|
FOFC NHL All-Time Team Challenge (Round 4)
        ~~~~~ There are only a few positions left to fill so let's set a short deadline for those who need it. Round 4 Deadline: Saturday, May 15th, 11:59 p.m. Otherwise, it's time to set your forward lines, defence pairings, starting goaltender and write a paragraph or two explaining your selections, coach, lines, and why your team is the best. Note: The points bid on players will not be displayed for voters so set your lines as you see fit. I will add stats however along the lines of GP, G, A, Pts, PIM. Lines & Paragraph Deadline: Friday, May 21st, 11:59 p.m. |
Question:
Do you guys want me to include any stats for the voters or just lines and a paragraph? |
this looks a lot like the round 3 chart...
|
I don't know much about Hockey (more than the average American, I'm sure...but still not much), but Team #4 looks pretty strong.
|
Quote:
I reckon stats would be helpful. They don't tell the whole story, but tell some of it. |
Quote:
I think we need to be able to write more than a paragraph, frankly. I'd like to write a line or two about each player on my team, or at the very least each line combination. I realize that could be a bit more work than we want to get into. I'm not saying I want to go Chief Rum on you, I just worry that FOFC won't know who some of these guys are. (Especially Team One... who drafted them, Buccaneer?) |
I like Finnish forwards.
|
Quote:
I agree. A few lines for each guy and then a line or two for why the line combo will work would be good, I imagine. I don't know too much about a lot of these guys. You're right about Team 1. That's old school. Very old school... |
Quote:
Yes but I think everyone got at least 1 player they bid on. I know HB stole two guys I REALLY wanted! :mad: :D |
Quote:
As long as no one goes Chief on me, I don't mind a line or two about every player, line, coach, team overall, etc. That will help tell more of a story. I'll be adding stats over the next week while everyone works on their paragraphs. Since there's going to be a little more writing, I think I'll push the deadline back until Friday. |
Positions that still need filling:
Team 1 (1 defenceman) - done Team 2 (1 forward) - done Team 3 (2 forwards) - done Team 5 (1 forward) - done |
Quote:
Oops. I am sorry (not really). :D |
Ok, guys. I'm using Bill Barber as a sample for displaying stats and info. Tell me what you think:
 He didn't win any major awards but I would have included them as well. Too much info? I just want to get some sort of consensus before working on every player... |
Quote:
looks adequate to me. |
Quote:
I think that looks good too. Could add Hall of Fame status, but that wouldn't be fair to players still playing or not eligible yet. |
Actually, I was thinking about including Hall of Fame status instead of 1st and 2nd team All-Stars.
The All-Star teams only started in 1930 and I only have an accurate list up to 97-98. |
dola,
Just found an updated list of all-stars. Good to go... |
well, when I was breaking down my team stats (yes, I am lame), I prorated everything to a /82 games stat. I think it makes it easier to compare quickly that way.
|
OK, so here's the real question... Once we post our summaries, will the other players have a chance to shoot them down? Can I claim that Tim Kerr was the greatest winger of all time without getting called for it?
|
I would think you could try and justify anything you want in your summary. It's up to the voters to decide if it's reasonable.
Anyway, I've finished the stats for Team 4 and will post it shortly... |
Team 4 sans paragraphs...
 |
That looks great.....nice job......
|
Thanks.
I forgot to put that Scotty is in the Hall of Fame but that's been fixed... I'm ignoring the Calder, Masterton and Jennings trophies... Teams 2, 3 and 4 are complete with stats and awards... Still waiting on Team 1 for one more defenceman... |
karim,
that's above and beyond the call of duty. thanks for your hard work. this should be a lot of fun. |
Thanks wheels. I think it's good to have a quick synopsis of a guy's career all in one place.
All teams are now filled! Once paragraphs and line combinations are in, we can turn it over to membership. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:43 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.