CHorN Bracket 3, Rd. 1: 3 Keira Knightley v. 6 Liv Tyler
 

10 Keira Knightley v. 23 Liv Tyler

I voted HOT for Keira and NOT for Liv, but I'm switching my vote to Liv for this one. I hate the Keira has gotten so thin (as seen in her Pirates of the Caribbean 2 red carpet photos).

ill make Kiera eat some meat so she gets back to shape. i just dont like tyler girl, which is weird because i like brunettes

Kiera can be amazingly beautiful, but she can also be rather ugly when seen from the wrong angle. Liv is constantly hot, so she gets my vote...

I'll agree with this.

Stick figure over the Steven Tyler facial look-alike.

That I have to vote against either Liv Tyler or Keira Knightley, and that I had to vote for either Shania Twain or Tyra Banks, is evidence that the universe is a fundamentally unjust place.

But if I had to choose....Keira.