View Full Version : Werewolf XVI: Time Traveler (MAFIA WIN)
Raiders Army
10-12-2005, 07:57 PM
Back for a last minute look before Lost comes on.
Raiders Army
10-12-2005, 07:58 PM
Dola, guess nothing new...
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 08:07 PM
Yo.
word
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 08:09 PM
Double yo.
Is that related to the double dola?
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 08:18 PM
mint gum
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 08:34 PM
Can we get the night action people to hurry it up?!
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 08:39 PM
sundvls did say he had to reconfirm all night actions after the ardent switch, so despite getting night actions in already they all have to re-send them...so even if someone was here all day, if they left at 4:59 for the night we could be waiting a long time
sundvls did say he had to reconfirm all night actions after the ardent switch, so despite getting night actions in already they all have to re-send them...so even if someone was here all day, if they left at 4:59 for the night we could be waiting a long timeWait, I'm back in?
I have made an executive decision to replace an inactive player. Due to my error ardent had no chance of coming back from a lynch on day 1 as there was no night 0. So he has taken over for ntndeacon. I have sent those affected by this decision a PM so that they may change their night actions if they so choose. Once I get a yes or no PM then we'll continue as I have all the night actions up to this point.
Thanks.WOOHOO!!!!!
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 08:42 PM
I have made an executive decision to replace an inactive player. Due to my error ardent had no chance of coming back from a lynch on day 1 as there was no night 0. So he has taken over for ntndeacon. I have sent those affected by this decision a PM so that they may change their night actions if they so choose. Once I get a yes or no PM then we'll continue as I have all the night actions up to this point.
Thanks.
THIS MEANS 2 THINGS (to me):
1.Either ardent was mafia, and so was ntdeacon
2.Ardent was a villager and ntdeacon was a good guy
A third option is ardent was a normal villager and ntdeacon was a wolf, but im not sure sun would be so quick to send ardent into a wolf role...im leaning to option 2, which makes me think were getting into the danger zone of when we lose
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 08:44 PM
Wait, I'm back in?
WOOHOO!!!!!
Now im lost...he said he sent you a PM....so now im flat out confused on how you wouldnt know...
Unless you were both mafia and you already knew deacons role and didnt need a new PM to tell it to you...otherwise you would need a new PM to know deacons role
Now im lost...he said he sent you a PM....so now im flat out confused on how you wouldnt know...
Unless you were both mafia and you already knew deacons role and didnt need a new PM to tell it to you...otherwise you would need a new PM to know deacons role
Nope, got a PM telling me he was going to, I wasn't aware he had actually did it. Hence, the double posts. I was just biding time till he did it.
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 08:50 PM
Nope, got a PM telling me he was going to, I wasn't aware he had actually did it. Hence, the double posts. I was just biding time till he did it.
Fair enough...im sooo lost right now, i keep switching who i think is bad with every post...and im trying not to get tunnel vision which always gets good guys killed
I'm just happy to be back in. By the way, if anyone's curious, my wife's surgery went well. They found she broke her fibula as well, but it's all good. She'll be back tripping over things in 6 weeks time from what I hear.
SnDvls
10-12-2005, 09:59 PM
I suggest you read post #37 first, I'm sending PM's now
Night 2
The night passes and it’s eerily quiet. No gun shots, no screaming. Then you hear the same two shots you heard on night one. What is going on in this town? Once morning comes you all gather in the town square. Just like last night there are two of you missing, digamma and Raiders Army. You now are searching around trying to figure what is happening to all the villagers when you run across Raiders Army’s body, he’s been gagged and tortured with a note attached to his body by a knife. Looks like the serial killer got him last night. Now it time to find digamma, he just like Blade from the night before, looks like he was caught coming back home, the mafia got him.
Day 3 has begun.
SnDvls
10-12-2005, 10:00 PM
there are now 5 of you alive
need 3 to lynch
3 to end day
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:03 PM
Well this sucks, i got killed on night one now?? I hate life...so much for do gooding
Barkeep49
10-12-2005, 10:04 PM
Well ok then. Thanks to whoever helped me survive my near death experience.
It seems to me from SnDvls posts that the mafia don't have complete control over who they kill. I'm not sure where that leaves the villagers. I think we're in pretty dire straights here and don't have a lot to go on.
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:06 PM
...
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 10:07 PM
Well ok then. Thanks to whoever helped me survive my near death experience.
It seems to me from SnDvls posts that the mafia don't have complete control over who they kill. I'm not sure where that leaves the villagers. I think we're in pretty dire straights here and don't have a lot to go on.
I agree Barkeep. With 6 left we know we have to at least be up 4-2 or else the game would be over since it would be 3-3. Could we actually be up 5-1?!!http://dynamic.gamespy.com/%7Efof/forums/images/smilies/eek.gif
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 10:23 PM
Am I missing someone but looking at post 37 I see only 5 alive:
Passacagilia
pennywisesb
Mr. Wednesday
Barkeep49
kingfc22
Passacaglia
10-12-2005, 10:26 PM
So wait, ardent is back as ntndeacon, but still dead?
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:28 PM
So wait, ardent is back as ntndeacon, but still dead?
Yes...
kingfc22
10-12-2005, 10:32 PM
So wait, ardent is back as ntndeacon, but still dead?
I think I'm reading this right, but if SnDvls wants to verify that would be great too. AE took over for Deacon on night 2, but somebody went back in time and killed him.
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:32 PM
I think I'm reading this right, but if SnDvls wants to verify that would be great too. AE took over for Deacon on night 2, but somebody went back in time and killed him.
i can verify that occured
Every time I think I'm in...they keep kicking me back out!
Passacaglia
10-12-2005, 10:34 PM
So I figure there's 3 villagers, at least 1 mafia, and 1 serial killer. Could be 2-2-1, but if so, we're screwed.
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:35 PM
Sun, your PM box is full...if im right ardent might not be dead, but i cant speak publicly about it
Barkeep49
10-12-2005, 10:45 PM
I think a role reveal from the serial killer, along with explanation, would be helpful at this point. Perhaps it's too early? Not knowing what powers everyone has, or even some people have, makes it harder for me to figure out our best way of winning at this point.
I will say that my role is of no use to anyone but myself and due to the limitations, it appears unlikely that my minor ability will ever be used.
Passacaglia
10-12-2005, 10:49 PM
I think a role reveal from the serial killer, along with explanation, would be helpful at this point. Perhaps it's too early? Not knowing what powers everyone has, or even some people have, makes it harder for me to figure out our best way of winning at this point.
I will say that my role is of no use to anyone but myself and due to the limitations, it appears unlikely that my minor ability will ever be used.
I'll reveal my role -- I'm the bodyguard, and I saved/protected Barkeep.
Mr. Wednesday
10-12-2005, 10:49 PM
I think the serial killer is probably in the same situation as the last mafia game with one in it... he wins if he stays alive. He has no incentive to help either side win.
That really sucks that our investigator was inactive during the first day and then killed overnight.
Blade6119
10-12-2005, 10:51 PM
i hate being dead...im clueless for the first two days while trying to use the powers i was given to help the team, and the second i die i figure it all out(or so i think)...i hate death
SnDvls
10-12-2005, 11:08 PM
sorry my pm box was full, it's clear now.
SnDvls
10-12-2005, 11:11 PM
Am I missing someone but looking at post 37 I see only 5 alive:
Passacagilia
pennywisesb
Mr. Wednesday
Barkeep49
kingfc22
sorry you are correct I fixed it.
SnDvls
10-12-2005, 11:11 PM
I think I'm reading this right, but if SnDvls wants to verify that would be great too. AE took over for Deacon on night 2, but somebody went back in time and killed him.
correct
kingfc22
10-13-2005, 01:45 AM
I think we made the right choice lynching RealDeal last night as Pass turns out to be the bodyguard and he used his power to perfection. Well done.
I'm now curious of Mr. Wednesday. a) he is in the day 1 vote for AE. b)Why did he vote for Passacaglia? Was he thinking the vote might be closer and he might be able to save one of his own? c) Also, I think Blade's reaction to the deacon/AE kill indicates that he was likely the serial killer which means that Mr. W does not have that role. So who in turn killed our investigator? I wonder if the mafia has a member that can make a night kill if one of their own is lynched/killed.
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 02:42 AM
On ardent, I was surprised everyone wound up voting for him. I indicated that was where I was going to vote, and why. On Passacaglia, I was actually confused about whether we were voting for him or RealDeal.
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 05:23 AM
me dead.
digamma
10-13-2005, 09:06 AM
times two.
Blade6119
10-13-2005, 09:07 AM
...
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 09:09 AM
I don't know what is going on at this point. It's pretty confusing.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 09:36 AM
heres something, we tked the investigator! :( heres something else, people think they know know my role but dont....heres something else, WHY DID THE MAFIA KILL ME!!!
tked?
Who thinks they know your role?
Aren't you dead?
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 09:57 AM
Maybe the dead don't speak coherently.
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 10:36 AM
He is dead, but he seems to have a problem with the whole not saying anything bit.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 10:43 AM
Well, after the game is done, you'll have to tell me what tked means, cause it is going to drive me batty!
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 10:44 AM
Well, after the game is done, you'll have to tell me what tked means, cause it is going to drive me batty!
I get it. Now that he knows I'm the bodyguard, he's trying to mystify me into bringing him back.
And why would he ask why the mafia killed him?
Should I just be ignoring his questions?
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 10:47 AM
Jees man, I'm completely confused as well. So, let me think out loud here.....Barkeep is back in the game. AE, Digamma, and now Blade are dead?! What a turn of events for the villagers. We go from having a pretty good ratio to being possibly down to 2-2-1.
As far as the serial killer goes, I think he'll win if the mafia wins, but probably doesn't know who the mafia is. I'm just thinking outloud here, but if thats the case, we were WAY behind the 8 ball right off the bat with something like a 7-4 ratio!
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 10:48 AM
Dola. Actually, in the above post I forgot about RA as well, so now 1 person is brought back, but we lose 4!
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 10:51 AM
My guess is that he counts as a villager, but wins if the mafia win. So if we're 2-2-1, then lynching a villager ends the game, right? If that's the case, I think we should vote no lynch. But I think if it's 2-2-1, we're just gonna die. So I think we should assume we're 3-1-1, so we should try our luck with voting.
I'm wondering about Mr. Wednesday. He did vote for me, but I can also see his reasoning that people thought most people were voting for me and not Real -- when I read the discussion, I thought I might be dead, until I saw the vote count.
Thoughts?
kingfc22
10-13-2005, 11:50 AM
My guess is that he counts as a villager, but wins if the mafia win. So if we're 2-2-1, then lynching a villager ends the game, right? If that's the case, I think we should vote no lynch. But I think if it's 2-2-1, we're just gonna die. So I think we should assume we're 3-1-1, so we should try our luck with voting.
I'm confused after reading that.http://dynamic.gamespy.com/%7Efof/forums/images/smilies/confused.gifhttp://dynamic.gamespy.com/%7Efof/forums/images/smilies/confused.gifhttp://dynamic.gamespy.com/%7Efof/forums/images/smilies/confused.gif So do you want to vote no lynch or do you want to vote for someone. I still think Mr. W is mafia since everyone other than pennywise who voted for AE at the beginning is dead. And he didn't vote for RealDeal who must be a mafia member since Pass is the bodyguard. I have to go to work so I hope we make the right decision.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 11:55 AM
Sorry. I guess I was saying we should vote for someone. I'm fine with Mr. Wednesday. However, I don't think that RealDeal must be a member of the mafia just because I'm the bodyguard. I think the only one that we KNOW to be clean is Barkeep, since the mafia killed him. If the mafia decided to kill one of their own to trap me into saving him and thinking him clean, then they're really good (that's why Blade's comment worries me -- I was planning on saving him tonight, but now I'm not so sure).
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 02:01 PM
At this point, I don't think we have a lot of room for errors, and lynching me would count as one. Not a huge one, I'm nobody special, but we can't really afford to give people away right now.
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 02:05 PM
LOL. I think RealDeal is out of the game. Boxed.
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 02:05 PM
LOL. I think RealDeal is out of the game. Boxed.
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 02:06 PM
Currently alive:
1) Passacagilia
2) pennywisesb
4) Mr. Wednesday
6) Barkeep49
8) kingfc22
I know I'm clean.
Barkeep was saved from a mafia hit by someone from the future, so that would seem to suggest that he's clean.
Pass claims to be the bodyguard, and I don't suppose I have any reason to doubt him at the moment, since the bodyguard isn't dead and nobody's gone after him for a liar.
That leaves pennywise and kingfc...
Blade6119
10-13-2005, 02:07 PM
....i wish i could talk...
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 02:09 PM
Er, correction to my last, the bodyguard is presumably not dead by mafia or serial killer. We could have lynched him, in which case nobody would know... making it a risky play to claim you're the bodyguard if you're not.
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 02:30 PM
If the mafia decided to kill one of their own to trap me into saving him and thinking him clean, then they're really good (that's why Blade's comment worries me -- I was planning on saving him tonight, but now I'm not so sure).
I've been worried about the same thing ever since Blade mentioned it. It seemed like a really brash move, but with such low numbers to start the game, I think it'd be a good play for the mafia. I just hope they weren't that smart to begin with.
I'm not sold on Mr. W at this point either. His voting pattern was AE on day one (Bandwagon vote) and Pass on day two. [Granted we didn't know during the day 2 vote we didn't know Pass was the BG] My main suspicion is because I still think the mafia were trying to hide their votes along with the AE vote and that would leave myself and him as the last two who voted for AE. Mr. W. himself in an earlier thread said he didn't think it'd be a good ploy for the mafia to not vote on day 1. Since I know I'm clean, my suspicion meter for Mr. Wed. is off the charts at this point and I think thats who I'm going to vote for.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 02:34 PM
I'm voting for Mr. W as well.
VOTE END OF DAY
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 02:38 PM
Well perhaps things would be better if more poeple revealed their roles? I, in case you haven't figured out, am a simple villager. My one ability is to activate a protection shield on one night possibly preventing me from being killed. This must be done in advance and I have already chosen a night to do it. There is an important detail I've left out in case this role becomes in dispute.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 02:41 PM
What do you mean, in advance? Like, you had to pick a night to be protected, when the game started?
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 03:01 PM
By advance I mean I couldn't send the protection BACK in time.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 03:03 PM
Hmm. So why didn't you protect yourself the first night?
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 03:13 PM
As villagers, we were required to choose the night to protect ourselves before the end of day 3. And we had to send it forward. Obviously, barkeep had no idea that he would be attacked by the mafia in night 1.
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 03:14 PM
Too bad Pass already decided to end the day, perhaps the fact that I know the villager role would have convinced him to change his mind about voting for me...
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 03:16 PM
Double dola, voting patterns are difficult to impossible to make sense out of without more information than we currently have at our disposal. We can get a lot more information out of votes that are between a mafioso and a villager, but right now we don't know which (if any) of those votes turned out that way.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 03:20 PM
Well, hopefully the truth sets you free Mr. Wednesday -- it's just one vote!
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 03:22 PM
sombody save meeeeeeeeeee
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 03:30 PM
Can Barkeep please confirm this to be true?
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 03:32 PM
Just in case every villager has a slightly different role, I want to make sure Mr. W is telling the truth.
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 03:50 PM
The before the 3rd night was the detail I hadn't included. The description Mr. Wednesday gives matches perfectly with the role I recieved and in my mind clears him absolutely.
Mr. Wednesday
10-13-2005, 04:02 PM
That leaves pennywise (particularly interesting with the question about whether what I posted was accurate) and kingfc22...
I'm secure with my vote for pennywise. Vote end of day
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 04:09 PM
Vote End Day
SnDvls
10-13-2005, 04:11 PM
well that's 3 end day votes I'll tally everything in just a second...stay tuned.
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 04:11 PM
I hope my vote got in there before penny closed the day.
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 04:12 PM
Dola -- Although I think I might have wasted my vote in the end as I voted for King. He's seemed slightly more suspcious.
Don't let your dola posting dangle in the dirt.
SnDvls
10-13-2005, 04:22 PM
Day 3
You all gather in the town square for the lynch vote. Mr. Wednesday and Barkeep seem to have confirmed eachother as a normal villager. Everyone has a weird feeling in their body though that this could turn out bad. pennywisesb and kingfc22 don’t feel that Mr. W is on the up and up though and accusations begin to fly. Barkeep thinks king is bad and Mr. W feels it’s penny. It all comes down to Passacagilla. With a confused look in his eye he throws his vote to lynch Mr. Wednesday. Mr. W is quickly strung up and his lifeless body comes to rest. Just then pennywisesb and kingfc pull their guns and shoot pass and barkeep. The mafia gained their 1:1 ratio and have gained control of the time machines. The mafia have won.
Mr. W (3) - penny, king, pass
king (1) - Barkeep
penny (1) - Mr. W
post 37 has been updated with roles.
SnDvls
10-13-2005, 04:23 PM
here is everyone's original role PM..please give me some feedback as this was my first mod. wearwolf game.
• 3 Mafia: You are the mafia, or bad guys. You have stolen a time travel machine from the scientist to help you control the town. You can send one person through time to kill another player, forward or backward through time, or you may kill on the current night. On even nights (2, 4, 6, ect) you may send another player through time to kill someone either forward or backward in time, thus giving you two kills on these nights. You can not go back to a day more than once and you have a 3 day window to travel. So on Day 5 you can go to any day between day 2 to 8. You can travel 3 times each. You will need to PM me who is doing the traveling/killing and what day and who to kill. Please also send in a back up as if you are killed/lynched in the past or revised present a future killing won’t happen. You may PM each other. If the target is protected you will be notified.
• 1 Investigator: You are the Investigator who has been brought in to help track down the mafia and the stolen time travel machine. You may travel back through time to investigate one player, either dead or alive, to know their role (Mafia/Villager) or you can investigate the current night. You may go back to any day, but only twice to the same day. You have a 2 day travel window. So on Day 5 you can go back to any day between 3 and 4. You may travel 3 times total.
• 1 Bodyguard: You can travel through time to save one player from the mafia only. You may go back to any day, but only twice to the same day. You have a 2 day travel window. So on Day 5 you can go back to any day between 3 and 4. You may travel 3 times total. You may protect anyone including yourself, however you can not protect the same person on consecutive nights. You can also choose to protect on the current night instead of time traveling. Please PM me the top 3 names in order to protect as your protect may change as the revised present and past are effected by time travel. If all three of your protected list is killed you will protect yourself. You may not protect the same person on consecutive nights, unless a modified present/past has affected your choices. If you stop a kill you will be notified.
• 1 Serial Killer: (you are seen as Mafia to any seer) You count as a villager for victory conditions. Can not time travel. Can kill once every other night starting with night 2. So if you kill night 2 you can not kill again until night 4, If you kill on night 3 then you can not kill until night 5. If the target is protected you will be notified.
• 1 Vigilante: You can travel through time and kill one player once every two nights (could travel once on nights 1 or 2; once on nights 3 or 4... ect.) May travel 3 times total. Can travel to any point in time within a 2 day range forward or backward. So on Night 5 you may travel to night 3 or 4 or 6 or 7. If the target is protected you will be notified.
• 4 Villager: You are just a plain villager. You do however have an “object porter”. This gives you a way to send a protection shield into the future to protect yourself from attack for one night. You must PM me the night you wish to send the shield to by the end of day 3. Choose wisely as once the PM is sent you can not change it. You may pick any night in the future to send it to.
This was a little confusing.
Blade needs to get over it, honestly. I've been a villager for each of the past three games and he's always "convinced" I'm on the bad side. Seriously, it's getting a little old.
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 04:29 PM
I almost totally f-ed that up. I was trying to look like an oblivious villager, but right after I hit submit on that post about having barkeep confirm what Mr. W said I knew exactly what I had just done. Fortunately for me, Pass had already voted to end the day and I knew that King and I were already voting for Mr. W. at that point. Whew!
digamma
10-13-2005, 04:31 PM
Who had which roles?
I was the serial killer, but got knocked off by the mafia.
My initial thought is that for a game of 11 people, it had way too many people with the ability to kill.
We never really got to explore the time travel aspect because the game ended so quickly.
pennywisesb
10-13-2005, 04:31 PM
Good game. I think with like 5 or 6 more players it would have been alittle more interesting. I hope future WW games will get better showings as far as participants go. I think SnDvls did a good job, there just wasn't enough players. Great idea though SnDvls and I hope you choose to GM another game in the future!
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 04:33 PM
Way too much killing compared to protecting would be my comment. I'm sorry there wasn't more interest in the game as I think it would have worked far better with a larger crowd.
digamma
10-13-2005, 04:37 PM
Sweet. RA was mafia. At least I picked him off.
Barkeep49
10-13-2005, 04:43 PM
Oh and props to SnDvls for running this rather complex game. I would play in one of your games again.
digamma
10-13-2005, 04:51 PM
Oh and props to SnDvls for running this rather complex game. I would play in one of your games again.
Agree. Kudos.
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 04:55 PM
Sweet. RA was mafia. At least I picked him off.
Bastard!
Yay us!
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 04:57 PM
I was playing a role in the game pretending to be an innocent villager, but...
What I posted is how I felt. The game seemed very much slanted towards the Mafia. This was somewhat proven when the mafia won on Day 3, which probably was the shortest game of WW on this board.
Maybe the original mafia should've been only 2 instead of 3 people?
Blade6119
10-13-2005, 05:18 PM
This was a little confusing.
Blade needs to get over it, honestly. I've been a villager for each of the past three games and he's always "convinced" I'm on the bad side. Seriously, it's getting a little old.
You need to get over yourself man...evidence was presented against you better then anyone else...sorry you dont know how to survive, but i dont hold grudges or else all my votes would go to real deal...how many times did you vote for schmidty first round in past games?? thank you
digamma
10-13-2005, 05:19 PM
Blade, you also shouldn't send people PM's in game. Even if it's only to tell them to read your post in the thread.
Blade6119
10-13-2005, 05:22 PM
Blade, you also shouldn't send people PM's in game. Even if it's only to tell them to read your post in the thread.
I agree, you were the only person ive ever done that too...i originally had you killed first night before a last second swap to deacon/ardent so i pushed for your views since i thought you were mafia and wanted to see who you would cover...my bad
Evidence. Right, because I took a look at the thread on the first day, realized I didn't have a chance at knowing what to say or what I needed to do. The fact I needed to spend time with my injured wife, pack her bags, drop her off at her mom's, and had to take a 6 hour drive back to Chicago in the same day is probably not evidence enough you have no clue that you're being a little stupid about this.
You've used some silly choices to rally others to remove me. Honestly, you're the bad guy's MVP. They know you're not bad, they know I'm not, and you've been persistent in removing me...for three games.
I'm over it. It's over. Quit trying to run me up some flagpole because you're upset with me. Just admit it to yourself and stop it.
Seriously, let's get over this and let me have some fun with the games.
Raiders Army
10-13-2005, 05:31 PM
Please, stop! That's why gottmid and rkmsuf make fun of the Werewolf games!
SnDvls
10-13-2005, 05:37 PM
thanks all for participating.
some thoughts on the game. It should have started on night 1 to allow for AE to be brought back...my fault.
Day 1 vote wouldn't have been effected if the non/late voters had got them in on time.
Day 2 might have changed some things though. ntndeacon as the investagator looks at Blade on night 1 for his action. His hint was that he was a villager, but something wasn't right about him. When he did not participate on day 2 that hurt you as a group as he might have swayed some people away from RealDeal towards the VIGILANTE, thus preventing an innocent kill.
all in all I'm happy with the game, I knew it'd be short if the mafia figured out how to do a mass kill and the villagers made a few mistakes along the way.
I'm surprised the BODYGUARD didn't pick up on his hint in his role that he could only protect mafia kills.
Also surprised the mafia or villagers didn't use the end day to their advantage as much as I thought it would happen.
I do have another game I've though about. It's a public vote and a vote to end day, but each person has multiple roles, but they only know about their current active role. It would keep people involved even if they are killed as they would get a new role to continue with.
anyhow thanks again.
SnDvls
10-13-2005, 05:39 PM
dola- I should have made the investagator role a day role/action too to help in the voting.
Passacaglia
10-13-2005, 06:49 PM
I'm surprised the BODYGUARD didn't pick up on his hint in his role that he could only protect mafia kills.
Heh, when I first read this, I didn't even know what you meant. Then I realized that it took me until the serial killer killing to realize it, and by then, well, it was obvious to everyone. Although, I totally punted the game on Day 3, when I was the only villager to vote for another villager. Sorry, Mr. Wednesday! And kudos to king and penny for just piling on and ending it there.
So I said that if 2 mafia were left, we should do a no-lynch, since lynching the wrong person would end the game immediately. I still think that if we did a no-lynch, with 2 mafia, we were goners.
Fun game, SnDvls!
kingfc22
10-13-2005, 08:26 PM
Thanks for the fun game SnDvls and I hope you continue to GM games. We got a couple good breaks at the beginning. We knew nobody would believe I was mafia since we killed the only guy that voted for me. Deacon would probably have been our next lynch target if he had not been killed last night. This game would have gotten really interesting if we had 16-20 people. Too bad we couldn't get more to play.
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.