Fantasy Trade Advice

[MikeVic]

Would you do this trade?

Carson Palmer and Shaun Alexander for Brian Westbrook and Laveranues Coles.

I have Palmer/Alexander. This is a 2-player keeper league, where you can keep one guy multiple years, but one guy only one year. I have Addai, and would be keeping Palmer as of this moment as my second... I'm currently in first place.

I was just thinking that Alexander's bad days are still ahead of him. I can maybe try to swap out Coles for Garrard or Schaub? I'm at about 75% no on this trade, but was wondering what FOFC thought.

Also... would you start Derrick Mason this week, or Stallworth? I'm leaning towards Stallworth. The Cowboys' secondary could get lit up.

[rowech]

Sorry....are you nuts? Westbrook can't survive a season and Coles has nobody to throw to him. I wouldn't trade Palmer by himself for Westbrook and Coles.

[sterlingice]

What he said

SI

[Toddzilla]

Unless your backup QB is Brady or Manning AND you'd be replacing an empty spot/non-contributor with Coles, this is a dreadful deal for you.

[MikeVic]

Thanks, I'm not thinking clearly. :)