Garrard or Leftwich?

[Abe Sargent]

You have a healthy Jaguars team and two healthy QBs in Jacksonville. If you are the coach, who do you make your starting QB?


-Anxiety

[stevew]

I'd say Leftwich on talent. But he's so damned injury prone, I'm not sure that it would be the smartest thing to take him exclusively. Especially if I have to find a suitable backup since I can't keep Garrard around anymore.

[TroyF]

Leftwich without a doubt.

I saw some stats analysis on it the other day that clearly showed the offense moved better and scored more points with Leftwich.

The Giants have a beat up defense that Garrard exploited last night. It's easy to forget he lost to the Texans. (as did Leftwich, I know, but at least he had the excuse of having an ankle that needed surgery that he played with)

[dbd1963]

I haven't followed the Jags, so my question is, have you seen enough of Garrard to know you don't want him as your starter? From what I saw last night, if he progresses from there, he could be one good QB.

I know Leftwich a little, and his lack of mobility is a bit of a problem. It's like Bledsoe/Romo writ small in J'Ville.

[Passacaglia]

I say Leftwich because Reggie Williams is on my fantasy team.

[DaddyTorgo]

i've been saying garrard for years

[rkmsuf]

Leftwich so we can keep seeing the video of his team carrying him to the line of scrimmage.

[INDalltheway]

I like Garrard. I think they need to see how he plays the rest of the year and make a decision after that.

[Young Drachma]

Matt Jones?

I kid, I kid.

[dbd1963]

Wow, tied at 18. This is like a Hot Or Not battle.

Which one looks better in a swimsuit?

[BigDPW]

Living in Greenville NC I have to go with the ECU alum!

[BigDPW]

I do worry about how Garrard would perform if he were the go to guy for a team. I think the pressure is basically off when you are the backup like he is. And in that role he has really excelled!