What is odd here
 

from

http://msn.foxsports.com/story/3152386

1 Daunte Culpepper
2 Drew Brees
3 Ben Roethlisberger
4 Peyton Manning
5 Brian Griese
6 Tom Brady
7 Marc Bulger
8 Donovan McNabb
9 Trent Green
10 Byron Leftwich


And the rest...
11. Jake Plummer (LW: 19): The good Jake showed up Sunday.
12. Tim Rattay (LW: 10): Can't keep up with 49ers porous D.
13. Chad Pennington (LW: 7): Will Quincy do as well?
14. Joey Harrington (LW: 14): Can still stay in NFC North fight.
15. Brett Favre (LW: 12): So can the Pack.
16. David Carr (LW: 13): Momentum ended with a thud.
17. Albert Brooks (LW: 17): Here comes the dropoff.
18. Vinny Testaverde (LW: 18): Not time for a change… yet.
19. Michael Vick (LW: 20): The week off may have hurt him after great game.
20. Jay Fiedler (LW: 22): May have been forced back to the bench.
21. Jeff Garcia (LW: 15): Needed more of an effort against Ravens.
22. Josh McCown (LW: 23): Had a Plummer-like comeback win.
23. Kurt Warner (LW: 24): Unfortunately, looked like Kurt Warner 20o2 vintage.
24. Billy Volek (LW: 25): Will it be him or McNair?
25. Mark Brunell (LW: 21): It's probably time for a change here.
26. Drew Bledsoe (LW: 26): Actually looks better now than when he was overrated.
27. Jake Delhomme (LW: 27): Panthers may be headed to another 1-15 disaster – but it's not his fault.
28. Carson Palmer (LW: 30): Starting to make signs of progress.
29. Matt Hasselbeck (LW: 28): While he seems to be regressing.
30. Kyle Boller (LW: 29): Got Lewis back, but offense still sputtering.
31. Steve McNair (LW: 31): Needs to get healthy.
32. Kerry Collins (LW: 32): Finally broke winless drought.
33. Ken Dorsey (LW: 33): In bottom five in every category.

Daunte ahead of Manning is a joke. That simple.

What a weird list.. Who is Albert Brooks? Why is griese so high?

Besides the ex-Fin?

Isn't Leftwich out for 4-6 weeks?

The lower-case "o" in 20o2? (see #23)

1 Daunte Culpepper
3 Ben Roethlisberger
5 Brian Griese
7 Marc Bulger
9 Trent Green

That is what's odd from the top list.

lol

This really is a weird list... so funny.

I'm a Steelers fan, but I don't see how someone can claim Big Ben is the best in the league with the game on the line in the 4th Quarter. That is a weird way to look at QBs - and any list that has Peyton behind Brees and Ben is WRONG.

DING!

who says a middle aged fat guy can't play ball?

I said it first. :(

I believe all this list does is take the Qb ratings of each player in a specific situation, and rank them on a 1-howevermanyqualifiers scale. Ben has a great 4th quarter qb rating.

Yes you did. Sorry about the snub Mister VIck. Perhaps I am still miffed that your family lived (in part) on my tax dollars in Newport News, but when you made the big time you moved your mother into some nice taxable real estate in Suffolk. Perhaps I hate Warwick High. Perhaps I hate that you said some unflattering things to an ex-girlfriend who volunteered for the Boys and Girls Club. Perhaps I am just a little angry that you bumped Jay Fiedler down a slot.

Thanks for the highway construction for my commute from Williamsburg to Norfolk.. when it is finally done, my commute will be that much better than it is for those that paid for it.

Hooray for Northern Virginia tax money!

That is a-ok. I'll get one rushing TD and then point with the ball to the stands against Tampa this week for you.

Drew Brees being number 2

That whole list is odd. I guess it shows that when someone creates a bad formula it gives you bad data.

Mark Brunell ahead of anybody is a joke.

This just goes to show that the rankings that everyone else in this thread work on are much better.

Rankings are always very subjective. I love the x is better then y argument or the a ahead of b is a joke (good one detox).. baaaaaaaaaaaaah

i am just saying that manning is a better QB then Culpepper. His stats show it, his play shows it, his entire career has shown it. After MNF, I can't fathom how Culpepper is ahead of Manning. It honestly makes no sense.