PDA

View Full Version : OT: Logic and Reason Camp


BucDawg40
06-18-2003, 05:00 PM
Why doesn't somebody create an organization that functions in a similar manner to Young Life, but instead of luring kids far away from home and forcing them to learn about Christ's Eternal Love (tm), they are taught critical thinking and problem-solving skills? It could even be disguised as a skiing or camping trip where there will be opportunities to interact with extremely confused members of the opposite sex! :eek:

Who wants to help me get this thing started?

Aylmar
06-18-2003, 05:02 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
It could even be disguised as a skiing or camping trip where there will be opportunities to interact with extremely confused members of the opposite sex! :eek:

Hmm...so what you're proposing is Vacation Bible School without the Bibles?

Easy Mac
06-18-2003, 05:04 PM
Its called computer camp, nerd

BucDawg40
06-18-2003, 05:11 PM
Originally posted by Aylmar
Hmm...so what you're proposing is Vacation Bible School without the Bibles?

Well, campers will be allowed to bring any reading material they wish. However, bible study will not be part of the agenda, unlike the Young Life excursions.

BucDawg40
06-18-2003, 05:18 PM
Originally posted by Easy Mac
Its called computer camp, nerd

I suppose I am a nerd -- an incredibly cool nerd, but a nerd nonetheless.

I've never heard of computer camp before, but I'll check it out.

I want this to be just like SkyDog's thing, with the notable exception that campers will be coerced into developing the ability to think with logic and reason, rather than being coerced into believing whole-heartedly in that which is (at best) of questionable validity.

Easy Mac
06-18-2003, 05:22 PM
I was kidding with the nerd thing (favorite class in college was logic).

But I don't think you can get kids to want to think like that. If you could maybe apply it to getting into girls pants, it may work.

Schmidty
06-18-2003, 05:30 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
I want this to be just like SkyDog's thing, with the notable exception that campers will be coerced into developing the ability to think with logic and reason, rather than being coerced into believing whole-heartedly in that which is (at best) of questionable validity.

From my experience, the people who are the most outspoken against religion (especially Christianity) are also the ones who feel the most empty inside. The louder people cry out against spirituality, the louder they seem to be crying out for help.

I'm not saying that this is your situation, but I wouldn't be suprised if it is.

Franklinnoble
06-18-2003, 05:37 PM
Originally posted by Schmidty
From my experience, the people who are the most outspoken against religion (especially Christianity) are also the ones who feel the most empty inside. The louder people cry out against spirituality, the louder they seem to be crying out for help.

I'm not saying that this is your situation, but I wouldn't be suprised if it is.

I think this is why the movie "The Matrix" has become such a cult phenom, typically amongst this crowd.

The Matrix is all about people wandering about on the internet, knowing for sure that there is something more to life... some man behind the curtain... some truth deep in the rabbit hole... and the movies have created a clever non-spiritual explaination to the innate feeling we have that there MUST be some greater meaning out there.

sabotai
06-18-2003, 05:44 PM
"But I don't think you can get kids to want to think like that. If you could maybe apply it to getting into girls pants, it may work."

Hmm..using logic to get into a woman's pants...done it. :)

Or at least, it's the only way I can explain how it was I was able to get her.

BucDawg40
06-18-2003, 06:08 PM
Originally posted by Schmidty
From my experience, the people who are the most outspoken against religion (especially Christianity) are also the ones who feel the most empty inside. The louder people cry out against spirituality, the louder they seem to be crying out for help.

I'm not saying that this is your situation, but I wouldn't be suprised if it is.


My bowels feel empty -- that's about it!

Franklinnoble
06-18-2003, 06:10 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
The only part of me that feels empty is my bowels.

Coffee enemas are the key to enlightenment.

Axxon
06-18-2003, 06:16 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
Why doesn't somebody create an organization that functions in a similar manner to Young Life, but instead of luring kids far away from home and forcing them to learn about Christ's Eternal Love (tm), they are taught critical thinking and problem-solving skills? It could even be disguised as a skiing or camping trip where there will be opportunities to interact with extremely confused members of the opposite sex! :eek:

Who wants to help me get this thing started?

Socrates tried to do this in Athens and it went poorly for him. I'll have to pass on this opportunity. ;)

thesloppy
06-18-2003, 07:35 PM
Originally posted by Schmidty
From my experience, the people who are the most outspoken against religion (especially Christianity) are also the ones who feel the most empty inside. The louder people cry out against spirituality, the louder they seem to be crying out for help.


Clearly, when someone says "I don't like hearing about pastries", they actually mean "I wish you would talk to me MUCH MORE about this bearclaw in a deeply personal, and condescending manner"

Blackadar
06-18-2003, 07:39 PM
Originally posted by thesloppy
Clearly, when someone says "I don't like hearing about pastries", they actually mean "I wish you would talk to me MUCH MORE about this bearclaw in a deeply personal, and condescending manner"

LMAO :)

wbonnell
06-18-2003, 07:52 PM
Originally posted by Franklinnoble
I think this is why the movie "The Matrix" has become such a cult phenom, typically amongst this crowd.

The Matrix is all about people wandering about on the internet, knowing for sure that there is something more to life... some man behind the curtain... some truth deep in the rabbit hole... and the movies have created a clever non-spiritual explaination to the innate feeling we have that there MUST be some greater meaning out there.

Unfortunately, it's pretty clear that no matter how hard one searches, one will never truly find the answer. Certainly one can and often does willingly submit to some religious cause, but it's not based on any reason- it just makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside. Immanueal Kant "proved" as much 200+ years ago. Whether or not you buy "philosophical mumbo jumbo", he makes some excellent points.

Anyway, you can find meaning in Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, whatever. I believe that the reason why ALL of these religions work is because they teach compassion.

mckerney
06-18-2003, 09:40 PM
Be careful BucDawg, your idea reeks of children learning common sense, and both the Trial Lawyers of America and the Illuminati are hell bent against common sense.

TroyF
06-18-2003, 11:09 PM
BucDawg,

I don't have a problem at all with you starting that up.

In fact, I wish you all the luck in the world with it.

I don't have anymore of a problem with you doing that than I do with Bible Camp. I think most (not all) religious people would say that most anything teaching kids self confidence and giving them the chance to meet new friends is a good thing.

It just so happens that the people with the commitment to start such ventures happen to be people of faith. I, for one, appreciate their efforts. I'd appreciate your effort to do the same.

TroyF

Tigercat
06-18-2003, 11:26 PM
Personally, I dont think kids should be forced into religious ideology, because that won't make a person spiritual. (which is way more important than being religious, if your religious and not spiritual you aren't even being a good follower of any religion i've studied)

Furthermore, critical thinking is a VERY important thing for one to learn to advance in ones education, but its not nessassarily going to makes ones life happier or more meaningfull.

I say you send them to a camp run by good people with no agenda, and let them have fun while they can. I was in Boy Scouts, and although I do not always agree with SOME of their agenda, I thought and still think it is very good at helping turn out very good human beings. But i suppose that sense even Boy Scouts has an agenda, a camp with an agenda isn't too bad as long as its run by people that want their participating kids to keep an open mind about the world and become good people.

TroyF
06-18-2003, 11:39 PM
We all have agendas. Even a normal, public school has an agenda. I disagree with many of their agendas if truth be known. (what the hell is happening with gym class? Don't these people realize taking care of your body is every bit as important as taking care of the mind?)

Sorry, different rant there. Still, every organization or group of people will have an agenda. Some type of criteria they want to teach the kids.

In BucDawgs case, his agenda would be to teach them practical skills and logic. Nothing wrong with that.

Which one would I send my kid to? A Bible Camp or a Logic Camp? Given the choice, I'd love to send the kid to both. I'm not nearly as religious as some people on this board, yet I fail to see the harm in MOST religious activities either. (please, feel free to tell me about the far right wing if you like. I can tell you just as many stories about the far left and their children)

All things being equal, I can think of MANY worse activities a teen or child can be doing in the summer than Bible Camp.

TroyF

sabotai
06-19-2003, 02:01 AM
"It just so happens that the people with the commitment to start such ventures happen to be people of faith."

And the people with the tax-exempt income that is used is used to start these ventures happen to be from people of faith. :D

Samdari
06-19-2003, 07:01 AM
SkyDog, was your recent trip voluntary for the kids, or herded onto the bus at gunpoint?

Where did we get 'coerced'?

And remember, I am in the non-religious crowd, but that word seems out of line.

TroyF
06-19-2003, 09:42 AM
Sab,

No doubt about it. Still, there are other organizations that do have cheap camps for kids with other agendas than preaching about God.

In fact, a quick search on google came up with this link:

http://www.atheistalliance.org/internet/net_young.html

There are arts camps, athletic camps, math camps, reading camps. . . if you are a parent or teen, you have many options.

Samdari,

Bingo. I agree. :)

TroyF

Fritz
06-19-2003, 09:51 AM
Originally posted by Samdari
SkyDog, was your recent trip voluntary for the kids, or herded onto the bus at gunpoint?

Where did we get 'coerced'?

And remember, I am in the non-religious crowd, but that word seems out of line.

Skydog did tell them that they would go to hell if they missed camp. I saw the flyer.

TroyF
06-19-2003, 09:55 AM
Originally posted by Fritz
Skydog did tell them that they would go to hell if they missed camp. I saw the flyer.

Geez Skydog, why'd you have to go and do that? :)

TroyF

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 10:28 AM
Heh. I had missed this thread. First off, I'll tell you right-off that Young Life is the LEAST coercive of any evangelical youth ministry I know of, but you don't have to take my word for it. BucDawg, we have VERY nice adult facilities at nearly every one of our camps. Adults can come and check out exactly what we do, have a fun time, eat GREAT food and experience first-hand what kids experience. Before you criticize what you don't know any more, I'd be willing to pay the cost of you spending a week at one of our camps. All you'd need to take care of is your transportation. "Camp" is a misnomer really. All of our properties are of resort quality, with great facilities and outstanding food. It would be one of the best vacations you'd ever take. Here are some pictures from a couple of the Adult Guest Lodges:
http://www.younglife.org/sharptopcove/photo_5.jpg http://www.younglife.org/crookedcreek/photo_12_small.jpg

Samdari, to respond to your rhetorical question, of course the trip is the most voluntary trip kids will ever take. We have no "members" of any kind. Any kids are welcome to come, even those who have never been to a weekly meeting ever. Kids who don't go to camp are still welcome to participate in anything we do. There is no "penalty" in the group, either implied or real, for not going, nor is there a "reward" (other than a fantastic time) for going. Do we "sell" camp? Sure, to kids we know, but that isn't even a hard sell at all. I'll tell you EXACTLY what we did for camp sell this year:
1. We showed the camp video at no more than three of our weekly meetings all school year.
2. We sent one letter in the mail in early December with a sign-up flier and the offer of an "early-bird" discount for anyone who signed up by January 1st.
3. I put a short blurb about it in around a third of the weekly e-mails I send to kids reminding them of the upcoming weekly meeting. It always read something like this: "There's still room left on the Castaway trip this summer. There's a list of who is already signed up, and a link to a sign-up flier at www.younglifenorthdekalb.com/castaway.htm."
4. As mentioned above, I posted a list of who was signed up on our web site.
5. At each of our weekly meetings, there's a flier available sitting on a table somewhere. Sometimes we remind kids that it is there. Sometimes we don't.

By FAR, the best way to get teenagers to camp is when other kids talk about what a fantastic experience it is. Kids talk about it all year long, wear the trip t-shirts to school, and it builds a snowball effect. The fact of the matter is that Young Life camps have a reputation, even among some of the wildest party kids in the school, as being one of the most fun and meaningful experiences they'll ever have. I don't say that to brag. (I'm not exactly what you'd call a "company guy." :p) I am just stating what is a known fact in our community. If anything, we may have gotten a little lazy in my Area with regards to selling camp. It has become so easy to get kids to go, that basically we just mail out the flier, do a few reminder e-mails, and end up taking a pretty big group of kids.

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 10:36 AM
Originally posted by Fritz
Skydog did tell them that they would go to hell if they missed camp. I saw the flyer. LOL. Here is the flier (http://www.younglifenorthdekalb.com/castaway2k3.doc)

Anrhydeddu
06-19-2003, 11:01 AM
I think some folks are jealous that a large group of teens and adults can do things that are life-changing and making a positive difference in the lives around them. This goes against the worldly trend where sinful acts and behaviors are glorified and encouraged. (do I get another brownie point, Ben? :) )

TroyF
06-19-2003, 11:09 AM
Originally posted by SkyDog
LOL. Here is the flier (http://www.younglifenorthdekalb.com/castaway2k3.doc)

You just put a subliminal message in the pictures. I think it's something in the trees calling out: come here or BURN.

That's pretty bad of you to stoop to dirty tricks like that. . .

TroyF

sabotai
06-19-2003, 12:47 PM
" I think some folks are jealous that a large group of teens and adults can do things that are life-changing and making a positive difference in the lives around them. This goes against the worldly trend where sinful acts and behaviors are glorified and encouraged. "

Yep...everyone is jealous of the Christians...

:rolleyes:

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 02:50 PM
SkyDog,

Thanks for your kind offer to pay for me to experience a week at one of these excursions. However, I'll have to politely decline the offer. I have not taken a week off for vacation or otherwise as an adult, and I don't intend to unless I am too ill or injured to continue my daily routine. Besides, I don't think I could handle 1000 teen voices telling me that I'm going to hell and asking me why I "hate" Jesus -- the two most common responses from teen Jesus fans when they meet a non-Jesus fan.

I am pretty sure that you are sincere in your efforts and you are working from the kindness of your heart. But in my view, the world (and Humanity) would be better served if you put an equal or greater amount of effort into teaching these kids critical thinking and problem-solving skills. That is my point.

scooper
06-19-2003, 02:54 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
SkyDog,



I am pretty sure that you are sincere in your efforts and you are working from the kindness of your heart. But in my view, the world (and Humanity) would be better served if you put an equal or greater amount of effort into teaching these kids critical thinking and problem-solving skills. That is my point.

I can't speak for other areas, but the students in religious schools around here continually score higher on tests such as SAT/ACT, test that require "thinking and problem-solving skills." To insinuate that because a kid is a Christian means they can't think critically is assinine. As stated above, those kids didn't go to the camp at gunpoint. They chose to do so.

scooper
06-19-2003, 02:55 PM
dola:

To add: I'm not insinuating that children at local Christian schools score higher because they are Christians. My point is that it is possible to teach both and do it well.

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 02:56 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
Besides, I don't think I could handle 1000 teen voices telling me that I'm going to hell and asking me why I "hate" Jesus -- the two most common responses from teen Jesus fans when they meet a non-Jesus fan.You definitely don't get Young Life then. The HUGE majority of the kids involved in our ministry do NOT have any form of relationship with Christ. Of the 55 kids that were from my Area on the Minnesota trip, there were less than 10 with anything resembling strong faith.

scooper
06-19-2003, 03:00 PM
Not to mention, 1000 voices damning you to hell and judging you is not a true act of Christianity. I think people like yourself are often jaded by the acts of some of the more zealous.

I prefer to treat people well in the name of Christianity and hope they get the point from that.

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:03 PM
Originally posted by SkyDog
5. At each of our weekly meetings, there's a flier available sitting on a table somewhere. Sometimes we remind kids that it is there. Sometimes we don't.


I remember fliers like these. Every week (on a certain day of the week which I can't recall) when I went to lunch (class of '94) there was one of them in the center of each circular cafeteria table. Each flier had a "Top 10" list containing ten names selected out of those who had attended the weekly meeting.

I always wondered, "Top 10 of what?" Top 10 richest? Top 10 most hypocritical? Top 10 most pretentious? Do you publish a Top 10, SkyDog? If so, why -- and what does it mean?

This other group of kids (whom I barely knew) began laying out flyers before lunch promoting something called "Gordo Life" -- yes, it is a dumb name, and no I don't know what it meant. Anyway, they had their own ambiguous Top 10 list. There was nothing vulgar or inappropriate on these flyers from what I can remember, but after three weeks the flyers disappeared. Discipline was handed out to those responsible, but the Young Life flyers remained. Why did a public school give such preferential treatment to a Jesus fan club?

Easy Mac
06-19-2003, 03:05 PM
I'd say most of those kids don't care about God and just want to go so they can hook up with random people. That's why I went on Youth Group tirps... always go for the Catholic girls fellas, especially if they have the uniform.

JonInMiddleGA
06-19-2003, 03:08 PM
Am I the only person wondering why the heck this trolling-in-faint-costume thread has lasted this long?

TroyF
06-19-2003, 03:09 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
SkyDog,

Thanks for your kind offer to pay for me to experience a week at one of these excursions. However, I'll have to politely decline the offer. I have not taken a week off for vacation or otherwise as an adult, and I don't intend to unless I am too ill or injured to continue my daily routine. Besides, I don't think I could handle 1000 teen voices telling me that I'm going to hell and asking me why I "hate" Jesus -- the two most common responses from teen Jesus fans when they meet a non-Jesus fan.

I am pretty sure that you are sincere in your efforts and you are working from the kindness of your heart. But in my view, the world (and Humanity) would be better served if you put an equal or greater amount of effort into teaching these kids critical thinking and problem-solving skills. That is my point.

This is one of the most stereotypical posts I've read in a long time.

For your information, I was at one of those camps. It was actually a basketball camp. I joined up with the church ONLY because of that camp. I didn't join them in their prayers, nor was I ever forced to. Not a single person told me I was going to hell or asked me why I "hated Jesus"

The only rules I had to follow was to watch my language and make my bed up in the morning. That was it.

It's a shame so much stereotyping is done by non-religious people. It's every bit as destructive as the Christians who scream hell and damnation every other breath. Stop paying attention to ONLY the far right wing groups and look at the majority before you speak. (hint: the majority of teen Christians do not ask you why you hate Jesus or tell you you're going to hell, they just happen to be the most outspoken ones)

Notice how in this post I'm not telling you that I'm "praying for your soul" or "hoping you let Jesus into your heart"? I'm still undecided on what my spirituality is, I've never said those words to anyone. I just think it's sad how you've taken an entire group of people and slapped a label on them. Truly sad.

TroyF

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:09 PM
Originally posted by SkyDog
You definitely don't get Young Life then. The HUGE majority of the kids involved in our ministry do NOT have any form of relationship with Christ. Of the 55 kids that were from my Area on the Minnesota trip, there were less than 10 with anything resembling strong faith.


http://www.younglife.org/

From the front page:

"Young Life" is the name of our organization, and it's also what we call our outreach to high school-aged kids. We have named our middle school and junior high ministry "Wyldlife" to differentiate between the two age groups and their varying developmental stages and maturity levels. Both ministries stay true to the time-tested practices we've been using for more than 60 years: going where kids are, loving them unconditionally, earning the right to be heard and communicating God's love in terms kids can understand.

The kids may not yet have a relationship with Jesus, but it is a ministry with the goal of creating more Jesus fans. Where have I misread it?

scooper
06-19-2003, 03:11 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40



The kids may not yet have a relationship with Jesus, but it is a ministry with the goal of creating more Jesus fans. Where have I misread it?

Yes, and?

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:14 PM
Originally posted by scooper
Yes, and?

SkyDog said I didn't "get" Young Life.

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 03:16 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
I remember fliers like these. Every week (on a certain day of the week which I can't recall) when I went to lunch (class of '94) there was one of them in the center of each circular cafeteria table. Each flier had a "Top 10" list containing ten names selected out of those who had attended the weekly meeting.

I always wondered, "Top 10 of what?" Top 10 richest? Top 10 most hypocritical? Top 10 most pretentious? Do you publish a Top 10, SkyDog? If so, why -- and what does it mean?

This other group of kids (whom I barely knew) began laying out flyers before lunch promoting something called "Gordo Life" -- yes, it is a dumb name, and no I don't know what it meant. Anyway, they had their own ambiguous Top 10 list. There was nothing vulgar or inappropriate on these flyers from what I can remember, but after three weeks the flyers disappeared. Discipline was handed out to those responsible, but the Young Life flyers remained. Why did a public school give such preferential treatment to a Jesus fan club? Well, first off, you're missing what I was saying. The camp sign-up fliers that I speak of are at the location of our meetings, not at the school at all. We meet in kids' homes, or in a "neutral" site such as a subdivision's clubhouse. Somewhere at the location of our meetings, there is registration info available for any trips coming up. That is what I said earlier, and it is very different from what you're speaking of.

That being said, the fact of the matter is that even Government School officials recognize that positive adult role models are always beneficial to teenagers. Young Life is an organization that does NOT overstep its bounds. Our style is to build relationships, love kids right where they are, not to condemn them for the things they do. We don't evangelize on campus, pass out tracts or do anything that would get the school in trouble. Some schools (perhaps yours, and that is why they were allowed to put fliers in the school) even have an official faculty sponsor, and guess what? That is 100% legal.

No, I don't publish any sort of top ten list. My guess is that they just drew names out of a hat from those that had attended the previous week. Kids love to see their name in print, and doing something like that helps them feel valued and noticed. If I were to do it, that would be why I'd do it. However, even though I have permission to put fliers in the school, I rarely do it. Fliers don't get kids to the club meeting, to camp, or to Christ. Relationships do.

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:16 PM
Originally posted by JonInMiddleGA
Am I the only person wondering why the heck this trolling-in-faint-costume thread has lasted this long?


I wasn't really trolling. However, I did sort of half-expect to get banned for daring to challenge the majority. Kudos to SkyDog for letting it continue!

scooper
06-19-2003, 03:17 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
SkyDog said I didn't "get" Young Life.

Nothing about the above passage indicates "1000 teen voices telling me that I'm going to hell and asking me why I "hate" Jesus -- the two most common responses from teen Jesus fans when they meet a non-Jesus fan."

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 03:20 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
SkyDog said I didn't "get" Young Life. You spoke of picturing 1,000 kids who are "pro-Jesus" singling you out at camp. Not only would such behavior be utterly discouraged, the fact is that there is NO POSSIBLE WAY that anyone at a YL camp could ever be singled out for being "anti-Jesus," because the fact is that there are a LOT more kids at camp who are ambivalent or "anti-Jesus" than the very small handful who are "pro-Jesus." If you can envision the scenario you brought up happening at a Young Life camp, you REALLY don't get Young Life, believe me.

scooper
06-19-2003, 03:20 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
I wasn't really trolling. However, I did sort of half-expect to get banned for daring to challenge the majority. Kudos to SkyDog for letting it continue!

I'll agree, you're doing nothing ban-able here. Nobody has been banned for having a difference of opinion.

Anrhydeddu
06-19-2003, 03:23 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
I wasn't really trolling. However, I did sort of half-expect to get banned for daring to challenge the majority. Kudos to SkyDog for letting it continue!

If that was the case, I would have been banned years ago.

Samdari
06-19-2003, 03:26 PM
You know BucDawg, having strong faith (and I am NOT in this camp) does not preclude one from using and applying logic in other facets of life. I know many math/logic types who are religious. They can take religious matters on faith and yet know that when they throw their pencil at the ceiling (a favorite activity of us engineers/scientists) a force called gravity pulls it back towards them, not the hand of {insert name of preferred diety here}. Everything you post in this thread presumes that believing in {insert name of preferred diety here} requires one to completely abandon all common sense - this is simply untrue. Many people I know who pray also work and make their mortgage payments rather than expect prayer to provide them with shelter and resources to buy food. They could probably be described as displaying faith AND applying logic to the problem of providing for their basic needs.

Unless, of course, you think the government should provide those needs. DOH! That's a different thread.

sabotai
06-19-2003, 03:27 PM
"1000 voices damning you to hell and judging you is not a true act of Christianity."

Unfortunatly, it is the act of many who call themselves Christians. Maybe not the majority, but definatly the majority of the one's that are outspoken. (As TroyF said)

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:28 PM
Originally posted by SkyDog
You spoke of picturing 1,000 kids who are "pro-Jesus" singling you out at camp. Not only would such behavior be utterly discouraged, the fact is that there is NO POSSIBLE WAY that anyone at a YL camp could ever be singled out for being "anti-Jesus," because the fact is that there are a LOT more kids at camp who are ambivalent or "anti-Jesus" than the very small handful who are "pro-Jesus." If you can envision the scenario you brought up happening at a Young Life camp, you REALLY don't get Young Life, believe me.

Fair enough. If this behavior does not happen and is actively discouraged, then I guess I don't get YL. Not the chapter you are associated with at least. Things were different around here.

Anrhydeddu
06-19-2003, 03:29 PM
Great scientists who believed the Bible
by Dr. Henry M. Morris

"I find it as difficult to understand a scientist who does not acknowledge the presence of a superior rationality behind the existence of the universe as it is to comprehend a theologian who would deny the advances of science."
- Wernher von Braun

George Washington Carver (1864-1943) was an agricultural chemist considered the world's top authority on peanuts, sweet potatoes and their products. Born a slave in the southern part of the United States, he worked his way through college in the north. He returned to the south, desiring to devote his life to improving the quality of southern farm lands and the economic prosperity of his people. As a faculty member at the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama, he turned down a number of much more lucrative offers, as the fame of his genius as an agricultural chemist spread. He developed more than 300 products from the peanut and more than 115 from the sweet potato, which were largely responsible for saving the southern part of the United States from economic disaster.

Carver was also a sincere and humble Christian, never hesitating to confess his faith in the God of the Bible and attributing all his success and ability to God. In 1939, Carver, who was black, was awarded the Roosevelt medal, with the following citation: "To a scientist humbly seeking the guidance of God and a liberator to men of the white race as well as the black."

Charles Stine (1882-1954) was for many years director of research for the E.I. duPont Company. As an organic chemist with many degrees and honors, he developed many new products and patents for his company. He was a man of top eminence in his field and a believing Christian. He frequently spoke to scientific and university audiences concerning his faith and authored the book, A Chemist and His Bible.

After a stirring exposition of the Gospel and an appeal to accept Jesus, Dr. Stine gave this testimony of the Creator: "The world about us, far more intricate than any watch, filled with checks and balances of a hundred varieties, marvelous beyond even the imagination of the most skilled scientific investigator, this beautiful and intricate creation, bears the signature of its Creator, graven in its work."

Wernher von Braun (1912-1977) was one of the world's top space scientists. With a Ph.D. from the University of Berlin in Germany, von Braun was a leading German rocket engineer, developing the famed V-2 rocket during World War II. He migrated to the United States in 1945, becoming a naturalized U.S. citizen in 1955. He directed U.S. guided missile development for several years and eventually became director of NASA.

Dr. von Braun was a Christian active in his church. In the foreword to an anthology on creation and design in nature, he gave this testimony: "Manned space flight is an amazing achievement, but it has opened for mankind thus far only a tiny door for viewing the awesome reaches of space. An outlook through this peephole at the vast mysteries of the universe should only confirm our belief in the certainty of its Creator. I find it as difficult to understand a scientist who does not acknowledge the presence of a superior rationality behind the existence of the universe as it is to comprehend a theologian who would deny the advances of science."

From Men of Science, Men of God: Great Scientists Who Believed the Bible, by Henry M. Morris, Master Books, ©1982, 1988. Used with permission.

scooper
06-19-2003, 03:30 PM
Originally posted by sabotai
"1000 voices damning you to hell and judging you is not a true act of Christianity."

Unfortunatly, it is the act of many who call themselves Christians. Maybe not the majority, but definatly the majority of the one's that are outspoken. (As TroyF said)

That's why I said I try to speak through actions. It's not quite as loud, but if you look around, you'll see a lot of good deeds being done in the name of Christ. It's just that those that really mean it don't need to put others down at the same time.

I would say the vast majority of Christians aren't in that "screaming teen" group.

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 03:32 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
Fair enough. If this behavior does not happen and is actively discouraged, then I guess I don't get YL. Not the chapter you are associated with at least. Things were different around here. If things were different around there, I'd go as far as to say that some staff person(s) or leader(s) weren't staying remotely true to the mission of Young Life. I've been in four different communities doing this, am now considered "Senior Staff", and I've never seen or heard of anything like that occurring. If the leaders were engaging in that sort of behavior, and/or encouraging students to do so, then they're waaaaaaayyyyyyyy off base.

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:36 PM
Originally posted by Samdari
Many people I know who pray also work and make their mortgage payments rather than expect prayer to provide them with shelter and resources to buy food. They could probably be described as displaying faith AND applying logic to the problem of providing for their basic needs.


I'm reminded of a remark made by the President just a few short weeks after he "choked on a pretzel" and busted his head open. He said: "I truly believe that, above all else, the greatest thing you can do for a person is to pray for them."

So Georgie, next time you are "choking" on a pretzel I'll drop to my knees and pray instead of giving you the Heimlich. Let's see how that turns out, shall we?

BucDawg40
06-19-2003, 03:41 PM
Originally posted by SkyDog
If the leaders were engaging in that sort of behavior, and/or encouraging students to do so, then they're waaaaaaayyyyyyyy off base.

Does YL keep a database of leaders/years/locations where I could find the names of these people?

TroyF
06-19-2003, 03:46 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
I'm reminded of a remark made by the President just a few short weeks after he "choked on a pretzel" and busted his head open. He said: "I truly believe that, above all else, the greatest thing you can do for a person is to pray for them."

So Georgie, next time you are "choking" on a pretzel I'll drop to my knees and pray instead of giving you the Heimlich. Let's see how that turns out, shall we?

Yeah, I'm sure that's exactly what he meant. :rolleyes:

TroyF

Ben E Lou
06-19-2003, 03:52 PM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
Does YL keep a database of leaders/years/locations where I could find the names of these people? No, not on a national basis. If you really want to find out who they were though, tell me what city you were in, and I can PM you with the office number in that town. Such records are typically kept locally, or at least known by someone in the community, particularly if you're talking about just 9 years ago. There's likely SOMEONE still there who knows who was involved at your high school in '94.

Ben E Lou
06-23-2003, 07:58 AM
Heh. Here ya go BucDawg. Maybe this teen camp is better? ;)

Another camp for teens (http://www.cnsnews.com/ViewCulture.asp?Page=%5CCulture%5Carchive%5C200306%5CCUL20030620b.html)

BucDawg40
06-23-2003, 09:58 AM
Originally posted by SkyDog
Heh. Here ya go BucDawg. Maybe this teen camp is better? ;)

Another camp for teens (http://www.cnsnews.com/ViewCulture.asp?Page=%5CCulture%5Carchive%5C200306%5CCUL20030620b.html)


It is "better" -- if only in the sense that it is not yet as large a threat to mankind as religious indoctrination camps are. When teen nudist camps gain a large following and the members start to persecute non-members, I might start to get worried. For now, there are much bigger fish to fry.

Ben E Lou
06-23-2003, 10:55 AM
Originally posted by BucDawg40
It is "better" -- if only in the sense that it is not yet as large a threat to mankind as religious indoctrination camps are. Agreed.

The problem you need to reconcile with your argument is that there is no religion taught at YL camps. In fact, we speak out AGAINST religion. :)