Front Office Football Central

Front Office Football Central (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//index.php)
-   Werewolf Games (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//forumdisplay.php?f=31)
-   -   Werewolf LVIII: Clash of the Gods (GAME OVER) (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//showthread.php?t=61606)

Alan T 10-21-2007 08:41 PM

Werewolf LVIII: Clash of the Gods (GAME OVER)
 
Cronus, the youngest of the Titans has just killed his father Uranus, and has claimed the title of ruler of the entire universe. Cronus's sister/wife Rhea in order to stop his reign of terror hid away their child Zeus on the isle of Crete. After being raised to adulthood in hiding, Zeus has finally come back to lead the assault upon Cronus's rule. With the help of several other titans and fellow Gods, will the Olympians be strong enough to overthrow the ruler of the heavens?

Game moderator note: While I would have preferred this game to be called "Clash of the Titans" or "War of the Titans", I was afraid that similarities to the 1981 movie would confuse people to thinking that was the theme of this game. This game might include some characters from that story, but it is based upon Greek mythology in a much broader sense. Some characters or story lines may have been moderated to enable the flow of this game to be improved.

Alan T 10-21-2007 08:41 PM

Gameclock:
------------------------------------------------------------------------

The gameday will consist of one 24 hour gameturn each day. 10pm EST will signify the end of each game day and the start of the next day. Each player will have a vote action as well as personal actions that will be due by 10pm EST each day. Any actions received after the 10pm deadline will count for the next day. The game day officially ends once the board clock hits 10pm EST. Thus, any post marked at 10:00pm EST will be after the day deadline and count for the next day.

Weekend play:

We will play an extended weekend play time in order to not have the game to go stagnent, but to allow for a longer period of time to respond. The weekend play will consist of one game day that lasts from 10pm EST Friday night until 10pm EST Sunday night.

Schedule problems:

In the case that any player has issues with scheduling for a day and need to provide conditional orders/votes, please contact me via PM as soon as possible so we can work out a solution for you.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Characters:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

This list includes some of the characters that may be in play during this game. There is also always the possibility of additional characters being in the game that is not included in this list:

Evil Titans:
-----------------------
Cronus
Coeus - Titan of Intelligence
Crius - the "Ram"
Hyperion - God of observation
Atlas
Campe - She-dragon with a woman's head and torso with a scorpion like tail.

Other titans:
-----------------------
Gigantes
----
Alcyoneus
Porphyrion
----
Hecatonchires
----
Briareus (The Vigorous)
Cottus (The furious)
Gyes (The Big limbed)
----
Cyclops
----
Arges
Brontes
Sterioes

Monsters:
-----------------------
Medusa
Kraken
Minotaur


Gods:
-----------------------
Zeus - Ruler of the Gods
Hades - The king of the underworld
Poseidon - God of the Waters
Hestia - Goddess of the Hearth
Demeter - Goddess of Fertility
Hera - Goddess of Marriage and Womanhood
Ares - God of War
Hermes - Messenger of Heaven
Hephaestus - The Smith of Olympus
Aphrodite - The goddess of tender passions
Athena - Goddess of Warriors, industries and prudent intelligence
Apollo - God of prophecy and music
Artemis - Goddess of hunters
Hebe - The goddess of youth
Dionysus - god of the cultivaton of the vine
Persephone - Queen of the underworld
Asclepius - God of medicine

Mankind:
------------------------
Heracles - Greatest hero of mankind
Odysseus - King of Ithaca
Achilles - Hero of the trojan war.
Perseus - Founder of Mycenae

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The teams:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Titans:
The Titans, under the rule of Cronus rule the heavens and earth. With the help of various other monsters, they look to remain in power. Keep in mind that not all players that are "Titans" will be for this team. Several Titans will be alligned with the Olympians during this game. All players will be informed in their PM what team they are working for (if any).

The Olympians: Led by Zeus, the Olympians seek to overthrow Cronus from rule with the help of various other titans and heros of mankind. If you are a titan that is sympathetic to the Olympians' cause or a hero of mankind that wins with the Olympians, your PM will inform you as such.

Other: Several roles may have individual victory conditions that do not fall within the scope of the above two teams. Individuals will be informed as such if that case applies to them.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Victory Conditions:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Titans:
You will win the game if you eliminate Zeus, Hades, Poseidon from the game as well as have a 1:1 Titan to Olympian ratio. Note: this does include Titans that are sympathetic to the Olympians cause as a Titan in this ratio.

Olympians: You will win the game if you eliminate all of the Titans that are working with Cronus. This does not include any monsters that may be teamed up with them, or any Titans that are sympathetic to the Olympians cause.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Daily Actions:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Each player receives 5 Action points (or APs) for each day. They must use at least 1 AP for a vote each day. Players that fail to place a vote for the day will not be allowed to use any APs for other actions during that day, and will be limited to only 1 AP for the following day which must be used for a vote.

Each player also has at least one individual action that they may choose to perform during the day. Any player that has multiple individual or team actions to choose from is limited to only one vote and one other action per day.

As all players are limited to only 1 vote and 1 action per day, they may use the remaining 3 Action points (APs) to further "strengthen" their votes or actions. Each AP spent on a vote will be counted in the final total. The player with the most votes is not lynched, it is the player with the most vote action points that is lynched at the end of the day. Likewise a player may choose to use further action points to strengthen their actions as well. A night kill action with 4 APs used will overwhelm a Bodyguard action with only 2 APs used for instance. In the case of actions conflicting with one another, a winning action will not always completely negate the losing action, but it will have the favorable outcome. ie: the bodyguard action listed above may fail, but they may be able to recognise who the assailant was.

Important note: Your Vote must be posted in the thread such as:

VOTE Alan T

You should send any other day actions as well as the number of Action points used for each via PM to me. Everyone else in the game does not get to know how many APs you spent that day and for what.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Email/PM/IM communication:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Players should not communicate with other players in this game outside of this thread in any topic regarding this game unless your PM clearly states that such communication is allowed.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rules or Roles may be modified if needed or gameplay may be changed if needed during the course of the game if it is determined necessary in order to maintain the integrity of the game. If there are any questions or comments regarding this rule set, please send me a PM and I will respond as quick as I can.

Alan T 10-21-2007 08:41 PM

1) Render - Killed Day 3 Hermes / Olympian
2) Barkeep - Killed Day 2 Zeus / Olympian
3) Chief Rum
4) PurdueBrad - Killed Day5 Hera / Independant Olympian
5) St.Cronin
6) Neon_Chaos
7) Lathum - Lynched Day 5 Heracles / Mortal Hero
8) ntndeacon - Lynched Day 2 Dionysus / Olympian
9) ArlingtonColt - Lynched Day 6 Hephaestus / Olympian
10) Passacaglia - Killed Day 1 Athena / Olympian
11) Telle
12) Hoopsguy - Killed Day 4 Hades / Olympian
13) Path12 - Lynched Day 1 Cronus / Titan
14) Anxiety
15) Ardent_Enthusiast - Lynched Day 4 Atlas / Titan
16) Racer - Killed Day 5 Hyperion / Titan
17) DaddyTorgo
18) Raiders Army - Killed Day 6 Apollo / Olympian
19) Schmidty - Lynched Day 3 Minotaur / Monster

RendeR 10-21-2007 08:43 PM

IN!


YAY I'm the irst one IN ! Whoooot!

Barkeep49 10-21-2007 08:47 PM

I am purposefully not signing up now since Render beat me as the first one in :)

On a more serious note when you looking to start?

Barkeep49 10-21-2007 08:48 PM

DOLA: And I know I read somewhere that you said your next game was going to be Wall Street. What happened to that? I thought it was an awesome theme for WW.

Chief Rum 10-21-2007 08:51 PM

Maybe it's financial gods. :)

I'm in. Hopefully this time, y'all won't kill me right away for being "suspiciously absent" from the game on Mondays and Tuesdays. :rolleyes:

PurdueBrad 10-21-2007 08:55 PM

I'm in as well.

st.cronin 10-21-2007 08:56 PM

I'll play.

Alan T 10-21-2007 08:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1575926)
DOLA: And I know I read somewhere that you said your next game was going to be Wall Street. What happened to that? I thought it was an awesome theme for WW.


I am looking to start early this week (tuesday/wednesday) if ther eis enough interest. As for what happened to Wall street, well long story short.. I had forgotten when I said that would be my next game, but I still have the rule set for that in my folder. I had originally changed my next game to be "Black and White" but have tabled that one until later. This ruleset I think will hopefully be one of my best games yet and one I worked up before I actually ran my Tombstone game. I just wanted to get a feel for what I needed to lock down on wide open games where everyone has actions before I rolled out this game.

Hopefully everyone will enjoy it. Its not overly complex, but it gives everyone a chance to contibute :)

st.cronin 10-21-2007 09:04 PM

Alan's games are always great; I think he's my favorite ww-host. Tombstone and the Big City I think are my two favorite games ever.

Chief Rum 10-21-2007 09:07 PM

Agreed. I don't know if either of his games I have palyed in were my favorite (haven't really played that all out in my mind), but I know I had a blast in both of his games, playing a hooker sheriff in one and a neutral bookie in the other.

Neon_Chaos 10-21-2007 09:09 PM

In.

Lathum 10-21-2007 09:35 PM

Tombstone was easily in my yop 2 games.


In

Any idea about the weekend schedule, I won't really be available next weekend

Alan T 10-21-2007 10:00 PM

Rule set posted. If there is any questions regarding how the actionpoints/actions/voting happens, please feel free to ask those questions now and I will happily answer them. That is the only really different part of this game to understand, so I wish to not have that affect the game play. I will make sure to spell things out as we go as well so there is not unintentional confusion.

(Barkeep, was your posting a signup earlier, or are you not signed up? Wasn't sure if I put you down or not) :)

Alan T 10-21-2007 10:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lathum (Post 1575964)
Tombstone was easily in my yop 2 games.


In

Any idea about the weekend schedule, I won't really be available next weekend


Weekend schedule will be extended play. Friday -> Sunday night = 1 day. I'm moving next weekend so I won't be around a ton next weekend either.

ntndeacon 10-21-2007 10:38 PM

in

ArlingtonColt 10-22-2007 07:20 AM

In

Passacaglia 10-22-2007 08:43 AM

In.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 09:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1575998)
(Barkeep, was your posting a signup earlier, or are you not signed up? Wasn't sure if I put you down or not) :)


I refused to sign-up at that time. I will, however, sign up now :)

Lathum 10-22-2007 09:22 AM

how about a thread in the GD?

Alan T 10-22-2007 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lathum (Post 1576165)
how about a thread in the GD?


Put one there this morning :) I assume we'll have more people fill in the next few hours. As long as I have a decent amount of players by tonight I will start the game with PMs sent out and day 1 will end on Wednesday morning at 10am EST. I don't need 20 players for this game to work, but as with most of my games like this, the more people there are the more fun that happens for everyone's roles :)

Telle 10-22-2007 10:01 AM

I'll play.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 10:10 AM

I'm in as long as we start early in the week. If the date gets pushed back very far I won't be able to do this as next weekend is hosed.

So if I'm a villager I'm asking the wolves to remove me by Day 5 or so :) If I'm a wolf I expect to be scanned or do something stupid to get run without needing much help.

Lathum 10-22-2007 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576212)
I'm in as long as we start early in the week. If the date gets pushed back very far I won't be able to do this as next weekend is hosed.

So if I'm a villager I'm asking the wolves to remove me by Day 5 or so :) If I'm a wolf I expect to be scanned or do something stupid to get run without needing much help.


why should this game be any different then others?

path12 10-22-2007 10:31 AM

Once again I'm about to take a break but can't really miss a game Alan is running......no matter how awfully I'm playing at the moment.

Sign me up.

Abe Sargent 10-22-2007 10:42 AM

In

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lathum (Post 1576217)
why should this game be any different then others?


I've seen plenty of wolves leave me alive when my theories are dumb. I'm asking them not to because I'll be unable to post my dumb theories for a couple of days near the end of next week. So that part is a little different - usually I'm around to post new dumb theories each and every day.

st.cronin 10-22-2007 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576239)
I've seen plenty of wolves leave me alive when my theories are dumb.


:)

Abe Sargent 10-22-2007 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576239)
I've seen plenty of wolves leave me alive when my theories are dumb. I'm asking them not to because I'll be unable to post my dumb theories for a couple of days near the end of next week. So that part is a little different - usually I'm around to post new dumb theories each and every day.


*Raises Hand*

Passacaglia 10-22-2007 11:15 AM

Or maybe they just want to end your streak of never getting lynched as a villager.

Alan T 10-22-2007 12:35 PM

Just an update, We have 14 signed up now, which is enough for a good WW game. I'll leave signups open until tonight just in case anyone else wants to join in. I'll close up signups some point after 9pm EST tonight and send out roles/information tonight.

Day 1 will run from when Roles go out tonight until Tuesday night 10pm EST. Deadline will be Tuesday night.



Lathum 10-22-2007 12:53 PM

perfect, lets get going!!!!!

RendeR 10-22-2007 02:04 PM

woohoo

Poli 10-22-2007 02:25 PM


Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 02:36 PM

You spelled 'in' wrong.































:D

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 02:47 PM

Welcome Back Ardent.

Racer 10-22-2007 03:12 PM

I'll play.

saldana 10-22-2007 05:29 PM

as much as i would love to, i am out...i have a deal with my wife that i dont play game after game after game, and i have already played 2 in a row, so i gotta sit one or two out.

RendeR 10-22-2007 05:35 PM

But I need you in the next game! I have 3 perfect roles for you, special!

RendeR 10-22-2007 05:36 PM

BTW do you look better as a redhead, brunette or blonde?

saldana 10-22-2007 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RendeR (Post 1576556)
BTW do you look better as a redhead, brunette or blonde?


i have no hair.

Alan T 10-22-2007 05:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RendeR (Post 1576556)
BTW do you look better as a redhead, brunette or blonde?



lol best setup question ever.

Alan T 10-22-2007 06:09 PM

I have the 16 roles picked that will be in the game if this is the list of final players. I ideally actually would like one additional player to help balance out one specific thing, but if not I will be sending out roles in a little while. I am just giving another hour or so for last chance to sign up for people. I figure if they haven't signed up by now they likely won't anyways though :)

DaddyTorgo 10-22-2007 06:42 PM

dammit. I'm in, but just because it's an alan t game

Raiders Army 10-22-2007 06:42 PM

Looks good to me. Sign me up Uncle Alfred.

Schmidty 10-22-2007 06:48 PM

I'll play.

Alan T 10-22-2007 06:56 PM

I am glad that everyone has decided to join up. I hope you find this game fair, challenging and entertaining! I have closed the signups and will be sending out PMs in a few minutes. It might take a bit of time for all PMs to go out. The game will officially start once all PMs have been sent out.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 06:58 PM

Just for the record since the Titans is intertwined with the the Olympians/Heroes, I will be referring to evil doers as the wolves and to good guys as villagers, since it seems to have a standard dynamic in terms of win conditions and such.

Alan T 10-22-2007 07:48 PM

All PMs have been sent out. If you did not receive one and expect that you should have, please drop me a PM to let me know. Also if you have questions regarding your role or how Action points work with it, please let me know in PM.

Day 1 Starts now:

Zeus has called forth upon all Olympians to help him lead the charge against the cruel Titan lord Cronus. In a fight that the earths and heavens has never seen before, and likely never will see again you must draw upon all of your power to overcome your adversity. You must now decide whom among you are the Titans hiding in disguise.. Pick one today for your lynch vote and the player with the most vote points at the end of the day will be destroyed.

All players must place a Vote in this thread such as:

VOTE ALAN T

the number of points you wish to spend on the vote as well as any actions should be PM'd in private to me.

Deadline is Tuesday night 10pm EST

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 07:58 PM

Hmm, who is more likely to have this role - Ardent or Schmidty? Discuss.

Quote:

Cottus (The furious)

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 07:59 PM

Checking in.

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576635)
Hmm, who is more likely to have this role - Ardent or Schmidty? Discuss.


Render.

:)

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:06 PM

Can we unvote or is the AP spent once we cast the vote?

Passacaglia 10-22-2007 08:11 PM

Hey all. I am an Olympian.

Alan T 10-22-2007 08:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1576640)
Can we unvote or is the AP spent once we cast the vote?


Everyone has to cast a vote every day, or they forfeit their other Actionpoints any ways. You can change who you vote for as many times as you want during the day however by posting the update in the thread. You can also change how many Action points you spend and for what as many times as you want in PM to me.

Passacaglia 10-22-2007 08:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Passacaglia (Post 1576643)
Hey all. I am an Olympian.


Or maybe I should say, I am Olympian.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:22 PM

So we're not really going to know where we're at in this game, really, in terms of voting.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 08:25 PM

I'm guessing there is no indication of who spent how many action points, but just a total "votes" listed for each at the end of the day?

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:27 PM

Ok since hoops is back and I went away from my "hoops is always a wolf" suspicion last game when he was a friggin wolf, he's got my D1 vote this game as a result this game.

Vote hoopsguy

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 08:33 PM

Perfect logic, BK.

So, I'm doing some thinking on the voting for today. Is there a compelling reason on Day 1 to put extra votes in on a candidate? Obviously as we learn more information it makes sense to try and influence a good vote, but the ability to spend extra points adds another dynamic to measure when evaluating votes. I don't see how this is going to be pro-Olympian at the outset.

Thoughts?

PurdueBrad 10-22-2007 08:39 PM

I am Olympia (and so can you!) for the Stephen Colbert fans out there.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576651)
Perfect logic, BK.

It's a d1 vote. Let's not read more into it than that.

Quote:

So, I'm doing some thinking on the voting for today. Is there a compelling reason on Day 1 to put extra votes in on a candidate? Obviously as we learn more information it makes sense to try and influence a good vote, but the ability to spend extra points adds another dynamic to measure when evaluating votes. I don't see how this is going to be pro-Olympian at the outset.

Thoughts?

I'm also concerned about people being able to manipulate the votes behind the scenes as I've already commented on. I'm not sure the best way to combat that.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576651)
Perfect logic, BK.

So, I'm doing some thinking on the voting for today. Is there a compelling reason on Day 1 to put extra votes in on a candidate? Obviously as we learn more information it makes sense to try and influence a good vote, but the ability to spend extra points adds another dynamic to measure when evaluating votes. I don't see how this is going to be pro-Olympian at the outset.

Thoughts?


I can't see any good reason to put more than one vote action or whatever the points are given.


I wonder if we get to know the total actions taken vs an individual?

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ntndeacon (Post 1576655)
I can't see any good reason to put more than one vote action or whatever the points are given.


I wonder if we get to know the total actions taken vs an individual?

You think people will just let the APs go to waste?

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 08:44 PM

Ooooh, the gauntlet has been thrown by BK. :D

I am assuming that there are certain win conditions and situations that would restrict us from revealing who we are (other than the Olympians that the Titan must kill). Because if not, we can all reveal and weed out the Titans easily.

On second thought, Alan T has probably designed the roles to prevent that from happening.

Right?

:)

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 08:44 PM

dola

another question...

can these points be hoarded. use our one action on a vote and that is it or one on a vote and one on an action and hoard the rest?

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 08:46 PM

*Titans

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 08:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1576657)
You think people will just let the APs go to waste?


no, but if we know vote action totals, that would be a big help in determining extra actions there. It might narrow the field we are looking at in certain cases.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neon_Chaos (Post 1576658)
Ooooh, the gauntlet has been thrown by BK. :D

I am assuming that there are certain win conditions and situations that would restrict us from revealing who we are (other than the Olympians that the Titan must kill). Because if not, we can all reveal and weed out the Titans easily.

On second thought, Alan T has probably designed the roles to prevent that from happening.

Right?

:)


Certainly true for the Nuetral Titans and monsters, but aren't the Titans favoring Olympus counted for the good guys now?

Alan T 10-22-2007 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ntndeacon (Post 1576660)
dola

another question...

can these points be hoarded. use our one action on a vote and that is it or one on a vote and one on an action and hoard the rest?


Points are either used each day or lost. You start the next day with the same number of points each day unless for some game reasons that you have a modified amount.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 08:50 PM

In terms of the points - using the example that Alan does in the rules, I would hope that our Olympian bodyguard would have max points available to protect on Night 1 if we can't bank the points.

Again, I think there is increasing value to backing the votes with action points later in the game. Just not so much on Day 1. It is going to be hard enough to figure out what people are doing with their votes/points without adding that element on a day where we are essentially flying blind.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:50 PM

I would think Alan's designed a game to account for a mass reveal after that worked so successfully recently but I'm always game for it.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1576665)
Points are either used each day or lost. You start the next day with the same number of points each day unless for some game reasons that you have a modified amount.


I thought this was probably the case, but just to be sure I wanted it out there.

Alan T 10-22-2007 08:53 PM

Also remember each day is a 24 hour cycle. There is no night/day periods here. All actions must be submitted by 10pm EST Tuesday night as well.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:54 PM

I'll say now that my power isn't so clear cut that I will want to invest 4 points in it, like the BG would.

Hoops: I agree that if some people are using their powers come Day 4 and you're spending 5 points on voting that you will have a large effect. We saw last game the large effect someone can have even just having 2 votes compared to someone else's 1, or 0. The relative imbalance will be even more this game.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1576668)
I would think Alan's designed a game to account for a mass reveal after that worked so successfully recently but I'm always game for it.


Given that the Titans are hunting for three Olympians in their victory condition, I'm guessing that a mass reveal is not an optimal play.

Getting harder not to read anything into the early vote ...

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1576668)
I would think Alan's designed a game to account for a mass reveal after that worked so successfully recently but I'm always game for it.


I am up for it if everyone is on-board with it.

But, yeah, I would think that Alan would have worked some mechanism to make sure a mass-reveal wouldn't be as successful as it was before.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576678)
Given that the Titans are hunting for three Olympians in their victory condition, I'm guessing that a mass reveal is not an optimal play.

Getting harder not to read anything into the early vote ...

Why? So what if the three Olympians reveal if we've found the Titans. The Olympians shouldn't reveal first but even if the Titans claimed one of them we'd be able to sort out pretty quickly who was telling the truth and who wasn't about that. Seems ot me like it would be a quick game if we got people on board with this.

Alan T 10-22-2007 08:59 PM

I would like to encourage people to not try the mass reveal strategy from a few games ago. I am not saying this because I feel that it will give the villagers an easy victory, but instead because i feel it will be giving the villagers an easy defeat. I put in a balance into the game to prevent a mass reveal from working (the same as PM sharing), and I can gurantuee that its unlikely that any titans would be caught from a mass reveal.

I am not preventing anyone from doing a reveal, but just want to make sure its known that there are safeguards in place as I don't want the game to go unbalanced the other direction.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 09:00 PM

I certainly don't want any narrowing of suspects for those Titans. And How many Titans are there.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 09:00 PM

Neon or Ardent - can either of you explain to me why a mass reveal would be good at all? There are so many names in the opening post that I really think that there would be a lot of room for people to hide in the latter stages.

Could we have someone make an early fake reveal? Maybe, but Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon are also going to want to fake reveal rather than give up their identity publicly. So they will be holding out until later to fake along with the Titans. The Titans know who they are, so we leave those three guys hung out to dry in a fake reveal scenario.

Again, I'm willing to be convinced but I'm surprised that two people I consider decent thinkers seem to be so at odds with my views right now.

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576678)
Given that the Titans are hunting for three Olympians in their victory condition, I'm guessing that a mass reveal is not an optimal play.

Getting harder not to read anything into the early vote ...


Note that their victory condition says that they must kill the three olympians AND get a 1:1 ratio with the villagers to win. I assume that we can weed out who's who before they meet all of those objectives. Unless of course, the ratio of Olympians and Titans aren't as great. Do we know if the humans count as Olympians as well? I'm thinking no.

What I'm weary about is if there are roles out there that might have a different victory condition.

But I'm all up for it.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1576684)
I would like to encourage people to not try the mass reveal strategy from a few games ago. I am not saying this because I feel that it will give the villagers an easy victory, but instead because i feel it will be giving the villagers an easy defeat. I put in a balance into the game to prevent a mass reveal from working (the same as PM sharing), and I can gurantuee that its unlikely that any titans would be caught from a mass reveal.

I am not preventing anyone from doing a reveal, but just want to make sure its known that there are safeguards in place as I don't want the game to go unbalanced the other direction.

Ok so my guess is that this means the Titans know which roles are actually in the game.

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1576684)
I would like to encourage people to not try the mass reveal strategy from a few games ago. I am not saying this because I feel that it will give the villagers an easy victory, but instead because i feel it will be giving the villagers an easy defeat. I put in a balance into the game to prevent a mass reveal from working (the same as PM sharing), and I can gurantuee that its unlikely that any titans would be caught from a mass reveal.

I am not preventing anyone from doing a reveal, but just want to make sure its known that there are safeguards in place as I don't want the game to go unbalanced the other direction.


Point taken, Alan T.

I assumed as much that there are mechanisms in place. And if it only gives easy defeat to the villagers, then let's forget about it.

Let's just have people reveal at the right time and the right moment so we can weed out the Titans properly.

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopsguy (Post 1576686)
Neon or Ardent - can either of you explain to me why a mass reveal would be good at all? There are so many names in the opening post that I really think that there would be a lot of room for people to hide in the latter stages.

Could we have someone make an early fake reveal? Maybe, but Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon are also going to want to fake reveal rather than give up their identity publicly. So they will be holding out until later to fake along with the Titans. The Titans know who they are, so we leave those three guys hung out to dry in a fake reveal scenario.

Again, I'm willing to be convinced but I'm surprised that two people I consider decent thinkers seem to be so at odds with my views right now.


It's just an idea, hoops. Granted, if Zeus/Hades/Poseidon also have different victory conditions, there is no reason why they can't sacrifice themselves to help weed out the Titans.

The point is moot, however. Seems like Alan T does have certain precautionary measures in place to make it unfavorable for the villagers to mass-reveal.

Alan T 10-22-2007 09:13 PM

Please note also that there are 4 "species" in the game. Titans, Monsters, Olympians and Mankind (humans). They count as different species in victory conditions, however various ones may be working with other teams and have been noted as such in their personal PM.

Titans must kill Zeus, Poseidon, Hades and come to a 1:1 ratio of titans in the game (even ones loyal to the Olympians) to Olympians (not counting monsters or humans).

Olympians must kill the Titans off completely (but does not have to kill off the monsters that may be assisting the Titans.)

Any other personal or small scale victory conditions have been noted in the PMs

DaddyTorgo 10-22-2007 09:15 PM

checking in. Been around but talking on the phone since PM's went out, so I didn't even read mine till just now.

Proud Olympian here.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 09:15 PM

Alan will we get a vote action total at the end of the day or just a winner and who voted for who (with no vote action total given)?

Schmidty 10-22-2007 09:16 PM

Hi.

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 09:16 PM

Ok so interesting dynamic: THe Olympians have people helping them who they need to kill. The Titans have people trying to thwart them who they need to keep alive. With 19 players I'm thinking there could be as many as 6, but more likely 5, titans in the game total with 3 bad guys, plus 2 other Neutral/Pro Olympian Titans.

DaddyTorgo 10-22-2007 09:16 PM

neon...hard push for a mass reveal buddy...what gives?

Barkeep49 10-22-2007 09:17 PM

So given the clarification from Alan, what about a mankind reveal?

Alan T 10-22-2007 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ntndeacon (Post 1576698)
Alan will we get a vote action total at the end of the day or just a winner and who voted for who (with no vote action total given)?


No one will know the final vote point total, just a list of whom voted for whom and who ended up dead. Vote points spent are a private thing between me, that player and anyone who might have a role to see such things.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1576695)
Please note also that there are 4 "species" in the game. Titans, Monsters, Olympians and Mankind (humans). They count as different species in victory conditions, however various ones may be working with other teams and have been noted as such in their personal PM.

Titans must kill Zeus, Poseidon, Hades and come to a 1:1 ratio of titans in the game (even ones loyal to the Olympians) to Olympians (not counting monsters or humans).

Olympians must kill the Titans off completely (but does not have to kill off the monsters that may be assisting the Titans.)

Any other personal or small scale victory conditions have been noted in the PMs


Olympians have to kill all of the Titans? ithought it was just those Loyal to Croeses. So we kill even the ones that have loyalty to the Olympians?

DaddyTorgo 10-22-2007 09:19 PM

no vote points makes it impossible to use that like we did in say the Rome game to try to hold people accountable.

ntndeacon 10-22-2007 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan T (Post 1576705)
No one will know the final vote point total, just a list of whom voted for whom and who ended up dead. Vote points spent are a private thing between me, that player and anyone who might have a role to see such things.


Gotcha. We could hope :)

Neon_Chaos 10-22-2007 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barkeep49 (Post 1576703)
So given the clarification from Alan, what about a mankind reveal?


That would be dangerous, Alan. If everyone doesn't reveal then the reveal doesn't work.

You narrow down the Olympians that the Titans must kill, and therefore, make it easier for the Olympians.

Mass reveals only work when everyone reveals.

hoopsguy 10-22-2007 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Schmidty (Post 1576699)
Hi.


Hi.

Alan T 10-22-2007 09:22 PM

To further clarify the victory conditions (since I am not sure those are clear, and this is the time to clarify things)

5 Titans (good or bad), 5 Olympians, 1 monster, 3 humans = Titan win if Zeus, Poseidon and Hades are dead. Titans only care about TItans compared to Olympians, they do not care about monster or human totals.

3 Titans (all good titans left), 4 Olympians, 2 monsters, 4 humans = Olympians win.
Olympians only care about the titans working with Cronus. They do not care about monsters or humans in their victory conditions.

Everyone else either wins with the Olympians or the Titans or have some other individual victory condition listed in their PM.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.