Originally Posted by dubb93 (Post 3050013)

Yea, well, the werewolf is "neutral evil." He's bad. He's not working with the mafia, but he's working for himself and I would guess his win condition is likely to kill everyone but himself.

Some of the neutral roles will have village friendly, if not entirely straight villager, win conditions. What I'm saying is that in Town of Salem some of the neutral roles will win with the village, some will win with the baddies, and some will win just by themselves.

It's not just going to be straight win with the mafia or win with the village. All of the neutral roles in Town of Salem have a condition that must first be met and then a "win by" following that.

For instance a role that I'm very familiar with from that game is the exe. It's in basically every Town of Salem game you will play as it's a default role. The exe is one that wins on his own. He must first get the town to lynch his target and then he must get himself lynched after that in order to win. He's not working with the town or the mafia.

Many of the killing roles that are in Town of Salem, such as the serial killer (another default role in that game), intentionally work against the mafia and one of their win conditions is to eliminate all of the mafia.

So by itself neutral doesn't mean bad. It depends on the actual role. With only 8 villagers (9 max if we got lucky with random) it probably is not prudent to just cast away all the neutral roles as evil. We will quickly find ourselves outnumbered and lacking key votes when we need them.

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox (Post 3050022)

can any role steal the win and win solo?

the survivor perhaps?

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox (Post 3050022)

can any role steal the win and win solo?

the survivor perhaps?

Originally Posted by dubb93 (Post 3050027)

I've never really seen the survivor in Town of Salem, but a quick guess based on how I know that game works I would say the survivor would win either way as long as he's alive, but be more willing to work with the village/non killing roles, since he doesn't want to get lynched or night killed.

I would say that the werewolf would likely be a role that could steal the win and win solo since he's neutral evil and unlikely to be working with anyone.

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox (Post 3050031)

what?

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox (Post 3050048)

cute :) but we could, ya know, actually play this game first.
(if you wanna...)

Originally Posted by timmae (Post 3050117)

vote danny

Until there is some proof of life there.

My action was blocked last night. Not sure what that means for other actions. I.e. Night kills.

There will be a ww attack tonight. Not good.

Originally Posted by Ziiggy (Post 3050136)

So in a goodtimmae world that would mean the mafia has an escort role (or a village blocker mistargeted) so at minimum there is the Godfather and an escort and they were either blocked last night, or didn't put in a kill order. Any other pertinent action during the night?

Originally Posted by britrock88 (Post 3050140)

(This conjecture doesn't account for the random role.)

Shoveler was the Escort and was killed by the WW. A role-block of someone in timmae's probably came from a Consort. As for the mafia, they may have failed to put in an order; had that order thwarted by the Doctor or Jailor; or been unsuccessful in attempting to NK the Survivor, Serial Killer, or Executioner.

Originally Posted by timmae (Post 3050117)

My action was blocked last night. Not sure what that means for other actions. I.e. Night kills.

Originally Posted by Danny (Post 3042754)

I will play. I just have to be better about remembering to come here and read and participate

Originally Posted by Chief Rum (Post 3050163)

Hey, guys, let's not be so quick to lynch him. It's likely Danny has forgotten to check back in. He did post after the game start, but it was only to offer condolences to EF over his friend's passing.

I sent Danny a FB message to remind him. Hopefully he will check in today.

Originally Posted by lighthousekeeper (Post 3050147)

well here's a paranoid theory: you are the godfather, your action was blocked last night, there were no kills last night. and you're just having fun by revealing some clues in broad daylight.

Originally Posted by EagleFan (Post 3050194)

Originally Posted by britrock88 (Post 3050186)

I don't think he would have known the identities of the folks that visited Autumn on N1 if he were the godfather, though.

Originally Posted by Ziiggy (Post 3050196)

Post 327 - is putting votes in the middle of a sentence a faux pas? If so, sorry won't do it again.