quite a few minor league players included as well in this roster set, I think a total of 5 protected players sounds about right - I also like the 2 position players, 2 pitchers.


Todd

[ISiddiqui]

I'm all for no draft... just take what's given to ya and go .

[mtaystl03]

Vote in the new forum poll!