PDA

View Full Version : Interesting Player Career Arcs


Ajaxab
12-19-2023, 02:55 PM
I don't know if there is a general interest in seeing what individual players do and how their careers progress, but I enjoy the stories. Not really a dynasty, but an individual player narrative. To whit, I give you Philadelphia Eagles qb, Gustavo McGowen. Drafted #1 overall in 2026 as a Lamar Jackson-type, McGowen would see early individual success winning the 2026 Rookie of the Year Award. He would even lead the Eagles to the playoffs in that rookie season where they would lose to the Commanders in round 1.

McGowen's running style would lead to injury-riddled after injury-riddled season. He would lead the Eagles to the playoffs in 10 straight years (and the streak is ongoing). But when it came time to push Philadelphia to ultimate success, he was a failure or sitting on the sidelines with another injury. In 2028, he went down in week 15 with a sprained MCL that would end his season. Philly had started the year 12-1. In spite of McGowen's injury, the Eagles would go on to win the Super Bowl that year with backup qb, Jonas Jenks, winning the MVP award.

In 2029, McGowen would be undefeated...in the games he played. A broken shinbone kept him out for 8 weeks, but he was healthy heading into the playoffs. Despite playing one of the four best games in his career, McGowen and the Eagles were upset by the 9-8 Giants.

2030 was bound to be McGowen's year of revenge. As a 5th year experienced qb, he led the Eagles to a 13-0 start. But again in mid-December, that sprained MCL returned and sidelined him for the playoffs. Rookie qb, Britt Redman, came in and continued the perfect season as Philadelphia capped off an undefeated year with a rout of Houston in the Super Bowl. It seems as though Coach De Leon felt sorry for McGowen in that game. With the Eagles up 41-7 late in the 3rd, he put McGowen in for some garbage time on that sprained knee. The fans loved it, but McGowen could hardly take any credit for leading the team to a winning postseason. To cap things off, Redman ended up winning the Super Bowl MVP. McGowen's 2030 was so good that he won both Offensive Player of the Year, Player of the Year, and was All-League First Team QB, despite having only played 14 games. But he couldn't take any credit for the team's playoff success.

In 2031, McGowen has the Eagles out to a 7-3 start before tearing a foot ligament and going down for the year. In 2032, he comes back and finally wins his first playoff start in round 1 before Philly loses to Green Bay in the NFC title game. 2033 is more of the same. McGowen plays 14 games and gets Philly to the postseason, but has a disastrous playoff game throwing 5 picks against the Giants in one of the poorest performances of his career, a 28-20 first round playoff loss. In 2034, McGowen has the Eagles rolling again and he's able to stay healthy enough to play in 15 games, but again he can't get the team over the playoff hump. Philadelphia loses to Carolina 29-21 in the NFC title game.

By this point, Eagles fans are starting to wonder if McGowen is the guy. He's been great...when he's been healthy. A trip to IR every three years doesn't bode well for an aging quarterback. But the Philadelphia brass sticks with him. In 2035, McGowen does something he hasn't been able to do in his career. He starts every game and guides the Eagles to a 12-5 record. In round 1, they face an aging Brock Purdy and the Seattle Seahawks. McGowen is awful throwing 2 Ints and putting up a 53 qb rating. But the team rallies around him to win with a solid running game and a vicious pass rush. In the NFC title game, McGowen struggles again in only managing to pass for 168 yards and again has trouble protecting the ball. But again, his teammates rally around him with a solid rushing day and the Eagles win 23-18. The victory sends the Eagles to an all-Pennsylvania Super Bowl against the Steelers. In a back and forth game, McGowen gets the ball at his own 27, down 31-27 with 3:45 on the clock. In the drive of his life, he leads the team on a 12 play, 73 yard td drive to win the title for Philly. Game over. Eagles 34-Steelers 31. McGowen wins the Super Bowl MVP after passing for 258 yards and running for another 81. Finally, his team. His title.

markdub2
12-19-2023, 04:25 PM
great story!

bblom23
12-19-2023, 05:13 PM
Awesome story, well written!

Unimaginative
12-20-2023, 01:24 PM
Dig stuff like this. I almost consider FoF less of a game at this point, and more of a narrative engine! Really fun story!

markdub2
12-20-2023, 05:50 PM
Dig stuff like this. I almost consider FoF less of a game at this point, and more of a narrative engine! Really fun story!

Agreed, and this is the main reason I could never play with 0 Injury. It creates great dramatic moments and stories. I think NFL level injury rate where you go through 50-60 players a season is a little much but I think the default setting is great

Dutch
12-20-2023, 10:53 PM
Good point on the injuries and making interesting storylines.

Here's my addition to this.

2024: (As Tampa Bay) Drafted Scott Upton with the 8th overall pick. A scrambling QB with a great arm. He takes us to the Super Bowl as a rookie and we win it all with a 23-3 drubbing of the Denver Broncos. I'm set at QB for 15 years!

2025: Scott Upton loses the NFC Championship game to the Detroit Lions, 21-20...

2026: Scott Upton loses the NFC Championship game to the Green Bay Packers, 31-13...(at the hands of the best QB in the game named Glen Maule).

2027: Scott Upton doesn't go to the playoffs as the Bucs have a dismal 8-8-1 year. (I draft a QB in the 6th round of this 2027 draft named Tyree Harris. He was drafted to sit behind my star QB Scott Upton (8th overall pick in 2024)... more on him later as he's the star of this write-up.

But as I was still learning the new UI, I failed to resign my players in the first stage of the 2028 free agency. The result of that? My star QB, Scott Upton walked away for a $200 million dollar contact in Baltimore. That left me with an old QB mentor and the 6th round QB, Tyree Harris, drafted the previous year. Not good enough...

So in the ensuing 2028 draft, I find a new QB in the first round (15th overall) named Sebastian Stewart.

2028: Sebastian Stewart has a good year, wins 10 games and we're playoff bound!

Wildcard round Sebastian handily beats the Chicago Bears 27-10.

The next game is against Arizona. We're down 17-10 in the 3rd quarter when tragedy strikes. Sebastian is hurt and can't continue.

Enter Tyree Harris, that 6th round pick from Duke.

He hits one of his WR's for a 55-yard TD strike at the end of the 3rd quarter. The game is tied 17-17 and in the 4th quarter, AZ scores and Tyree Harris counters, AZ scores again, and with 4 seconds left, Tyree counters. 31-31! The Bucs go on to win in OT 34-31! In just over 2 quarters, Tyree goes 17 of 21 for 245 yards and 3 TD's. Okay...that's promising. Maybe the season isn't done after all?

The Bucs go back to the NFC Championship, two years ago Glen Maule ... mauled us in the NFC Championship and the Pack went on to win the Super Bowl. This year...we're starting 6th rounder Tyree Harris. Glen Maule is still at the top of his game, and this is expected to be another beat down by the Pack...

But Tyree Harris goes 31 of 39 for 333 yards and 4 TD's (1 interception) and gets the go ahead score with 1:56 left on the clock to beat Glen Maule and the Packers 34-30! Super Bowl Bound!

Now I have a decision to make. Tyree Harris is rated around 42/51 overall. He's been nothing short of great, but Sebastian Stuart is healthy after being listed as OUT for 1 game. He is my 1st rounder and has been fairly consistent. He's overall rating is 49/59. I decide to give my future QB the start.

Sebastian Stuart goes 21 of 34 for 296 yards, 2 TD's and 1 INT. We lose to the Tennessee Titans 23-19.

So that's the end of the Tyree Harris right? Nope.

2029: The Bucs go 13-4 with Sebastian Stuart. The Bucs get a Bye week and Stuart is a world beater!

We beat up on the Atlanta Falcons 29-10 in the Divisionals behind a power run attack but shockingly, Sebastian Stuart put up pedestrian numbers (147 passing yards). After the game, our QB of the future is suddenly listed as OUT with "headaches". My QB of the future is not going to be able to compete in the playoffs for the second year in a row.

Enter Tyree Harris, that 6th round pick from Duke...

NFC Championship Game: Tyree Harris does well again, 21 of 34 for 246 yards and 2 TD's. The Bucs beat the Dallas Cowboys 23-10. Back to the Super Bowl for the second straight year! Stuart is still OUT, so we'll have to rely on our backup.

Super Bowl '29: Tampa Bay vs Pittsburgh. Tyree Hill has a game for the ages in a game for the ages. The Pittsburgh Steelers have a pure stud at QB though, a 4th year QB named Terrell Williams. He's rated 81/81. Williams goes 27 of 35 for 378 yards and 3 TD's. That was the second best QB statline of the game. As for the former 6th round pick from Duke? Tyree Harris goes 33 of 35 for 413 yards and 4 TDs including a TD to put the Bucs up 40-28 with 4:38 left to go in the game. Unfortunately, Williams won't quit and scores 2 TD's in waning minutes of the Big Game to give Pittsburgh a 43-40 win. (Tyree Harris was named the SB MVP, fwiw)

The Steeler will play in the next 2 super bowls in '30 and '31 with Terrell Williams at the helm (and they win one more to go 2-1 in a three-year span).

The Bucs will continue on with Sebastian Stuart, but the Bucs lose to the Seahawks in '30 despite a very good game by Stuart. In '31, the Bucs go 10-7 but fail to qualify for the playoffs with Stuart at the helm.

As for Tyree Harris? I cut him after 2031 and he was a free agent until a he was signed by the Cleveland Browns in 2033. He didn't start for them and was cut. He's a free agent in 2034, 8th year QB now. Anyway, I really wished I had the stones to just play the man. He was something else even though he never won the big one.

Regular Season Career: 22 Games Played, 8 Starts
Passing Yards: 2,570
TD: 21
INT: 8
QBR: 96.7

Playoff Career Games: 6 Games Played, 3 Starts
Passing Yards: 1,237
TD: 13
INT: 1
QBR: 136.9













*

NawlinsFan
12-21-2023, 06:51 AM
Appreciate this. I have seen similar results in a number of the universes I have created. With that I have a question. Has anyone had a serious time and challenge in creating a winning team? Personally I have found that I am wanting to start creating more of my own "house rules" to try and increase the difficulty; i.e I can't participate in the FA until late FA to keep me from grabbing some of the top players, when starting with an allocation draft I can only make my top 5 picks then let the AI amke the rest. I know this is the difference between FOF SP and FOF MP and the challenge of dealing with real owners but I want the challenge to almost be impossible and to make me have to really work hard to achieve glory.

Just my own observation. I am looking forward to leaning on what Ben has been working on by nerfing the rosters to reduce the ratings but I am beginning to fear that even with this it may still become "easy".