PDA

View Full Version : A-Rod and his binkie


Buccaneer
09-23-2006, 10:54 AM
Just in time for the playoffs, Alex Rodriguez needlessly has heaped another mountain of pressure on himself.

Just in time for prime time national television, A-Rod has ensured that the October microscope will beam even brighter on him now than it ever has.
The latest is included in Tom Verducci's marvelous Sports Illustrated cover story this week, entitled "The Lonely Yankee: After a Bewildering Summer in Pinstripes, Alex Rodriguez Has to Prove Himself in Pinstripes."

It is an even-handed and fair look at Rodriguez's turbulent season and inexplicable slumps (both offensive and defensive). In the piece, Verducci works at identifying the cause of Rodriguez's bewildering inconsistency this summer, and the trail leads exactly where you might suspect: Directly into Rodriguez's fatal flaw, his epic insecurity.

Speaking of some of his high-priced teammates, Rodriguez tells SI: "(Mike) Mussina doesn't get hammered at all. He's making a boatload of money. Giambi's making ($20.4 million), which is fine and dandy, but it seems those guys get a pass. When people write (bad things) about me, I don't know if it's (because) I'm good-looking, I'm bi-racial, I make the most money, I play on the most popular team ..."

Aside from the sheer absurdity of those words, which would sound juvenile enough in a junior-high gymnasium, is this: Derek Jeter qualifies for three of those categories -- good-looking, bi-racial, plays on the most popular team -- and, though he doesn't make the most money, he makes enough ($21 million) to get people's attention. Not to mention the fact that he makes more than every Yankee not named A-Rod.

So what's Rodriguez's explanation for his one-time friend not getting raspberries from the crowd?

Meanwhile, instead of simply shrugging his shoulders, making a corny self-deprecating joke or giving a heartfelt self-analysis -- anything -- on the subject of his slumps this summer (in 80 games between June 1 and Aug. 30, Rodriguez hit only .257 with 81 strikeouts and 13 errors), Rodriguez crafted a response in which he seems to avoid responsibility for his own actions.

And in the process, he throws a couple of teammates and a Yankees legend under the bus.

"Reggie (Jackson) hit .230 one year," Rodriguez tells the magazine. "That's awful. He struck out 170-something times in a year. I don't care who you are, extremes are just part of the game. I was awful (in Anaheim during last fall's playoffs, when he went 2-for-15), but Jeter was 0-for-32 (in 2004), Mo (Rivera, Yankees closer) blew three games in one week (last year). ... Everybody goes through it."

I was awful, but. ...

Exactly how a brain can short-circuit to this extent, probably nobody can explain -- least of all the man talking. First off, how many players go around keeping a mental file on his teammates' negative statistics?
And for those who do, how many would clumsily speak of them in such a public forum? He also seems to take delight in pointing out that Oakland third baseman Eric Chavez is struggling badly this year ("He's got 16 home runs, 43 ribbies?") yet continues to be cheered in Oakland.

Perhaps someone should tell A-Rod that Chavez probably should have spent half the season on the disabled list with forearm tendinitis yet has played through it even at the expense of his own numbers because he can help his team in other ways.

For a seemingly smart guy, A-Rod leads the league in saying dumb things.
This is exactly the kind of petty stuff that rarely went on inside the vaunted Yankees' clubhouse before A-Rod's arrival. It is the stuff that Joe Torre has managed so well to keep at arm's length during his time in New York.
Torre has spent most of his days in the pilot's chair selling the team before the individual, and part of the magic of Torre is that he almost always has gotten whatever highly talented group he was charged with in a particular year to buy into it.

Rodriguez, once again, completely comes across as a guy obsessed with his own numbers when all he has to do is look at Jeter to realize that the only thing that matters in New York is winning. After that, everything else takes care of itself.

People who have known Rodriguez well for years have told me time and time again that the root of his problems is his patented insecurity. After so many years, it is HDTV clear to anybody who simply pays attention to the man for any length of time.

The incredible thing is that, all of these years later, it seems to be getting worse instead of better.

.

azjoe_02
09-23-2006, 12:01 PM
As a Yankees fan, I can pretty much agree with this and yet at the same time, I feel as though he does...at times...gets pointed out a little unfairly.

Just my .02

Vinatieri for Prez
09-23-2006, 12:51 PM
Actually, I think Giambi and the other Yanks looked more like jackasses in that SI article than A-Rod.

EagleFan
09-23-2006, 12:53 PM
As a Yankees fan, I can pretty much agree with this and yet at the same time, I feel as though he does...at times...gets pointed out a little unfairly.

Just my .02

Yeah, with the peanuts that he is making there is no reason to point him out above other players......

azjoe_02
09-23-2006, 01:06 PM
Yeah, with the peanuts that he is making there is no reason to point him out above other players......

I just don't think it makes sense to criticize him any more or less than any other player making roughly the same money he is. He signed the huge contract and it is his fault that someone was willing to pay him. That is saying, Hey he is making 5 Million/year so he can slide on the criticizing for batting .220 in the playoffs, but if you are making say 10 million/year than you had better have at least a .285 average, and if you are making 15 million/year, you better .300 avg.

My point is...if you are in the majors, than you should be getting criticized for under-peforming in the post season, REGARDLESS of your pay. It should not be scaled based on the amount of money you make. Now on the other hand, if you are a career .270 hitter, I don't expect you to hit .325 in the post-season, if you do great. If you hit .220, than you should be criticized.

Deattribution
09-23-2006, 01:54 PM
He shouldn't get any criticism for how much he's being paid - if someone offers you 25 million a year you take it. You don't say ooh I don't know, I think I'd prefer 15 million.


The rest of the stuff is him trying to fit on a team he doesn't fit on. He can't seem to be 'one of the guys' he has to be 'THE guy' which is hard when youre playing on the who's who team in baseball.

rexallllsc
09-23-2006, 02:08 PM
Giambi is a fool. Talking about helping A-Rod needing help or needing to step up or even that A-Rod doesn't know himself.

Giambi is hitting .250 and is a juice monster. F him.

JS19
09-23-2006, 02:16 PM
I gotta agree with A-Rod here. He wasn't criticizing Jeter or Mo there, he was just making a point. Players go through rough stretches, it's part of the game.

dawgfan
09-23-2006, 02:27 PM
Yeah, as much as I'd like to rub A-Rod's face in his "struggles", the fact is that the amount of shit he's taken from the media and "fans" in New York is deplorable. He remains one of the very best players in the game, yet he's taking shit for hitting .284 with 34 HR's and an .898 OPS while playing 3B? Yeah, he got a case of the yips defensively this year, but the fact is that he made a big sacrifice when he came to the Yankees in agreeing to move to 3B when he's a superior fielder at SS to Jeter.

A-Rod has his personal flaws, no question, but he's gotten way more shit in New York than is warrented.

cougarfreak
09-23-2006, 02:31 PM
Giambi is a fool. Talking about helping A-Rod needing help or needing to step up or even that A-Rod doesn't know himself.

Giambi is hitting .250 and is a juice monster. F him.

My sentiments exactly........Giambi is an ass.

sterlingice
09-23-2006, 02:51 PM
Yeah, as much as I'd like to rub A-Rod's face in his "struggles", the fact is that the amount of shit he's taken from the media and "fans" in New York is deplorable. He remains one of the very best players in the game, yet he's taking shit for hitting .284 with 34 HR's and an .898 OPS while playing 3B? Yeah, he got a case of the yips defensively this year, but the fact is that he made a big sacrifice when he came to the Yankees in agreeing to move to 3B when he's a superior fielder at SS to Jeter.

A-Rod has his personal flaws, no question, but he's gotten way more shit in New York than is warrented.

Should ARod be wanting to be dealt away and his salary paid by the Yankees for being such a burden, Kansas City would be more than willing to take him. Hell, we'd even let him play SS.

SI

rexallllsc
09-23-2006, 02:55 PM
Should ARod be wanting to be dealt away and his salary paid by the Yankees for being such a burden, Kansas City would be more than willing to take him. Hell, we'd even let him play SS.

SI

Seriously. Compared to Giambi's 20 mil/season A-Rod is underpaid (Note: I believe the salary is nuts, but relatively speaking...).

A-Rod would be loved just about anywhere else, I think. Esp. FLA, LA, Anaheim.

sterlingice
09-23-2006, 02:57 PM
Seriously. Compared to Giambi's 20 mil/season A-Rod is underpaid (Note: I believe the salary is nuts, but relatively speaking...).

A-Rod would be loved just about anywhere else, I think. Esp. FLA, LA, Anaheim.

If I'm not mistaken, the Yankees aren't even paying over $20 for him. They're actually paying more for Giambi, aren't they, if you take into account the cash he's getting paid from Texas?

SI

rexallllsc
09-23-2006, 03:00 PM
If I'm not mistaken, the Yankees aren't even paying over $20 for him. They're actually paying more for Giambi, aren't they, if you take into account the cash he's getting paid from Texas?

SI

I think you're right. Good point.

oykib
09-23-2006, 03:12 PM
Yankee fan here:

A-Rod is probably the best player to ever lace up a pair of cleats. I think his numbers at the end of his career will prove this out. My fellow Yankee fans are not as bright as they think.

You've got 30% or so trying to run him out of town. Where are you gonna get the 120 runs he produces every year? I thought nothing could be as stupid as the Sox Manny trade odyssey last year. I guess Yankee fans have to be better than Sox fans at everything.

Desnudo
09-24-2006, 01:11 AM
Clearly a closet homesexual. Occam's razor.

Easy Mac
09-24-2006, 11:07 AM
Wasn't A-Rod willing to take a pay cut to get to Boston, but the union vetoed it? Shouldn't that tell people that he'd play for less money and for them to get off the whole money thing?

clintl
09-24-2006, 11:29 AM
Wasn't A-Rod willing to take a pay cut to get to Boston, but the union vetoed it? Shouldn't that tell people that he'd play for less money and for them to get off the whole money thing?

Yes. I'm baffled at why A-Rod gets takes so much crap for that, and for all of the other stuff, too. As far as I can tell, he's been pretty much a model citizen as well as a great player, throughout his career. If he's insecure, I'm not so sure that he doesn't have some good reasons to be. Every little flaw (and let's be honest here, all of them are nitpicky little things that he gets criticized for) gets magnified way out of proportion.

Jas_lov
09-24-2006, 11:40 AM
A-Rod was given that ridiculous contract by Texas and who could live up to those expectations? I hope they win it all this year and A-Rod is a big part of it so this all goes away because he deserves better. For the numbers he puts up every year for the Yankees he should be treated like Jeter but that won't happen until he wins the ring. Whenever I'm listening to baseball radio shows where fans around the country call in, they all say they'd love to have A-Rod anyday.

miami_fan
09-24-2006, 12:00 PM
Well the messenger has been ripped enough but what about the message? Mike Mussina DOES NOT get hammered the way Rodriguez does. He also has not led the Yanks to a World Series championship. Giambi? This "leader" has not gotten that elusive title either despite being there longer. He has even been a part of the black eye that is performance enhancing drugs (allegedly). Hey ,that is okay because he apologized right? Sheffield? Nope no Yankee title for him either. The fact is none of the players that were received via trade or players signed through free agency have gotten the Yanks a world title since 2000. And yet if you believe the media and the Yankee fans, Alex Rodriguez is the only reason the Yanks have not won the WS since 2000 though he has only been there since 2004. Is Rodriguez a diva? Yes. Does he care way too much what the media and the fans have to say about him? Absolutely. Maybe he should chit chat with Sheffield on how to not give a shit what the fans and the media think. Has he not been "clutch" in his two postseason as a Yankee? No, but has anyone taken a look at Giambi's and Mussina's postseason number for the Yankees? They are not exactly playoff MVP type numbers. Why is it that Rodriguez is the "worst" Yankee and Mussina and Giambi are so beloved?

Ryan S
09-24-2006, 02:16 PM
Why is it that Rodriguez is the "worst" Yankee and Mussina and Giambi are so beloved?

I don't think I have ever heard anyone say that Giambi and Mussina are beloved by Yankee fans.

ISiddiqui
09-24-2006, 03:12 PM
Well, not ripping them in the media is close enough to being beloved in NY ;).

miami_fan
09-24-2006, 04:54 PM
I don't think I have ever heard anyone say that Giambi and Mussina are beloved by Yankee fans.

Well Giambi won the Comeback Player Award last year which is voted on by the fans. How many non-Yankee fans do you think voted for Giambi? And would any Yankee fan vote for A-Rod if (when?) he has a better year next year than he did this year?