PDA

View Full Version : Choosing a favorite National League team


Young Drachma
09-16-2007, 09:29 PM
Ok, so I'm a Blue Jays fan (insert laugh track here..) and the fact is, not only do I never get to see my team play during the year because of where they play and the fact that they're never on TV where I live, I'm thinking that it might be time to adopt a second team.

I doubt this 2nd team will be a team that I care about as much as the Jays (and partially because I don't want to be a fairweather fan, though I've been a fan since at least '91, when I was just getting into baseball), but I would like a team to follow starting next year, because by and large..I love baseball.

But I hate that I don't really have a team to follow and one I can go see.

I'm 90 minutes from Denver, so the Rockies are a logical choice to some degree. But I don't know whether I just hate them because the majority of their fans have yet to realize that the team isn't a minor league club or for some other reason.

So for that reason, let's just keep this choice at National League clubs only. That way, it'll be a team that comes to town and gives me something to root for or to go watch, because I don't have to wait for interleague play to go see them in Denver more than once a year if I want.

Here are the choices I've narrowed it down to and the reasoning behind each and I'd like some help narrowing it down.

Here goes:

ST. LOUIS CARDINALS: I lived in the STL metro area when I was in the Air Force, lived in St. Louis for my last year there and started college there. I've been to probably 30 or 40 Cardinals games -- more than any other team, despite growing up in the NYC metro area -- and I appreciated the fact that the Cards let active or retired military members go to games for free using their military ID (you sit anywhere there is an open seat and if the ticketed person comes, you move.) and well..they're obviously a good team in recent years, have recognizable faces and I submit that their fans are indeed the best fans in baseball hands down.

The cons to the Cardinals are that I 1) don't live in St. Louis anymore and don't plan to move back anytime soon, if ever. 2) it's kinda a popular choice in recent years and 3) they're essentially a juggernaut, but we don't think of that way because they're not the Sox or Yankees. I don't know if I can fake hating Cubs fans and all of that Midwestern silliness is a bit much for me.

COLORADO ROCKIES: Not a popular pick by any means. I mean, is anyone outside of Denver actually a Rockies fan? I get annoyed about the fact that they are where they are more often than you'd believe. They play in a great looking ballpark. Their team is great, young and fun to watch. And management seems to be generally competent given the task of putting together a winner in the hardest place in baseball to do that. (And if you doubt that, watch one game at Coors and look what the altitude does to routine flyballs and then you'll understand...)

But..they're new. Yes, I know. In that span, the Marlins have won TWO Word Series titles. But...I just feel a little weird liking a team that doesn't have a discernable "die hard" fan base. Maybe that's selling them short. But...it seems to me that the crowds here are minor league (lots of families and couples, not a whole lot of single guys going out to the ballpark like in other cities or old dudes who you know have been going to baseball games since the Dodgers were in Brooklyn) and so, the lack of ambience to me makes uncomfortable. But...I do like the fact that it's new, there are few traditions and it's the kind of team that you can appreciate for life, especially getting in while they're still relatively new.

WASHINGTON NATIONALS: They're terrible now. But someday, they'll have a new ballpark and eventually, you'd figure they'll be good right? And I used to like the Expos. And plus, the fans in D.C. are knowledgable and the team is newer (in practice) than the Rockies are. So it's all of the 'newness' of an expansion team (down to them being bad), without the newness of a city that's not quite sure about this "major league baseball" thing. So it combines a lot of what I like about the first two choices, only with the aftertaste of knowing that outside of Ryan Zimmerman I'll have nothing to cheer about for about 3-5 more years.

NEW YORK METS: I grew up in the Jersey. The only NYC area team I truly root for are the Devils. I like to see the Jets do well, but I only call myself a "fan" in the sense that people expect you to have a team to root for and well...I'll never root for the Broncos. But anyway...the Mets are a safe choice. And that NY logo hat sure does always remind me of home and it's scarce out here, since everyone associates New York with the Yankees. It helps that the Mets are good, that they spend money and are always getting new players. Carlos Delgado is on the team and that's a HUGE boon, since he came up with the Jays and we foolishly let him go for money we've since wasted on players who aren't half as productive.

They're a team I love to see do well and so, it wouldn't be a stretch to support them and it's not as if rooting for them now when they're good would make me a bandwagon fan since growing up in Central Jersey, my choices are limited to them or the Yankees anyway. (The Phillies are too far and seriously, that's just a bad idea.)

I guess the cons here are, they'll always be 2nd fiddle to the Yankees short of winning a string of titles that make them instantly more relevant. Plus, Shea is an awful place to watch a game. CitiField might be great, but airplane noise won't be going anywhere anytime soon. But a part of me would love to bring my east coast roots with me to Coors Field when they come to town, as if to say "no, I'm not from here. Thanks."

But I dunno. Something about it doesn't quite feel right.

I think that's it. I considered Milwaukee. I really love their team right now. I mean, those guys are just a bunch of awesome, scrappy kids who you just love to see play. But I have no doubt that in five years, all of them will be gone. Maybe Prince will stay. But the rest of them? No way they'll be Robin Yount/Paul Molitor types. So that's just setting myself up for disappointment and I'm not okay with that. Plus, Milwaukee isn't somewhere I particularly enjoy visiting.

So okay. That's it. Thoughts? This year's standings and results don't really have much bearing on my choices, but it just came to mind when the Yankees v. Red Sox game was on and I thought, "I need a team to root for. This sucks." So that's what brought this all on tonight.

Lathum
09-16-2007, 09:36 PM
Mets.

Reyes and Wright locked up to deals and they are 2 of the most exciting young players in the game

molson
09-16-2007, 09:37 PM
I'd vote for the Nationals.

The most fun thing about being a fan is when your team is on the way up. The Nationals offer the potential for that, with their market size, and all the other reasons you mentioned.

SackAttack
09-16-2007, 09:51 PM
Why not the Pirates?

You'd double the size of their fan base immediately.

lighthousekeeper
09-16-2007, 09:51 PM
...
COLORADO ROCKIES: ...it seems to me that the crowds here are minor league (lots of families and couples, not a whole lot of single guys going out to the ballpark like in other cities or old dudes...

You should just root (root, root) for the home team. Don't let the fact that there aren't enough single guys deter you. There are other ways besides baseball to meet single guys.

Greyroofoo
09-16-2007, 09:59 PM
Cubbies

Karlifornia
09-16-2007, 09:59 PM
Nationals. I've somewhat adopted the Devil Rays as a second favorite team behind the Giants...Even if they never win anything, they're still a source of entertainment.

Young Drachma
09-16-2007, 10:01 PM
You should just root (root, root) for the home team. Don't let the fact that there aren't enough single guys deter you. There are other ways besides baseball to meet single guys.

Well played. Not what I meant though.

Single girls at Brewer games won't help me, since Milwaukee isn't exactly down the street. :)

But that's good to know.

st.cronin
09-16-2007, 10:01 PM
There are a whole lot of single GIRLS at Brewer games.

Greyroofoo
09-16-2007, 10:12 PM
There are a whole lot of single GIRLS at Brewer games.

There's a reason for that...

Neuqua
09-16-2007, 10:25 PM
Cubs.

sterlingice
09-16-2007, 10:41 PM
I don't get these "help me pick a team" threads. It's not something you sit there, analyze, go "hm... I think this team will be good so I'll follow them despite having no other vested interest" and then viola, you're a fan. That's maybe a half step from being a fairweather fan. Why not just start liking the Yankees or Red Sox or something filthy like that?

It's like saying 10 years ago, "say, I like Milton Bradley since he has a cool name" and suddenly he's your favorite player. Then he never quite busts onto the scene but you still follow him. Then he turns out to not be that good of a person but you don't care because you chose him a long time ago. It just doesn't work like that.

You don't just become a fan because you set out to be a fan one day and "presto, now you like them". It's like the falling in love cliches- it's not like you just set out to pick the next girl who walks by and she's going to be your wife. You start liking a team or player because you're following them and one day you think to yourself- you know, I've been following this team/player for quite a while and I really do like them. And you don't know when exactly it started or how but when you realize it, then you're a fan.

Back to your particular issue, the Rockies are an easy choice. You have a good reason to like them in that they are you local team. They're also going to be easy to follow because they're your local team- this sounds like a silly thing, but it's easy to fall away from being a fan of a team if you can't follow them as easily. So, then, you can start following them and eventually you'll feel like you're an actual fan.

SI

Lathum
09-16-2007, 10:44 PM
I don't get these "help me pick a team" threads. It's not something you sit there, analyze, go "hm... I think this team will be good so I'll follow them despite having no other vested interest" and then viola, you're a fan. That's maybe a half step from being a fairweather fan. Why not just start liking the Yankees or Red Sox or something filthy like that?

It's like saying 10 years ago, "say, I like Milton Bradley since he has a cool name" and suddenly he's your favorite player. Then he never quite busts onto the scene but you still follow him. Then he turns out to not be that good of a person but you don't care because you chose him a long time ago. It just doesn't work like that.

You don't just become a fan because you set out to be a fan one day and "presto, now you like them". It's like the falling in love cliches- it's not like you just set out to pick the next girl who walks by and she's going to be your wife. You start liking a team or player because you're following them and one day you think to yourself- you know, I've been following this team/player for quite a while and I really do like them. And you don't know when exactly it started or how but when you realize it, then you're a fan.

Back to your particular issue, the Rockies are an easy choice. You have a good reason to like them in that they are you local team. They're also going to be easy to follow because they're your local team- this sounds like a silly thing, but it's easy to fall away from being a fan of a team if you can't follow them as easily. So, then, you can start following them and eventually you'll feel like you're an actual fan.

SI

so who should he pick?

ISiddiqui
09-16-2007, 10:53 PM
Pick the Mets :).

Aside from my personal homer issues (I'm from Jersey), the point has been brought up that they have some great young talent in Reyes and Wright that'll be fun to watch for years. They do tend to spend money to win. And even though they are a NYC area team, they aren't the Yankees ;). This also has the added benefit of hating the Yankees and having an actual reason other than "they spend a lot of money and junk".

lordscarlet
09-16-2007, 10:56 PM
Go Nats!

Karlifornia
09-16-2007, 11:03 PM
I don't get these "help me pick a team" threads. It's not something you sit there, analyze, go "hm... I think this team will be good so I'll follow them despite having no other vested interest" and then viola, you're a fan. That's maybe a half step from being a fairweather fan. Why not just start liking the Yankees or Red Sox or something filthy like that?

It's like saying 10 years ago, "say, I like Milton Bradley since he has a cool name" and suddenly he's your favorite player. Then he never quite busts onto the scene but you still follow him. Then he turns out to not be that good of a person but you don't care because you chose him a long time ago. It just doesn't work like that.

You don't just become a fan because you set out to be a fan one day and "presto, now you like them". It's like the falling in love cliches- it's not like you just set out to pick the next girl who walks by and she's going to be your wife. You start liking a team or player because you're following them and one day you think to yourself- you know, I've been following this team/player for quite a while and I really do like them. And you don't know when exactly it started or how but when you realize it, then you're a fan.

Back to your particular issue, the Rockies are an easy choice. You have a good reason to like them in that they are you local team. They're also going to be easy to follow because they're your local team- this sounds like a silly thing, but it's easy to fall away from being a fan of a team if you can't follow them as easily. So, then, you can start following them and eventually you'll feel like you're an actual fan.

SI

I happen to think Milton Bradley is an okay guy with a bad temper.

cuervo72
09-16-2007, 11:07 PM
(The Phillies are too far and seriously, that's just a bad idea.)

Hahahahahahaha.

Very wise decision.

I'd go with the Nats. They could be in a very good position, and with Kasten should be run pretty well. Plus like you say, they have a pretty clean slate. I'm going to have a hard time rooting against them myself (really, it's not like I couldn't root for them and a 79-85 Phillies team at the same time).

EagleFan
09-16-2007, 11:09 PM
Phillies!!!! That way you can just sweep, sweep, sweep those Mets off your list.

Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins and Cole Hamels trump Over-Reyes and Wright easily.

RPI-Fan
09-16-2007, 11:18 PM
Astros!!!!!!!!!!!

Young Drachma
09-16-2007, 11:41 PM
Pick the Mets :).

Aside from my personal homer issues (I'm from Jersey), the point has been brought up that they have some great young talent in Reyes and Wright that'll be fun to watch for years. They do tend to spend money to win. And even though they are a NYC area team, they aren't the Yankees ;). This also has the added benefit of hating the Yankees and having an actual reason other than "they spend a lot of money and junk".

That's true. I do hate the Yankees, especially since they are the predominate reason that the Jays can't really compete in the AL East. Well that and incomptent GMs since Pat Gillick left.

As for "why do these threads?" Well, they're fun for one. But also....not everyone picks a team based on where they live. It wasn't a priority when I was coming up and choosing teams to root for, I was far more interested in other factors like players I like, a good foundation for the future and such alike. I picked the Jays when I was 12. My reasoning came down to liking Jack Morris and liking the team back when Sportscenter actually covered sports and did those "let's look at this team and see who they have and who they lost" during spring training. It helped that they won back-to-back World Series titles, that they were not a popular choice AND of course, they were at the time one of the best run franchises in baseball.

My how the times have changed.

I haven't been in the mountain west long enough to really embrace their teams or considering myself a "resident". I just live here. And yes, there is a difference. And the difference here is, fans aren't rabid about anything other than college sports and of course, the Broncos. They attend games, they'll cheer. But the passion is different than what I've seen in other parts of the country.

I can't embrace it or a lot of things about out here, so I think it still feels a bit weird rooting for one of their teams. But the Rockies would be the most likely of them that I'd support...and if they were anywhere else in the country with the same stadium and players, they'd be an easy choice. But since they're not..it makes it a bit more challenging.

Young Drachma
09-16-2007, 11:42 PM
Dola--

And in my case, there are several teams that I could be like "I've been following them for a while....and I like their players.." about and so, it's essentially a tie and I figure other fans can help break it. Because after all, what are sports teams without fans?

Pumpy Tudors
09-17-2007, 12:17 AM
I grew up as a Cardinals fan, I hate the Cubs, and you do have that St. Louis connection. With all that in mind, it is my opinion that you should start cheering for the Pirates.

Somehow, I became a Pirates fan after being a Cardinals fan first. You can do it, too. Also, you're a Devils fan like I am! Join Bucco Country!

Chief Rum
09-17-2007, 12:18 AM
Mets.

Reyes and Wright locked up to deals and they are 2 of the most exciting young players in the game

Reyes is one of the top ten players of the past 50 years.

Chief Rum
09-17-2007, 12:20 AM
I don't get these "help me pick a team" threads. It's not something you sit there, analyze, go "hm... I think this team will be good so I'll follow them despite having no other vested interest" and then viola, you're a fan. That's maybe a half step from being a fairweather fan. Why not just start liking the Yankees or Red Sox or something filthy like that?

So true. I mean if everyone did this, who would be a Royals fan? :p

Seriously, SI, all the love, hoping they keep off the Sox for last.

Ryche
09-17-2007, 12:49 AM
I'm joining the Rockies bandwagon, it looks like they'll be competitive the next few years. Can't wait to see my first game at Coors Field.

Young Drachma
09-17-2007, 01:12 AM
I'm joining the Rockies bandwagon, it looks like they'll be competitive the next few years. Can't wait to see my first game at Coors Field.

It's a nice looking ballpark, it really is. It's too bad you can't really see the mountains from there most days, but..it's a nice looking park, even after a decade.

It's still surreal as hell when the bats get to going, but....I was there last week and saw Jeff Francis and Greg Maddux duel it out and it was a quick game and little offense, but...its a nice place to take in a game. Especially compared to some other parks.

Toddzilla
09-17-2007, 07:17 AM
I would suggest you become a Cubs fan, because at this point in your life , you are willingly rooting for a team you know hasn't won a World Series in a century and probably won't in another century. As such, your expectations are tempered. You also get to see them on television a great deal, and if you're ever fortunate enough to go to a game in Wrigley Field, it's the best place to watch a baseball game ever. Similarly, if you ever go to a NL game in another stadium, there will always be a big contingent of Cubs fans.

Finally, should the Cubs ever actually win the World Series, you can take part in what will undoubtedly be the biggest celebration in the history of recorded civilization.

sterlingice
09-17-2007, 07:56 AM
So true. I mean if everyone did this, who would be a Royals fan? :p

Seriously, SI, all the love, hoping they keep off the Sox for last.

Already avoided 100 losses. Would have to go 9-5 to avoid 90 losses so that's probably out of reach. However, they're down to being 4th from the bottom again (i.e. 4th draft pick) and I'm kindof torn if I want them to do better or worse at this point. There's this logjam for worst with the Orioles, Royals, White Sox, and Devil Rays all within 2 games. And then 5 national league teams within 2 games of the Orioles, so the bottom 9 are all within 4 games of each other. Without much to play for at this point, I think I'd almost rather drop down to get a better draft pick. In a perfect world, I'd take them passing all 9 of these teams to best the best of the bad teams but I'd love another really high draft pick, too.

But we're getting way off track here.

SI

lungs
09-17-2007, 10:22 AM
I'd go with the Brewers.

Mustang
09-17-2007, 10:49 AM
Picking a team can't be done by this method. You have no other choice but to find someway to watch the Blue Jays.

korme
09-17-2007, 01:44 PM
TRADITION
http://sportslogos.net/images/teams/primaries/704.gif


http://sportslogos.net/images/teams/primaries/2916.gif


http://sportslogos.net/images/teams/primaries/706.gif


http://sportslogos.net/images/teams/primaries/705.gif

Young Drachma
09-17-2007, 01:46 PM
Picking a team can't be done by this method. You have no other choice but to find someway to watch the Blue Jays.

When they move to the National League, I sure will.

JimmyWint
09-17-2007, 02:56 PM
The Brewers are the easy choice. There is nowhere else where you can get brats with 'secret stadium sauce'! Plus, look at the great young talent they have. Lastly then you can join the masses that pee thier pants when they make the playoffs!

dawgfan
09-17-2007, 03:21 PM
I dunno - for me, rooting for a team other than my local team (the M's) just progressed naturally from rooting for particular players. When I was growing up and getting into baseball and baseball board games, I really took a liking to Pedro Guerrero - here was a great hitter producing well in a ballpark that favored pitching, and he seemed underrated by the national media. From there, I got even more hooked by taking an early appreciation for their young pitching, guys like Orel Hershiser and Alejandro Pena. I related to Hershiser and thought he had a cool pitching motion, and of course he was a pretty damn good pitcher.

So, by the time the Dodgers got to the W.S. in 1988, I was a fan, and that fandom was cemented by Kirk Gibson's homerun, Orel's amazing pitching streak that year and his tremendous performance in the playoffs that year and the underdog Dodgers taking out the A's.

My fandom for them faded in the early '90's as Guerrero was traded, Hershiser blew his arm out and the team started to drop from contention.

I don't have a favorite NL team anymore - I'm really just in "appreciate specific players" mode. I will say I was very intrigued by the Marlins last year - while everyone else (it seemed) was toasting them for seemingly giving up on a good nucleus with all their trades, I saw very clever re-stocking of their system and liked the group of young pitchers they'd acquired, along with my strong appreciation for Miguel Cabrera, and it was cool to see them do much better than expected.

EagleFan
09-17-2007, 07:21 PM
I'll say it again.... Phillies!!!!

Reyes, who's your daddy? Jimmy Rollins, that's who!!!

EagleFan
09-17-2007, 07:21 PM
:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D