Celebrity Hot or Not 2.0, Vol. 74: Sarah Michelle Gellar

[DanGarion]

So Rachel McAdams raked in a solid 78.67% placing 20th overall. Next up is everyone's favorite vampire slayer, Sarah Michelle Gellar. I was a huge fan for the show but I always considered Gellar the 3rd or 4th best looking woman on the show. Let's see what the majority here think of Mrs. Prinze.

<iframe width='900' height='800' frameborder='0' src='https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?hl=en_US&hl=en_US&key=0Av8FbkRqCjBbdGhfNHNXSlk5cmtzd04wNXluRmtkaWc&single=true&gid=0&output=html&widget=true'></iframe>

[DanGarion]

http://i.imgur.com/t4jEJl.jpg http://i.imgur.com/i8mTsl.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/nwU0ul.jpg http://i.imgur.com/YI377l.jpg

[CrimsonFox]

reserved for hotness

[DaddyTorgo]

Is this "current" or "at her peak?"

I dunno how she looks these days...

[panerd]

http://www.sfbrain.co.uk/sf/smg/me227_sarah_michelle_gellar_009.jpg
Hot

[cougarfreak]

No question here. Hot. Very hot. Smokin' hot.

[CrimsonFox]

3739

37403741

[Matthean]

Never did anything for me. Wasn't even the hottest chick on her own show.

:popcorn:

[PurdueBrad]

Panerd posted the first image that popped into my head thinking of Sarah Michelle Gellar, definitely hot.

[CrimsonFox]

I actually didn't intend to vote hot, then looked at the various pictures I found, then thought, "who am I kidding..."

*drooooooooooooool*

[Rizon]

Is that her body in the red bikini picture? I don't remember her having cannons like that.

[cuervo72]

Yeah, I think that's a 'shop.

[PurdueBrad]

Is that her body in the red bikini picture? I don't remember her having cannons like that.

I was wondering the same thing. I was assuming it was photoshopped.

I do admit, per my previous post, I did almost say that "Panerd nailed the imagine in my head..." but that put a very different image in my head! :(

[CrimsonFox]

sorry if it is. Am just googlin.

[JediKooter]

Not ugly by any stretch, but, not hot enough to get into the the 'hot' category.

[CrimsonFox]

there, photoshop removed.

Then again the other pics were hotter anyway.

[JonInMiddleGA]

I dunno how she looks these days...

That first pic, in the blue dress, is her at the 2012 Golden Globes

[JonInMiddleGA]

DT hit the nail on the head I think, are we voting on today's SMG or the historical SMG? The former is a narrow run thing, the latter is an easy yes.

Ultimately I'm going with Hot here, she's not fallen that far off the mark with the passage of time & I've got a good enough memory of her peak for her to remain hot enough to get the vote.

[CrimsonFox]

doesn't matter when you vote for her. We voted for susanna hoff thinking of the 80s susanna hoff. You can think of her whenever you want.

[claphamsa]

hottest ever! petite cheerleader type who could beat the ever living shit out of you... how can you not love that?

[Buccaneer]

doesn't matter when you vote for her. We voted for susanna hoff thinking of the 80s susanna hoff.

Don't use the royal "we" when you are making false assumptions.

[Buccaneer]

hottest ever! petite cheerleader type who could beat the ever living shit out of you... how can you not love that?

Because unless you were a pre-teen or a teen when that show was on, one could think the show (and the acting) was stupid?

[CrimsonFox]

Don't use the royal "we" when you are making false assumptions.

i use we because most of the susanna hoff pictures posted were 80s pictures. And many of the comments made were about her in her prime. That really goes for everyone really. People make comments about candidates from various time periods. Obviously we aren't voting for people the way they look THIS SECOND. And it's easy enough to compare hotness across decades. (an 80s babe vs a 2000's babe. The hotness speaks for itself.

[DanGarion]

Because unless you were a pre-teen or a teen when that show was on, one could think the show (and the acting) was stupid?

Totally disagree. Wasn't a teen when when it started. And honestly disagree that the acting was stupid. It's still has a lot of rewatchability. My wife that never watched it before has now watched the whole series twice in the past 2 years and loves it.

[DanGarion]

You guys have a very screwed up notion of time. Buffy the vampire slayer was on from 1997-2003. And Sarah Michelle Gellar is only 34 years old. In the 80's she would have been 5-15 years old...

[CrimsonFox]

she dies hot too...

<iframe width="480" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/3uFjIAIkrqQ" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

[Matthean]

We voted for susanna hoff thinking of the 80s susanna hoff. You can think of her whenever you want.

She's still attractive enough to get a hot vote from me.

[Izulde]

This is a borderline case for me. At her peak, hot as hell, but 34 and aging that fast suggests her peak was very short.

[lighthousekeeper]

just can't see past the bulbous-dropping-down-to-her-lip nose

[CrimsonFox]

This is a borderline case for me. At her peak, hot as hell, but 34 and aging that fast suggests her peak was very short.


i thought you were all about girl's peaks

[cody8200]

All time favorite pic of her from my youth http://images.t-nation.com/forum_images/1/0/1095842.1149553860259.sarah_michelle_gellar_5.jpg

[cuervo72]

Cute, but I don't think I'd go hot.

[Autumn]

This one will take some thought. My first thought is Not - she's fairly attractive but never quite did it for me. The nose bugs me. But I remember her being pretty hot in that Dangerous Liaisons knock-off.

[Caine]

If we'rd going Buffy chicks, we should do a Hot or Not on Allyson Hannigan.

[stevew]

If we'rd going Buffy chicks, we should do a Hot or Not on Allyson Hannigan.

I bet she won't crack 33%

[JonInMiddleGA]

I bet she won't crack 33%

Unless we do a poll about "reasonably cute chicks that look like good candidates for a FWB", her numbers probably wouldn't be all that great.

[cody8200]

http://www.holytaco.com/wp-content/uploads/images/2009/alyson_hannigan_hot_girl_schoolgirl.jpg<br>
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-PcROIKO4FKM/Twe4_0AmI3I/AAAAAAAAGT4/KyFm02Ott-M/s1600/alyson_hannigan_alyson_hannigan.jpg

[Rizon]

No "I'd hit it with my wooden stake" jokes yet? Ya'lls disappoint me.

[sabotai]

Alyson Hannigan is near the top of the cuteness meter. However, to me, she's the perfect example of the "cute, not hot" type of girl.

(Not that that's a bad thing to me. I'm more attracted to cute chicks than I am to hot chicks.)

[Matthean]

Alyson doesn't stand out for me either. Again, it's another case of where there are clearly better looking women on the show she is on either with Buffy or HIMYM.

[spleen1015]

No fucking way Alyson Hannigan is hot.

[DanGarion]

No fucking way, Alyson Hannigan is hot.

FTFY.

[Logan]

I think there's a couple times watching HIMYM where I've thought Alyson Hannigan would fall under "pretty", but it's few and far between. Her entire acting persona is built around being cute.

[CrimsonFox]

All time favorite pic of her from my youth http://images.t-nation.com/forum_images/1/0/1095842.1149553860259.sarah_michelle_gellar_5.jpg

oh baby....yeah I can see why that's your favorite :)

[Matthean]

In terms of Buffy


http://newspaper.li/static/b39a9365cb6ec0b17174d5f56ac9ed13.jpg

[JediKooter]

I'll save all of my comments for Allyson Hannigan when she gets her time in CHoN.

Needless to say though, she's on the short list for any future Mrs. Jedikooter. If there were to ever be one again.

[spleen1015]

FTFY.

???

[CrimsonFox]

FiFTY?

[stevew]

Fixed this for you.

[CrimsonFox]

WTET!

[PurdueBrad]

No fucking way Alyson Hannigan is hot.

+1

I was amazed to see comments that Hannigan was hot. I figured her's would be a landslide of not, guess I'll be surprised when we get to her.

[stevew]

I never watched Buffy, maybe saw like 5 or so episodes. I always thought Hannigan was funny looking. Like the female Steve Buscemi.

[CrimsonFox]

I never watched Buffy either. I think I tried it and disliked it. And I've never thought anything about Gellar. It's seeing Gellar outside of Buffy that I'm now thinking...wow she's amazing looking.

[PurdueBrad]

I never watched Buffy, maybe saw like 5 or so episodes. I always thought Hannigan was funny looking. Like the female Steve Buscemi.

Ha, that's a great way to put it.

[CrimsonFox]

HA! I think even Steve would find her fugly.

[Raiders Army]

SMG is superhot.

[Danny]

Gets an auto yes vote from me, I had a crush on Buffy when I was an early teen. Pretty sure only time my dad walked in on me mastering my own domain was while watching her on buffy.

[Autumn]

Five hours and no one's got a comment on that ...

[JediKooter]

Five hours and no one's got a comment on that ...

There's some redundancy in that post too.

[Autumn]

I was sure I could come up with something, but was left empty-handed.

[JediKooter]

I'm sure you were spent after trying to come up with something.

[Autumn]

It was harder and took a lot longer than anyone expected.

[JediKooter]

Sounds like you pulled through though.

[CrimsonFox]

Clean this thread up!

[Autumn]

Sorry, dad.

[Danny]

Sorry, dad.

No words were ever spoken about that event

[EagleFan]

Hate to say it but she hasn't been aging well. She was smoking hot in her prime but that hasn't translated to where she is now and she seemed to lose it quickly (like there was about a 3-4 year window of smoking hot).

[EagleFan]

SMG was superhot.

Fixed it for ya... :)

[Danny]

Hate to say it but she hasn't been aging well. She was smoking hot in her prime but that hasn't translated to where she is now and she seemed to lose it quickly (like there was about a 3-4 year window of smoking hot).

I haven't seen her in anything since Buffy / cruel intentions. I'd prefer that SMG be the one always implanted in my mine

[EagleFan]

More recent... meh
http://hairstyles.thehairstyler.com/hairstyle_views/front_view_images/296/original/9024_Sarah-Michelle-Gellar_copy_2.jpg

Now back in the Buffy days... hell yeah!
http://www.tv-reviewed.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/sarah-gellar.jpg

[OldGiants]

Pee Wee Herman was never caught jacking off in a movie theater while watching a SMG flick.

That's all, Folks.

[Capital]

Always thought hot...loved her in Cruel Intentions...