Front Office Football Central

Front Office Football Central (http://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//index.php)
-   FOF9, FOF8, and TCY Discussion (http://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//forumdisplay.php?f=33)
-   -   FOF8 Game Logs--Oh My! (http://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//showthread.php?t=92065)

Ben E Lou 11-24-2016 10:04 AM

FOF8 Game Logs--Oh My!
 
Pulling this out from the main thread as it deserves its own shout-out as a likely game-changer when it comes to evaluating players' performances.

The logs contain this information on every play, which tells us who effed up to allow the winning TD in this case:

1-10-WAS12 (4Q: 01:03) Harrison Iacuessa pass completed to WR Chris Hillhouse for 12 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Hillhouse gained 2 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. Washington 13, Dallas 13
OFFENSE113t Personnel, Weak formation, PistolDEFENSE34 Eagle, Nickel Personnel, Press-1
QB H.Iacuessa
***LDE L.ShullRush Passer+++
X(SE) L.BushSecondary, F Flat (0-4)+++NT B.MathisRush Passer+++
TE C.BensenOutlet, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++RDE K.MarquisRush Passer+++
Z(FL) C.HillhousePrimary, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++SLB T.RhodesShort Zone+++
RB G.StewartOutlet, W Wheel (9-18)+++SILB E.MontgomeryShort Zone---
SLOT R.SpearmanOutlet, 1 Out (5-8)+++WLB K.BanksShort Zone---
LT D.Stehlik
+++LCB K.RiordanBump and Run+++
LG K.Sawyer
+++RCB E.MunozBump and Run+++
C E.Hardman
+++NB P.HenryBump and Run+++
RG S.Rector
+++SS C.LyleDouble TE+++
RT R.Morrison
+++FS J.LeakeDeep Zone+++
(4Q: 01:03) Extra point by Jordan Osorio was good. Dallas 14, Washington 13



Ben E Lou 11-24-2016 10:05 AM

...and at the end of the log, there's this:

Informal Player Pariticipation Grades

DallasPlusMinusGrade
OLB Nolan McGregor90100%
WR Nate Newton40100%
DE Johnathan Noyes130100%
CB Luis Matthews70100%
ILB Jon Sanderson40100%
WR DeAndre Angel60100%
CB Jerald Knudsen40100%
CB Colton Lake70297%
TE Cooper Bensen48296%
S Ron Welch43296%
CB Derrick Pegues40295%
C Ethan Hardman55395%
T Devan Stehlik55395%
ILB Kyle Tubbs70593%
DT Patrick Nowlin41393%
DT J.R. Newhart12192%
OLB Edgar Di Pardo43491%
DT Ezra Page63691%
G Kevin Sawyer53591%
S Hector Gilliland72791%
CB Joey Mayes72791%
S C.J. Bonetta31391%
DE Roger De Boer60691%
WR Chris Hillhouse47590%
OLB Graham Agustoni62790%
WR Leslie Bush50689%
G Sean Rector51788%
DE Leon Kemp58888%
DT Kelvin Hawkins28488%
WR Rodolfo Spearman33587%
RB Gilbert Stewart19483%
T Rusty Morrison471181%
TE Dominic Perrone17577%
RB Dustin Weaver26876%
RB Trent Eddings3175%
TE A.J. Cherry010%
WashingtonPlusMinusGrade
WR Tanner Van Pelt20100%
CB Erick Munoz580100%
TE Kaleb Ding90100%
WR Cory Whiting10100%
RB Avery Norey220100%
DE Zane Zeppelin70100%
CB Kelly Riordan57198%
RB Zane Ginsberg45198%
DT Brayden Mathis49296%
WR Ramon Durand69495%
WR Randal Horton66494%
G Chad Lang74594%
S Caleb Lyle41393%
OLB Sedrick Gray13193%
S Terrence Wiegert13193%
WR Marco Wayne37393%
RB Austin Mills25293%
T Lincoln Simmons73692%
CB Dalton Reynolds11192%
S Josiah Leake53591%
ILB Howard Wells19290%
CB Patrick Henry27390%
T Isaiah Schultz71890%
TE Sherman Gilmore24389%
C Bo Titus70989%
G Zachery Humphries70989%
OLB Terrell Rhodes47689%
OLB Kim Banks39589%
DE Kaden Marquis45688%
TE Drake McCants681087%
ILB Emmitt Montgomery46787%
DT Zach McDaniel6186%
DE Johnathan Barrett6186%
DE Lawrence Shull43884%
OLB Albert Hernandez4180%

corbes 11-24-2016 10:10 AM

I had not scrolled all the way to the bottom of a log yet. Wow.

SlyBelle1 11-24-2016 10:24 AM

Yep, this is a nice addition to the game

Pyser 11-24-2016 10:37 AM

That's awesome...but please tell me that info is stored somewhere (player cards? Maybe when you click into specific season stats to see each game?). Otherwise sounds like it's time for Ben to write a new script! :)

Dawgfan19 11-24-2016 10:39 AM

The SS doubling the TE is interesting to note.

corbes 11-24-2016 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pyser (Post 3131321)
That's awesome...but please tell me that info is stored somewhere (player cards? Maybe when you click into specific season stats to see each game?). Otherwise sounds like it's time for Ben to write a new script! :)



+1
+1
+1
+1

PilotMan 11-24-2016 11:14 AM

No kidding. Wow!

But yeah, that's gotta go on the player card somewhere!!! Please!!

gstelmack 11-24-2016 11:20 AM

Would be great if this could be added to player stats.

If it's per-play data, it may be in the Solevision logs, which also means that either they have new info I have to parse, or it's been there all along and totally missed. I'll try and poke around soon and see what I can extract.

aston217 11-24-2016 11:26 AM

Participation grades! That's cool.

gstelmack 11-24-2016 11:49 AM

Solevision has definitely changed. Relative structure is the same, but the individual records are different and need some figuring. The depth chart is longer than it was, and the individual play records are new. Both are expected, but I'm going to need time to figure out what they mean. May need to turn it into a groupthink just to churn through it in a reasonable timeframe - my son is playing Classic-level soccer now so my time is more limited than it used to be.

johnnyshaka 11-24-2016 05:58 PM

Am I the only one who's curious about why the LBs in short zones get dinged on a comeback by an outside WR who is supposed to be covered by a CB?

perez24 11-24-2016 07:42 PM

SWEET!

I always wondered how you could assess how well everyone was doing...now I can.

Possibly my favorite game update since OOTP added doubleheaders!

mrbyte 11-25-2016 08:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben E Lou (Post 3131307)
Pulling this out from the main thread as it deserves its own shout-out as a likely game-changer when it comes to evaluating players' performances.

The logs contain this information on every play, which tells us who effed up to allow the winning TD in this case:

1-10-WAS12 (4Q: 01:03) Harrison Iacuessa pass completed to WR Chris Hillhouse for 12 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Hillhouse gained 2 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. Washington 13, Dallas 13
OFFENSE113t Personnel, Weak formation, PistolDEFENSE34 Eagle, Nickel Personnel, Press-1
QB H.Iacuessa
***LDE L.ShullRush Passer+++
X(SE) L.BushSecondary, F Flat (0-4)+++NT B.MathisRush Passer+++
TE C.BensenOutlet, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++RDE K.MarquisRush Passer+++
Z(FL) C.HillhousePrimary, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++SLB T.RhodesShort Zone+++
RB G.StewartOutlet, W Wheel (9-18)+++SILB E.MontgomeryShort Zone---
SLOT R.SpearmanOutlet, 1 Out (5-8)+++WLB K.BanksShort Zone---
LT D.Stehlik
+++LCB K.RiordanBump and Run+++
LG K.Sawyer
+++RCB E.MunozBump and Run+++
C E.Hardman
+++NB P.HenryBump and Run+++
RG S.Rector
+++SS C.LyleDouble TE+++
RT R.Morrison
+++FS J.LeakeDeep Zone+++
(4Q: 01:03) Extra point by Jordan Osorio was good. Dallas 14, Washington 13




Sorry to be a dud here but the logs generated in my game has nothing like the above. just the normal text with addition of who draws the penaltys. is there an option to turn this on or ...well what am I missing here where did the above come from?

Dutch 11-25-2016 08:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrbyte (Post 3131519)
Sorry to be a dud here but the logs generated in my game has nothing like the above. just the normal text with addition of who draws the penaltys. is there an option to turn this on or ...well what am I missing here where did the above come from?


There is an option to turn it on, it's not by default. :)

Check your game settings.

CONTROLS --> Options --> Edit Single-Player Options.

There ya go!

mrbyte 11-25-2016 08:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutch (Post 3131521)
There is an option to turn it on, it's not by default. :)

Check your game settings.

CONTROLS --> Options --> Edit Single-Player Options.

There ya go!


THANK YOU!! I had looked at that but just couldn't see it, if you know what I mean :)

garion333 11-25-2016 08:34 AM

Dutch is correct, in the options you want to put yes for "Add detailed information to game logs".

Firefly 11-25-2016 08:43 AM

Great new info! But wait, who effed up? The two guys in bold? It seems to me those guys might be the players who doubled-teamed a receiver. The play information says the QB threw away from double coverage, so how can two guys get burned in coverage?

Ben E Lou 11-25-2016 08:50 AM

2 YAC. Maybe missed tackle? Or I suppose it could be a "between the steams" kinda thing and neither helped like they should have.

EDIT: Or also, assuming the engine is similar to the past, maybe they screwed up on their assignments, causing someone else to have to lean in their direction. thus allowing the catch elsewhere? ("the center pancaked the MLB on that sweep and disorganized the defense" and all that...) I mean, my assumption is that every player gets a "did his job"/'did not do his job" dice roll on each play.

Firefly 11-25-2016 09:04 AM

Yes, the game is weird that way. And I assume you've seen enough logs to rule out that the guys in bold were the ones who double-covered a receiver. I've only see this one and so far.

Edit: Oh, I see you're not going by the bold print but by the minuses. Yes, that makes sense.

QuikSand 11-25-2016 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyshaka (Post 3131428)
Am I the only one who's curious about why the LBs in short zones get dinged on a comeback by an outside WR who is supposed to be covered by a CB?


I predict this line of questioning is going to get deep, in time. Even if the system is very good, we are bound to have quirks and questions that come up.

Ben E Lou 11-25-2016 09:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Firefly (Post 3131533)
Edit: Oh, I see you're not going by the bold print but by the minuses. Yes, that makes sense.

Oh, yeah. I bolded them myself; they're not like that in the log. The minuses are the key there.

Antmeister 11-25-2016 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben E Lou (Post 3131529)
2 YAC. Maybe missed tackle? Or I suppose it could be a "between the steams" kinda thing and neither helped like they should have.

EDIT: Or also, assuming the engine is similar to the past, maybe they screwed up on their assignments, causing someone else to have to lean in their direction. thus allowing the catch elsewhere? ("the center pancaked the MLB on that sweep and disorganized the defense" and all that...) I mean, my assumption is that every player gets a "did his job"/'did not do his job" dice roll on each play.



Yes, this is what I am gathering, the --- looks like they either messed up or were dominated in their assignment. Looking at my own game logs, there are plays where I got positive yardage, but it appears that there were players that still messed up their assignments.

In this example, my QB Rivers passed for 7 yards but I am geeked on the info it gives here. While the LT and RB messed up their blocking assignments, the QB had enough time to recognize and throw away from the Primary WR who was double teamed. The Secondary Receiver, who was running a screen, caught the ball 5 yards past the line of scrimmage and got an additional 2 yards. In addition, the NT was not successful trying to rush the passer which may have given Rivers the time to find the secondary receiver:

2-12-SDO41 (1Q: 13:44) Philip Rivers pass completed to WR Dexter McCluster for 7 yards. Tackled by ILB Deone Bucannon, assisted by S Tony Jefferson. McCluster gained 2 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage.
OFFENSE 221 Personnel, I formation DEFENSE 34 Eagle, Regular Personnel, Press-2
QB P.Rivers
*** LDE C.Campbell Rush Passer +++
TE A.Gates Outlet, 3 Comeback (9-12) +++ NT X.Williams Rush Passer ---
TE H.Henry Primary, 3 Comeback (9-12) +++ RDE R.Nkemdiche Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) D.McCluster Secondary, S Screen (S) +++ SLB C.Jones Blitz Passer +++
RB K.Farrow Protect --- SILB D.Bucannon Short Zone +++
FB D.Watt Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ WILB J.Bartu Short Zone +++
LT T.Burwell
--- WLB M.Golden Double TE +++
LG C.Watt
+++ LCB M.Jenkins Bump and Run +++
C M.Slauson
+++ RCB P.Peterson Bump and Run +++
RG D.Clark
+++ SS T.Branch Deep Zone +++
RT J.Barksdale
+++ FS T.Jefferson Deep Zone +++



In this example, the primary receiver could not get open and 3 of of the 5 lineman appear to have been dominated on the line of scrimmage which Carson Palmer to run for his life:

2-3-ARI42 (1Q: 04:16) Play-Action. Carson Palmer scrambled for 10 yards. Tackled by OLB Jeremiah Attaochu.
OFFENSE 113 Personnel, Pro formation DEFENSE 34 Eagle, Nickel Personnel, Cover-1
QB C.Palmer
*** LDE J.Bosa Rush Passer +++
X(SE) L.Fitzgerald Primary, 2 Slant (5-8) --- NT B.Mebane Rush Passer +++
TE J.Gresham Protect +++ RDE C.Liuget Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) J.Brown Secondary, 1 Out (5-8) +++ SLB M.Ingram Short Zone +++
RB D.Johnson Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ SILB M.Te'o Short Zone +++
SLOT M.Floyd Outlet, D Deep Fade (40+) +++ WLB J.Attaochu Man-to-Man +++
LT J.Veldheer
--- LCB B.Flowers Man-to-Man +++
LG M.Iupati
--- RCB P.Desir Man-to-Man +++
C A.Shipley
+++ NB J.Verrett Blitz Passer +++
RG E.Mathis
+++ SS D.Lowery Man-to-Man +++
RT D.Humphries
--- FS D.Stuckey Deep Zone +++



Since all this info is in the logs, I can see Solevision being expanded and this is the type of info I have always wanted but we couldn't in previous iterations because of how it was designed.

TroyF 11-25-2016 09:35 AM

What's really awesome about that second screen shot is how every defensive player did their job and they still gave up 10 yards. The QB simply made a great play. It happens.

MalcPow 11-25-2016 10:23 AM

I'll chime in with another thumbs up and agree that it would be very cool to have this tracked in game somewhere.

And as others have noted, I'm not sure this is meant to be a perfect proxy for "whose fault" anything was necessarily, although I'm sure that will often be the case. Trying to figure out which short zones these guys were covering with the offense in a trips formation and receivers running certain routes may very well be a useful exercise, but I'm not quite there yet. I just see it as a very simple coach's grade for how guys did their job on that play.

Antmeister 11-25-2016 10:53 AM

Okay so I was looking at the first play in the thread just to see if they were responsible and it just appears to me they just blew their assignments. It's just that the QB didn't see or take advantage of them.

1-10-WAS12 (4Q: 01:03) Harrison Iacuessa pass completed to WR Chris Hillhouse for 12 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Hillhouse gained 2 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. Washington 13, Dallas 13
OFFENSE113t Personnel, Weak formation, PistolDEFENSE34 Eagle, Nickel Personnel, Press-1
QB H.Iacuessa
***LDE L.ShullRush Passer+++
X(SE) L.BushSecondary, F Flat (0-4)+++NT B.MathisRush Passer+++
TE C.BensenOutlet, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++RDE K.MarquisRush Passer+++
Z(FL) C.HillhousePrimary, 3 Comeback (9-12)+++SLB T.RhodesShort Zone+++
RB G.StewartOutlet, W Wheel (9-18)+++SILB E.MontgomeryShort Zone---
SLOT R.SpearmanOutlet, 1 Out (5-8)+++WLB K.BanksShort Zone---
LT D.Stehlik
+++LCB K.RiordanBump and Run+++
LG K.Sawyer
+++RCB E.MunozBump and Run+++
C E.Hardman
+++NB P.HenryBump and Run+++
RG S.Rector
+++SS C.LyleDouble TE+++
RT R.Morrison
+++FS J.LeakeDeep Zone+++
(4Q: 01:03) Extra point by Jordan Osorio was good. Dallas 14, Washington 13

To illustrate, here is what that exact play look like:


What I love about the new game is that I can just design the exact play above easily in the play designer. As you will notice it is 113t which is the equivalent of 1 running back, 1 tight end, 3 receivers and it is weighted on the strong side of the formation (trips).

In the above each of the CBs did their assignments well which is why they don't have a negative. Here is what an eagle 3/4 Nickel roughly looks like:


Since this is a trips formation on offense, that means that slot (SL) receiver moves to the strong side of the formation (where the TE is). In addition, since this is Bump and Run Coverage, that means all 3 CB were up at the line of scrimmage.

Looking at the above and comparing it to the play, it is most likely the SLB (the O above the TE) covered the TE in the zone and the Safety helped to double team him. That leaves a RB open and their was most likely confusion on who to cover which made them blow their assignments but the QB didn't go that direction.

So what I am saying is that the Touchdown happened due to a well executed play that was well defensed. Now it can be sort of be indirectly involved, I guess, since there were two blown assignments, but I am leaning towards the former.

The reason I am leaning towards this conclusion is because I see other entries in the logs in which there is a passing TD not due to blown coverage. In the example below, the CB was not successful on the blitz. While we can conclude that not getting pressure on the QB helps the offense, we cannot say he is directly at fault for the TD. A well executed play (good route running, good pass) plus good personnel can still win out.

Example:
2-3-CAR03 (1Q: 07:57) Joe Flacco pass completed to WR Keenan Reynolds for 3 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Baltimore 6, Carolina 0
OFFENSE 113t Personnel, I formation DEFENSE 43 Under, Nickel Personnel, Cover-2
QB J.Flacco
*** LDE K.Ealy Rush Passer +++
X(SE) M.Wallace Secondary, 7 Corner (19-26) +++ 1tcDT K.Short Rush Passer +++
TE D.Pitta Outlet, 5 Deep Out (13-18) +++ RDE S.Lotulelei Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) B.Perriman Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ SLB C.Johnson Short Zone +++
RB T.West Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ SILB L.Kuechly Short Zone +++
SLOT K.Reynolds Primary, F Flat (0-4) +++ WLB J.Norris Short Zone +++
LT R.Stanley
+++ LCB R.McClain Man-to-Man +++
LG A.Lewis
+++ RCB J.Bradberry Man-to-Man +++
C J.Zuttah
+++ NB D.Worley Blitz Passer ---
RG M.Yanda
+++ SS M.Griffin Deep Zone +++
RT J.Hurst
+++ FS K.Coleman Deep Zone +++


By the way, I highly suggest downloading those PDFs off the site. They help explain a lot and get me a bit giddy every time I play. Here is an example of what the routes are (strong side of formation, flip when it is on the weak side):


Heck, if you just use that when viewing the game logs, it will help you see the routes each receiver is taking with just the number alone. Example when you see this in the game log - Secondary, 7 Corner (19-26) - you are just looking at number 7 on the graph to get a visual of the route.

Antmeister 11-25-2016 11:19 AM

Oh and I found one play with no --- that went for a touchdown:

1-10-LAS25 (1Q: 15:00) Case Keenum pass completed to WR Kenny Britt for 3 yards. Tackled by S J.J. Wilcox, assisted by CB Brandon Carr. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage.
OFFENSE 113 Personnel, Weak formation DEFENSE 43 Under, Nickel Personnel, Press-1
QB C.Keenum
*** LDE B.Mayowa Rush Passer +++
X(SE) T.Austin Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ 1tcDT T.Crawford Rush Passer +++
TE T.Higbee Outlet, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ RDE C.Thornton Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) K.Britt Primary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ SLB D.Lawrence Short Zone +++
RB T.Gurley Protect +++ SILB R.McClain Double X(SE) +++
SLOT M.Thomas Secondary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ WLB K.Wilber Bump and Run +++
LT R.Havenstein
+++ LCB B.Carr Bump and Run +++
LG R.Saffold
+++ RCB O.Scandrick Bump and Run +++
C T.Barnes
+++ NB M.Claiborne Blitz Passer +++
RG C.Wichmann
+++ SS B.Church Bump and Run +++
RT E.Wannamaker
+++ FS J.Wilcox Deep Zone +++


Ooops....wrong play. The above was a standard play for short yardage. Here is the one I was referring to:
1-10-HOU17 (3Q: 08:29) Colin Kaepernick pass completed to WR Keshawn Martin for 17 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Martin gained 18 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. San Francisco 15, Houston 0
OFFENSE 212 Personnel, Pro formation DEFENSE True 34, Regular Personnel, Cover-2
QB C.Kaepernick
*** LDE J.Heath Rush Passer +++
X(SE) K.Martin Primary, S Screen (S) +++ NT D.Reader Spy on QB +++
TE G.Celek Outlet, W Wheel (9-18) +++ RDE C.Covington Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) T.Smith Outlet, D Deep Fade (40+) +++ SLB W.Mercilus Short Zone +++
RB S.Draughn Secondary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ SILB A.Dent Short Zone +++
FB D.Harris Outlet, 0 Dig (0-4) +++ WILB B.Peters Man-to-Man +++
LT J.Staley
+++ WLB B.Scarlett Spy on QB +++
LG Z.Beadles
+++ LCB K.Johnson Spy on QB +++
C D.Kilgore
+++ RCB A.Bouye Man-to-Man +++
RG A.Tiller
+++ SS E.Pleasant Double Z(FL) +++
RT T.Brown
+++ FS A.Hal Deep Zone +++

Maynard 11-25-2016 11:53 AM

Thanks for explaining the numbers on the route tree corresponding with info in the log. That's so cool. Really will help visualize the game log.

Senator 11-27-2016 12:09 AM

I am spending enormous amounts of time parsing these logs. There is gold in them hills....

Brian Swartz 11-27-2016 03:43 PM

I've spent a 'very' little time with FOF7 and that's about it, but this feature has pretty much guaranteed I get this once a couple of issues are sorted. Very impressive.

Dutch 11-29-2016 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pyser (Post 3131321)
That's awesome...but please tell me that info is stored somewhere (player cards? Maybe when you click into specific season stats to see each game?). Otherwise sounds like it's time for Ben to write a new script! :)


I want this in the Exports...we see all these future columns just waiting for info and this player data on game +++ and --- would be perfect.

TroyF 11-29-2016 05:49 PM

What is your worst defensive/offensive play you have seen? I had a 14 yard run go against me where the safety made the tackle. There were negative grades for 2 DL, 2 LB and 1 CB (all on the side the run took place) Essentially, the entire left side of my defense exploded.

Nemesis 11-30-2016 07:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TroyF (Post 3132745)
What is your worst defensive/offensive play you have seen? I had a 14 yard run go against me where the safety made the tackle. There were negative grades for 2 DL, 2 LB and 1 CB (all on the side the run took place) Essentially, the entire left side of my defense exploded.


Tom Brady musta been lead blocking over there on that side. :D

sawblade300 11-30-2016 10:39 AM

Too bad none of this is kept track of in the player cards. I'm going to have to have several notebooks to keep track of how well everyone is doing. Yuck...writing.

AlexB 11-30-2016 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3132859)
Too bad none of this is kept track of in the player cards. I'm going to have to have several notebooks to keep track of how well everyone is doing. Yuck...writing.


An extra stat along the lines of '% cock-ups' would be great.

Stat name might need some refining I guess.

Sweed 11-30-2016 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3132859)
Too bad none of this is kept track of in the player cards. I'm going to have to have several notebooks to keep track of how well everyone is doing. Yuck...writing.


This was my thinking too. It if could be done add 2 columns to the player's individual game stat screen, I can figure the percent on my own.

garion333 11-30-2016 11:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3132859)
Too bad none of this is kept track of in the player cards. I'm going to have to have several notebooks to keep track of how well everyone is doing. Yuck...writing.


Me too! I'm gonna order one of these:



Comes with a stylus even!

Sweed 11-30-2016 12:29 PM

[quote=Antmeister;3131569]Oh and I found one play with no --- that went for a touchdown:

1-10-LAS25 (1Q: 15:00) Case Keenum pass completed to WR Kenny Britt for 3 yards. Tackled by S J.J. Wilcox, assisted by CB Brandon Carr. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage.
OFFENSE 113 Personnel, Weak formation DEFENSE 43 Under, Nickel Personnel, Press-1
QB C.Keenum
*** LDE B.Mayowa Rush Passer +++
X(SE) T.Austin Outlet, S Screen (S) +++ 1tcDT T.Crawford Rush Passer +++
TE T.Higbee Outlet, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ RDE C.Thornton Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) K.Britt Primary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ SLB D.Lawrence Short Zone +++
RB T.Gurley Protect +++ SILB R.McClain Double X(SE) +++
SLOT M.Thomas Secondary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ WLB K.Wilber Bump and Run +++
LT R.Havenstein
+++ LCB B.Carr Bump and Run +++
LG R.Saffold
+++ RCB O.Scandrick Bump and Run +++
C T.Barnes
+++ NB M.Claiborne Blitz Passer +++
RG C.Wichmann
+++ SS B.Church Bump and Run +++
RT E.Wannamaker
+++ FS J.Wilcox Deep Zone +++


1-10-HOU17 (3Q: 08:29) Colin Kaepernick pass completed to WR Keshawn Martin for 17 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Martin gained 18 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. San Francisco 15, Houston 0
OFFENSE 212 Personnel, Pro formation DEFENSE True 34, Regular Personnel, Cover-2
QB C.Kaepernick
*** LDE J.Heath Rush Passer +++
X(SE) K.Martin Primary, S Screen (S) +++ NT D.Reader Spy on QB +++
TE G.Celek Outlet, W Wheel (9-18) +++ RDE C.Covington Rush Passer +++
Z(FL) T.Smith Outlet, D Deep Fade (40+) +++ SLB W.Mercilus Short Zone +++
RB S.Draughn Secondary, 2 Slant (5-8) +++ SILB A.Dent Short Zone +++
FB D.Harris Outlet, 0 Dig (0-4) +++ WILB B.Peters Man-to-Man +++
LT J.Staley
+++ WLB B.Scarlett Spy on QB +++
LG Z.Beadles
+++ LCB K.Johnson Spy on QB +++
C D.Kilgore
+++ RCB A.Bouye Man-to-Man +++
RG A.Tiller
+++ SS E.Pleasant Double Z(FL) +++
RT T.Brown
+++ FS A.Hal Deep Zone +++


I used Antmeister's post to highlight something I would like to see in the game log. The play result in a contrasting color to the detailed player performance section. Too me it would make it much easier when reading through a game log breaking it up a bit lessening eye strain.

albionmoonlight 11-30-2016 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3132859)
Too bad none of this is kept track of in the player cards. I'm going to have to have several notebooks to keep track of how well everyone is doing. Yuck...writing.


Put me on team "find a way to get this info on the player card"

sawblade300 12-06-2016 10:54 AM

What does everyone think is a good threshold for negative ratings? Not that negative is good. Maybe, what's acceptable. 80%, 75%, 70% and below?

Ben E Lou 12-06-2016 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3134082)
What does everyone think is a good threshold for negative ratings? Not that negative is good. Maybe, what's acceptable. 80%, 75%, 70% and below?

I'm thinking "acceptable" is probably around 90% and "good" is 95%. I've been meaning to copy/paste some logs from maybe 20 wins and see what the average is in those.

sawblade300 12-06-2016 11:47 AM

Thanks Ben. Looks like my boys need to step it up a bit. Too many guys 85% and below.

Ben E Lou 12-06-2016 12:03 PM

At first quick glance even that is too low. it looks like somewhere around 91.5% is an average performance score.

sawblade300 12-06-2016 12:15 PM

Well, there's going to be some guys getting familiar with the bench if they don't pick it up. Thanks again.

TroyF 12-06-2016 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sawblade300 (Post 3134120)
Well, there's going to be some guys getting familiar with the bench if they don't pick it up. Thanks again.



One thing of note here. . . don't forget to take in the amount of HUGE plays a guy makes or the amount of horrible plays a guy makes.

My first game of the season, I have a lineman rotation battle going on. Both guys got between 35 and 40 plays. One guy had a 96% rating, the other guy 75%.

The 75% guy also had 1 sack, a forced fumble and generated 4 QB hurries. The 96% guy had zero explosive plays.

Obviously, there is more information to see and one game doesn't make or break a guy. . . but if the numbers stayed the way they are, I'll gladly take Mr. 75% in exchange for the game changing plays.

SocratesJC 08-29-2018 01:16 AM

Did we find a way to get this data consolidated using some sort of utility? Or, is the combined data stored somewhere? If I knew where to easily access the data, I suppose I could use a spreadsheet to combine it...

Also, did we determine how useful/important the data was to the player's value?

Sharkn20 08-29-2018 08:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SocratesJC (Post 3216031)
Did we find a way to get this data consolidated using some sort of utility? Or, is the combined data stored somewhere? If I knew where to easily access the data, I suppose I could use a spreadsheet to combine it...

Also, did we determine how useful/important the data was to the player's value?


You can use excel to compile it, you need to know a little bit of advanced formulas though.

victorbubba 08-29-2018 09:00 AM

does this only display on fof8 but not on 7 as I cannot find it

SocratesJC 08-29-2018 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sharkn20 (Post 3216036)
You can use excel to compile it, you need to know a little bit of advanced formulas though.


Yeah, I can do it, but do I need to copy and paste the data off of the html from each individual log? Or is there a way to get all the information for each player into one place easier?

Quote:

Originally Posted by victorbubba (Post 3216040)
does this only display on fof8 but not on 7 as I cannot find it


I can't remember if it was added near the end of fof7 (before fof8 came out) or not, but there is an option to turn on detail logs somewhere. Let me know if you can't find it and I will take a looksie myself.

victorbubba 08-29-2018 12:01 PM

I cannot find it, it only offers you a chance to show formations and not player contributions to a play


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.