Which Player Do You Like More?

[Matt2You]

In your opinion, which player do you consider to be better? Or, To word it in a different way; between these two players--Who would you keep?

#1 will is ahead by 5 weeks in playmaking

Player #1....

Speciality: Head

Stamina: excellent Goaltending: disastrous
Playmaking: world class Passing: poor
Winger: weak Defending: weak
Scoring: wretched Set Pieces: wretched

or:

Player #2....

Speciality: Unpredictable

Stamina: excellent Goaltending: disastrous
Playmaking: world class Passing: inadequate
Winger: weak Defending: passable
Scoring: weak Set Pieces: inadequate

[Desnudo]

#2! Who does #2 work for?

[NAIWF]

Even though I don't like Unpredictable players, I'd keep # 2 without a second thought. This assumes they are the same age of course or that # 1 isn't much younger which would skew things.

[RPI-Fan]

#2, in a landslide.

The unpredictable will help him, A LOT, and rarely/never hurt him.

[One_to7]

Experience being equal..........#2.

Nice secondaries, and they work perfectly with the unpred specialty.

[finkenst]

#2!

No doubt.

inad passing / passable defense...

disclaimer: I hope to have a world class player someday.

[Matt2You]

Their both the same age. As a plus though--#2 seems to have a much better average form. Their not World Class yet (as anyone can tell by looking at my team) but I am deciding who gets sold off when. I'm going to sell #1 off around week 14 at magnificient I believe.

[terpkristin]

Their both the same age. As a plus though--#2 seems to have a much better average form. Their not World Class yet (as anyone can tell by looking at my team) but I am deciding who gets sold off when. I'm going to sell #1 off around week 14 at magnificient I believe.
A good idea. The average form thing will play a nice role for you. If he's already WC, then the next level they'll hit is supernatural. Good luck!!

~tk

[terpkristin]

Dola,
Random question.
With their high level of PM but relative lack of secondary skills, what kind of performance do these guys put up, say, in passable form?

~tk

[Matt2You]

Their not yet World Class, I'm just planning who should be kept. I can only speak on how Brilliant's perform--And there is no difference in performance as far as midfield goes... But passing does help out attack. Defence doesn't seem to help out anywhere as much as passing does... though; but it is still a huge help. I'd have more input but I had too much of a form difference to say more.

[FrogMan]

I see what you mean now Matt. Projections...

Not to thredjack, but here's another one for you all. Two of may players and the playmaking level they should attain when I switch from playmaking to winger training for good, who would you keep???

Miao Thanh-Tuan
Stamina: excellent Keeper: disastrous
Playmaking: brilliant Passing: solid
Winger: poor Defending: weak
Scoring: poor Set Pieces: inadequate

or

Hubert Gortemaker
Stamina: excellent Keeper: disastrous
Playmaking: magnificient Passing: inadequate
Winger: weak Defending: inadequate
Scoring: poor Set Pieces: weak


My mind is already made up, I just want to see what other people thinks...

So who would you keep, to stay on your team for a looooooong time??

FM

[Matt2You]

Are they both Brilliant+0 and Magnificient+0?

[FrogMan]

yes, they should pop the exact same week. They are in perfect synch now...

FM

[saintjo]

personally, i would keep hubert. i think a level of playmaking is worth more than 2 levels of passing.

[KevinNU7]

I'd keep Hubert, you'll be training Winger so your attack ratings will improve that way. The passing from the midfield is less important