PDA

View Full Version : Mom Picks Up Slack For Shoddy Investigation


Ksyrup
03-02-2004, 07:10 AM
Mom finds kidnapped daughter six years later

Philadelphia officials had ruled infant died in 1997 fire



PHILADELPHIA, Pennsylvania (CNN) --A fire that authorities six years ago thought killed a 10-day-old girl was a ruse to kidnap the infant, Philadelphia police said Monday.

The baby, Delimar Vera, was sleeping in the upstairs front bedroom when a fire broke out at her family's two-story row house in north Philadelphia on December 15, 1997.

Luz Cuevas, her mother, could not find Delimar when she ran into the room. She eventually ran out of the house, overcome by smoke and burned on her face. Her two other children also survived, police said.

Remains of the infant's body were never found, and police concluded they had been incinerated in the flames.

The official cause of the fire was listed as an overheated extension cord attached to a space heater.

But Cuevas never fully believed her daughter died in the fire.

In January, she attended a birthday party for the child of an acquaintance and was struck by the resemblance of a 6-year-old girl to herself and her other children.

Telling the girl she had bubble gum in her hair, Cuevas was able to take strands of her hair in hopes a DNA test would prove she was right, according to Philadelphia police Lt. Michael Boyle of the special victims unit.

A state legislator helped put Cuevas in touch with police, who launched an investigation and had DNA tests performed that confirmed the girl is her daughter.

Police say Carolyn Correa, 41, a resident of Willingboro, New Jersey, a Philadelphia suburb, started the fire and kidnapped Delimar, whom she passed off as her own daughter.

Before the results of the DNA tests were in, officials placed the child in New Jersey state custody.

When police returned to Correa's home to confront her about the DNA results, she had fled, leaving behind three other children.

She remains a fugitive from multiple arrest warrants on charges that include arson, kidnapping and concealing the whereabouts of a child.

Lt. Thomas McDevitt of the special victims unit said Cuevas told police that Correa was a distant friend of a cousin of the baby's father, from whom she has separated.

Cuevas had met Correa the day before the fire, McDevitt said. Correa returned December 15, saying she had left her purse upstairs, he said.

The fire was discovered shortly after Correa left the house, McDevitt said.

It has not yet been determined when Delimar will be reunited with Cuevas.

Boyle said that when police told Cuevas about the DNA test results Saturday night she was "overwhelmed with joy."

"She sat there and shook and cried and kept saying, 'Thank you, thank you, thank you,'" Boyle said.

Police say they cannot fully explain why Delimar was declared killed.

Officers at the time found bone fragments they thought were the baby's remains, but tests later showed them to be nonhuman, McDevitt said.

When investigators returned to the scene, firemen had already dumped several hundred pounds of debris from the gutted bedroom in the back yard, McDevitt said.

The officers sifted through the debris but found mostly dry wool particles, which they were told resemble human ashes, but only those burned at 1,000 degrees for an hour or longer, McDevitt said.

The fire, which was confined to the bedroom, lasted only about 15 minutes and was nowhere near 1,000 degrees, McDevitt said.

McDevitt admitted this scenario is an explanation only "up to a point." On the other hand, officers had no reason to suspect arson or a kidnapping, he said.

CNN's Susan Chun and CNN.com's David Osier contributed to this story.

Chief Rum
03-02-2004, 07:27 AM
Looks like these cops are graduates of the Eagle County Police Academy.

CR

EagleFan
03-02-2004, 11:50 PM
The police screwed this up a couple times. First was when they failed to investigate it properly and the last time was allowing that woman to get away.

Why would they take the child before results were announced instead of getting the evidence first and then showing up to arrest her and take the daughter. Or even if they did, shouldn't they have surveillance on the woman or something, especially if they found that she had three other kids and as I've heard today she was also wanted for burning down a doctors office that she worked for, apparantly to cover up for checks that she was stealing.

Tekneek
03-02-2004, 11:53 PM
No surprises here. Cops drop the ball on investigations every single day in this country. When push comes to shove, most *seem* to take the easy way out. It explains why they didn't bother to catch the drunk driver who hit my wife and I, despite providing a description of him, the vehicle, and the license plate, but they are out on Sunday mornings catching speeders on a highway where traffic is so light they pose no threat to anyone but themselves. It's hard to get out there and catch that guy who hit you, but the effort is minimal to setup speed traps and a whole lot more fun.

sabotai
03-03-2004, 12:22 AM
This story has been all over the news where I live. Last I heard they got the woman who kidnapped the child.

Tekneek
03-03-2004, 12:40 AM
The difference between a child who is 10 days old and 6 years old is just incredible. The problems here have only just begun. The only mom this kid has ever known has been arrested and this girl will be placed with strangers.

FBPro
03-03-2004, 05:18 AM
The difference between a child who is 10 days old and 6 years old is just incredible. The problems here have only just begun. The only mom this kid has ever known has been arrested and this girl will be placed with strangers.


True, I hope that this turns out for the good and that the girl adjusts to her biological mom and family.

Ksyrup
03-08-2004, 12:53 PM
Good to see a happy start to a hopeful happy ending. And they might even get some "Lifetime Movie of the Week" money out of the deal as well.


(CNN) -- A long-lost daughter will be returned to her Philadelphia mother by the end of the day Monday, the mother's attorney said.

The mother, Luz Cuevas, had been told the child died in a fire six years ago in Pennsylvania, but she discovered the girl allegedly had been kidnapped by a family acquaintance and was living not far away.
The child, named Delimar, was 10 days old when her mother last saw her in December 1997. Cuevas saw the girl, now 6, at a birthday party in January and was struck by the child's resemblance to her and her other children. A DNA test proved Cuevas was the child's mother.

Carolyn Correa has been arrested. She faces charges of kidnapping the child and setting a fire to cover her tracks. Officials at the time ruled the newborn had died in the fire.

Cuevas' attorney, Anthony Cianfrani, said a court order would reunite the child with her biological mother by the end of Monday after three short-term visits between the two last week were declared successful.

The girl is already calling Cuevas "Mommy," Cianfrani said, and social workers are pleased with how quickly she has adjusted to the news. Cuevas voluntarily will submit to ongoing visits with counselors and social workers, Cianfrani said.

A New Jersey judge granted custody to Cuevas, but the final transfer was not expected until the judge had set up safeguards for the child's welfare, said state Rep. Angel Cruz of Philadelphia, a lawmaker who helped bring about a reunion. Cianfrani said that was expected Monday. Meanwhile, the child has been in foster care.

Cuevas said Delimar became hysterical when told that Correa was not her mother but has since calmed down and is beginning to adjust to the news.

Cruz and Cianfrani said a communication barrier between the mother and child -- Cuevas speaks little English and her daughter speaks no Spanish -- will be an easy one to overcome.
"The mother speaks enough English to communicate to the child," Cianfrani said. "The mother can talk about foods and colors, and how do you feel, and that sort of thing, so the mother can communicate, but she understands that she needs to learn English so she could communicate better with her child."

Cruz said Delimar also will learn Spanish.

Delimar's biological father also has come forward, hired an attorney and asked to be included in the process, but Cianfrani said his role would be "fairly limited for the near future."

The mother has hired a media attorney to deal with the multiple TV movie offers she has received.



On a lighter note, I didn't know there was such a criminal offense as "setting a fire to cover your tracks."