|
That's what I'm talking about, ITC. :)
|
Lupus 5 Oz 3 Howard 2 Helsing 2 |
nothing cooler than a online forum high five!!
|
what 2nd!???
|
opps is that total?
|
True.
|
has to be i appoligize
|
Question: Do we have to vote every time? Since we aren't getting any points out of this round, do we still need to vote? Will we be penalized for not voting?
|
Is the second post in the thread ever going to be edited to show the current tribes, or is it going to remain static throughout the game?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
so any speculation why there was no wolf kill last night?
|
Quote:
No, not really. |
Quote:
No not really that my thoughts wern't good enough for you, or no not really that you didn't see the post I made? |
Quote:
If yours was the post referencing Barkeep's comments about "evil" I don't find that persuasive. That's what I meant. |
Quote:
in my mind it seems to be alot more evidence than anything you are tossing out though. |
isnt that too obvious????
|
Quote:
Not sure. Maybe there are no wolves yet? Maybe BK's volunteer comment that "they are a little bit more evil" means that they are on the way toward becoming wolves but aren't there yet? Just guessing. |
Quote:
any theroies you have would be welcome |
Quote:
Not sure how its too obvious since we don't know who volunteered. |
Vote AlanT
|
Quote:
So you are stressing the "little bit" part, not the evil comment? |
Quote:
I'm not tossing ANYTHING out. I have been somewhat persuaded that this is a possibility. I just ... need a little bit more. |
at least we can give someone else a vote :)
|
Quote:
A pile-on vote? |
Quote:
sometimes it is best to not overthink things. The thing that led me to believe they are wolves were the comment about to many people volunteering and how those who did volunteer need to keep it to themselves. Seemed obvious to me. |
Quote:
Some tribes may know. Also, some tribes may not have ANYBODY who volunteered. Both of those possibilities are what make that theory a little too unlikely in my opinion. |
Quote:
more a vote to keep a pile on to happening to one of our guys. |
Quote:
. |
Quote:
Well, you know, at first I found this suspicious, because why vote for a guy who isn't here, because you can't do the whole Counterspell thing with it (see: Magic the gathering), but, since you have to vote for someone, I guess this makes sense the more I think about it. |
Quote:
Yes. That's my (lame) theory at this point. |
Quote:
read the rules, If a tribe knows who volunteered that is a direct violation of the rules. |
Quote:
true. But it sounds like those tribes will be punished in other ways as well. |
read the post I quoted above from Barkeep, it seems to me there are alot of clues in there.
|
Quote:
That's the post I was talking about. "A little more evil" seems carefully chosen to me. I don't know what it means, but... |
Makes sense to just get the vote out there, even if I don't like it too much because it's against one of my guys. But I can't really blame you for it.
|
Quote:
|
the line " too many people could be BAD too" bad as in consequences or in evil?????
|
Quote:
If somebody POSTS that they have volunteered that is a violation of the rules. There are many ways a tribe could know who volunteered without that person posting. |
Quote:
I agree. I think if volunteers = wolves, Barkeep would have said nothing, for the reasons I outlined. |
Quote:
I haven't encountered any in this game. I can't really think of anything that would show if someone had VOLUNTEERED or not -- a seer wouldn't tell you if someone had volunteered or not, it would just tell you if someone is bad, which is related but a distinct issue. |
Quote:
I take this post as nothing but you trying to garnish information from someone. |
Quote:
its actually just the opposite...why would i come into the general thread to try and work over team members? if i wanted to do that id do it in our tribal thread. I take your post as nothing but you trying to be mean |
Quote:
Let's not lie to ourselves. This is still Werewolf. Most of the posts in this thread are going to be trying to probe for unknown information right now, because I'm pretty certain none of us really know anything. I sure as heck don't. I'm not really going to get on blade for trying to learn something because I think we could all use more knowledge right now. |
lol @ Lathum and Blade
do it lathum, kill blade! hahahahahaha |
Quote:
Yes, I agree. But I've been very straightforward with my questions and theories today (and last night). I'm not trying to figure out anybody's tribal strategy. |
I think it is still important to share information and wolf theories with each other in this thread. If we only talk overall game strategy in our individual tribal threads, we'll lose a lot. Theories build on themselves, and without talking some of this stuff through as a big group, the wolves will pick us apart.
|
Vote AlanT
|
VOTE ST.CRONIN
|
VOTE SWAGGS
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:04 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.