PDA

View Full Version : Top rule 5 picks of all time.


bbor
05-04-2006, 03:34 PM
Some interesting names on here.


Top 5 Rule 5 draft choices

By Dave Sheinin - SportingNews



1. Roberto Clemente. That's right -- he was a Rule 5 selection of the Pirates, who plundered him from the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1954. He is the only Rule 5er in the Hall of Fame.



2. George Bell. The 1987 A.L. MVP was a 1980 draftee of the Blue Jays after the Phillies failed to protect him. Bell retired after the 1993 season with 265 career homers and three All-Star Game appearances.

3. Johan Santana. There are two losers in this tale. The 2004 A.L. Cy Young winner began his pro career in the Astros' chain but was lost in the 1999 draft to the Marlins -- who immediately traded him to the Twins.

4. Jay Gibbons. He's a gift from the Syd Thrift era that keeps on giving to Orioles fans. The O's grabbed Gibbons away from the Blue Jays in 2000, and he has had three 20-homer seasons in Baltimore.

5. Willy Taveras. Taveras came out of the same 2003 draft as Shelton and was the runner-up for N.L. Rookie of the Year in 2005. The Astros took him from the Indians.

Maple Leafs
05-04-2006, 03:38 PM
The Blue Jays also picked up Willie Upshaw and Kelly Gruber through Rule V, I believe.

I read somewhere that when Clemente was picked the "Rule V" worked differently, though.

SackAttack
05-04-2006, 03:43 PM
More recently I think Chris Shelton was a Rule V pick, but obviously time will tell if he merits discussion in a Top 5.

bosshogg23
05-04-2006, 03:44 PM
Rob Neyer ran a similiar article about 2 weeks ago. Apparently the Rule 5 was drastically different when Clemente was in it so Neyer "eliminated" him from consideration.

Neyers all time starting lineup was

Catcher - Jody Davis

First Base - Willie Upshaw

Second Base - Bip Roberts

Shortstop - Deivi Cruz

Third Base - Bobby Bonilla

Left Field - George Bell

Center Field - Shane Mack

Right Field - Jay Gibbons

DH - Chris Shelton

SP - Johan Santana

RP - Graeme Lloyd

Draft Dodger
05-04-2006, 03:46 PM
not quite in the same class, but Eddie Taubensee was a Rule V who got picked up by Cleveland after Oakland waived him and Cincy didn't want him back. a year later, he was traded for Kenny Lofton...a huge deal for Cleveland.

JeeberD
05-04-2006, 03:48 PM
Man, can you imagine Santana in the Astros rotation last year?

Oswalt
Santana
Clemens
Pettite
Backe/Rodriguez/Astacio

Sick...

Toddzilla
05-04-2006, 03:52 PM
Man, can you imagine Santana in the Astros rotation last year?

Oswalt
Santana
Clemens
Pettite
Backe/Rodriguez/Astacio

Sick...It would have made their World Series loss all the more heartbreaking - laff.

JeeberD
05-04-2006, 03:59 PM
Yeah, wouldn't have helped our bats any... :(

bbor
05-04-2006, 04:03 PM
I'd like to see a list of rule 5 busts.

stevew
05-04-2006, 04:13 PM
I'd like to see a list of rule 5 busts.


Pretty much every other guy.