Best video football game this year

[Kodos]

Time for a poll!

[MikeVic]

I'd vote Madden '08 for Wii since it's the only one I've played, and I enjoy it. But I see it's not up. What a discriminatory alien.

[Kodos]

Yeah. I made a judgement call that the Wii versions couldn't be the best. :)

I can be such a poll dictator!

[Eaglesfan27]

I voted for NCAA because it has the best combo of gameplay and a good dynasty mode. Neither are perfect, but the quality of the combination is the best from those choices. I voted for the 360 version since it is the only version I've played.

[sterlingice]

This lacks Trout or Maximum Football 2008 answers ;)

SI

[Raiders Army]

I only have NCAA and Madden for the 360, so I went with NCAA.

[WSR]

At another board I frequent, tpg.net, the guys their believe that APF has the best gameplay and Madden the best graphics.

[cartman]

Well, since Max. FB 2.0000001212332e-14 wasn't a choice, I went with NCAA on the 360.

[Greyroofoo]

The Nfl has alienated me w/ its w/ ass punishments

[Icy]

NCAA08, i have it in the PS3 and it's great, but voted for the 360 because the 60fps.

[Karlifornia]

Where is Michigan/App. State?

[KWhit]

NCAA 360

[MizzouRah]

Since Madden's franchise mode is pretty much broken, I went with APF 2k8. The atmostphere in that game is everything I want Madden to have.

[Noop]

NCAA08 for 360

I have brought Madden in 3 years...

[Balldog]

I went with APF, but I almost voted for Madden 08 PS2.

[MJ4H]

Useless poll without options for Wii.

[stevew]

Wii Madden isn't even close to the quality of any of the other games. Wise to not include it.

[MJ4H]

On the contrary, it is the only one I would even consider playing.

[MikeVic]

Wii Madden isn't even close to the quality of any of the other games. Wise to not include it.

Other than the fuzzy zoom-out bug and that automatic flip pass, I find it very enjoyable. I don't notice any interception/fumble problems, and the CPU seems to play properly.

[MJ4H]

NO MAN ITS ABOUT THE GRAPHCZXI

[Kodos]

I don't think anyone who takes these games seriously could choose the Wii.

[Shkspr]

What, no DS options?

[Groundhog]

Madden 2008 would have been the greatest game ever if not for the fumbles, interceptions, simulated stats, mind boggling lack of in-game stats, and dynasty bugs with Free Agents that makes it unplayable.

Seriously.

[MJ4H]

I don't think anyone who takes these games seriously could choose the Wii.

I don't think anyone that likes to have fun could choose anything but the Wii. But I guess I don't take it as OMG SERIUZ as you guys. I mean, I don't even care if the players have arm hair and adam's apples.

[johneh]

What no option for Maximum Football 2.0 or Football Mogul ??

[Kodos]

I just can't see playing an extended dynasty on the Wii. It is, after all, a kid's machine. :) DUDEZ.

[MJ4H]

Well that certainly is the only way to play.