CHorN Bracket 4, Rd. 2: 6 Jennifer Aniston v. 2 Scarlett Johansen
 

22 Jennifer Aniston v. 6 Scarlett Johansen

meh on both

Both are attractive, but never have that "sex appeal".

Aniston is a fucking dog. I can't believe she even made it this far.

Scarlett, on the other hand, was hotter than hell in Match Point, my only exposure to her thus far.

Scarlett is just not that good looking. Or even that good of an actor. I agree with bulletsponge ... Meh, but less of a meh on Jennifer Anniston.

You sir are an enigma.

I'm abstaining both are blah and neither got my vote last round

Any of you HOMOS vote for Aniston, and I kill you.

to make matters worse, ive seen scarlett jo on late night tv twice. both times i came away thinking " thank god actors dont have to think to do thier job". if it wasnt for her funbags she wouldnt even be here

I have to say that Scarlett is really overrated.

Once again I have to say that ScarJo is as hot as they come...

I don't find SJ pretty, let alone hot. But the only time I've really seen her was in Lost in Translation. I was not impressed.

The fact that you even know who she is should at least count for something. ;)

Only because I saw that movie a couple of years back. I couldn't name a single other movie she's been in. Otherwise, she'd be another "heard the name, not sure I've seen her" person.

Sigh. Jennifer may not be hot but at least she doesn't fall into the make-a-whore camp.

I'm not a big fan of Scarlett, but as long as you don't look above the neck, she is nice to look at.

Scarlett is one of my favorites. Only movie I've seen her in was Girl with a Pearl Earring and I thought she was great in that.

The thing about JA is that she is good looking, but not so good looking she could never be your girlfriend. But I don't think I can call her hot.. too whiny for hotness. I don't know much about SJ, but from the pics I found, I believe I can at least call her hot.

I agree with this.

As I believe I've noted before, Scarlett looked good in Ghost World, but every time I've seen her photographed, I find her appalling.

Go watch the island....i cant believe anyone who has seen that movie doesnt think scarlett is hot. Normally i think she looks good, not stunning. But in the Island, i thought she was a knock-out

ahh theres the problem. nobody went to see that movie :D

i know what you mean

Jennifer Aniston in "The Leprechaun." Now that was not hot.

After seeing ScarJo on the Tonight Show, something about her personality really turns me off.

bring that shit to me man, bring that shit to me!!

But as Pumpsy said, the stills from that movie make her look appalling. She may have done some things in the movie that were hot but she didn't look it.

She has the girl next door perona in my mind...i like it...it doesnt help that im one who doesnt understand the whole aniston obsession. I can see some other i didnt vote for, but im just not turned on by aniston at all

I'm not that turned on by Jennifer either but definitely turned off by Johannson. Anyone that goes out in public looking like a cheap knockoff of Marilyn Monroe is definitely not your girl next door persona. That's probably what is appealing to some about JA, she doesn't try to do the over-glam schtick which is a turn-off.

When i say that, i think more In Good Company...she seemed that type to me, which with the island is one of the few times ive seen her.

That's the movie that made me fall in love with her...

You're claiming Johannson of all people has girl next door appeal?!

Of all of the people in this contest, she is by far the most "dolled up" and forced of any of the women. Don't get me wrong, I think she is attractive (although I voted for Jennifer), but she is certainly NOT girl next door material.