All Pro Football 2K8 vs. Madden 2008
 

Which one has you more excited right now?

madden. i don't see what All Pro has that Madden doesn't, other than just being "the other football game".

Madden, real rosters are a must for me in every game plus i still have the hope (and dunno why) that the superstar mode will end being like RTTS in MLB 07.

Where is the option that states that I am equally apathetic toward both? :D

Where's the one that I am more excited about your mutha?

I could not be less interested in this All Pro game.

Agreed with the general sentiment, while it's hard to get excited about Madden I have absolutely no interest in the direction that 2k8 have decided to go.

Madden, but only b/c there was not a 'neither' option

The neither option is simply not to vote. :)

the only reason I voted Madden instead of AllPro is the no franchise mode,

Agreed. The lack of franchise mode just KILLS APF2K8.

APF2k8 is the new Tecmo Bowl..

Concur!!

Madden. I've never been able to get into the 2k sports football games.

I'll go with the trout option.

Went with All-Pro, not that I'm particularly excited about what they're doing but last year's Madden on the 360 did absolutely nothing for me. So, if I'm getting a football game I'll go with AP, but I'll probably end up just playing NFL 2k5 for another year.

Right now, Madden. Plus, 2K8 is not even coming out for the old Xbox, so...

I thought they would have revealed a story mode or something by now that equates with multiple seasons of player progression. That is also killing my enthusiasm for the game. Meanwhile, I'm cautiously optimistic with the recent previews/hype re: Madden, so I voted for Madden only because of the lack of a franchise equivalent mode in APF2k8.