FOFC MLB Hall of Fame

[Easy Mac]

Just a collection of the current MLB players who the FOFC will make the Hall of Fame (culled from the HOF Discussion threads). Amendment to the rules: A player must receive 75% of the votes to make it, just like the real world:

Arizona Diamondbacks: None (closest: Luis Gonzalez 13%)
Atlanta Braves: None (closest: John Smoltz 68%)
Baltimore Orioles: Sammy Sosa (91%), Rafael Palmeiro (88%)
Boston Red Sox: Manny Ramirez (88%)
Chicago Cubs: Greg Maddux (100%)

[Barkeep49]

Isn't this a faulty way of tabulating? Shouldn't all of the options where that person is mentioned be added together and then some number, perhaps 50 or 66 percent, be the cutoff off point?

[MikeVic]

Isn't this a faulty way of tabulating? Shouldn't all of the options where that person is mentioned be added together and then some number, perhaps 50 or 66 percent, be the cutoff off point?

That's what I'm thinking too. So, if Schilling by himself gets 20% of the votes, Schilling with another gets 35%, and Schilling with 2 others gets 10%... is his official percentage 20% or 65%?

[Balldog]

Can you do polls with multiple selections?