The 2015 NFL Draft
 

Might as well get this started. First question...what's best for Tampa Bay...Winston, Mariota, or a trade down? What will they do?

I think we don't see any dramatics and Winston goes #1. I would take Mariota. I think either is important for the Bucs...a little success at the QB position will go a long way to legitimize this downtrodden organization.

If there were an RG3 offer waiting for the Bucs, they should probably take it. But I don't see that out there. So, barring that, they should take a QB. Not sure which one.

What do you think RG3 is worth in today's NFL? 4th rounder? 3rd?

I think because of his age and supposed potential, a second.

nothing, hell be an FA in a year.

Washington should pick up that RG3 option cause it's only guaranteed for injury. If he's trash again you'd know it within a few weeks and you deactivate him.

I'd say Tampa or Tennessee should at least Consider RG3, the redskins #5 and another sliding scale pick in 2016 for #1 or #2

RGIII and picks would be a fascinating choice, but I doubt the Redskins want to do the rookie QB show right now.

If there's some option that lets the Redskins give up all their draft picks for the next 5 years, to get one player - they are definitely the team to do it.

To be fair, not a lot of teams are in position to give up all of the Redskins picks for the next 5 years except for them. :)

I don't know, they have traded a lot of them...

I feel like the Bucs best move would be to take Williams the DE, and then start Glennon for a year. That's the safest and smartest move in my opinion. I think Glennon can get it done, he just needs a defense (and a run game, maybe some O-line help) to help out. I feel like the Bucs are wasting a potential asset by not giving the guy one chance to show what he can do over the course of a season. If he plays well but the team doesn't win, you can flip him for a nice pick next year and build a core that can be successful for the long term.

I trade down if I'm Tampa Bay.

I think Winston has a world of talent but also could be a headache of epic proportions. But I also can't see either Winston or Mariota reaching their full potential on a Lovie Smith team.

Would take Mariota over the head case any day.

They've changed.

Assuming it's Winston first, like most do, then I think the Mariota situation might be the most intriguing we've seen in a while.

Regardless of whether you support the roll-dice-on-possible-franchise-QB strategy, it is undeniably interesting when any franchise does so. It just defines them for a significant period of time. And that's fun, or at least interesting, to see, even if you're not really a fan of that team.

I felt the same way, to some degree, with Manziel last year, but I think this is a clearer case as an observer. Especially if you factor in that many informed people feel that Mariota might really be best suited to a certain sort of system - then you have the potential that some team either deciding to restructure its system somewhat, or else a "good fit" team making a big move to get into position to take him (can you hear us, Chip?). Either of those situations is pretty compelling.

Personally, I really want to see Philadelphia make the big move and get him. I am simultaneously intrigued, appalled, and titillated by their move toward an uptempo offense, and I'd like to see the system get as fair a shake as possible in the NFL before the insiders reject it. If Chip thinks this is the guy for that, then let's go do the whole thing -- deal Bradford to Cleveland, wheel and deal away the future to get up to pick Mariota, and let's get rid of the safety net.

If the Chargers decide to make the rumored big splash, that's interesting for both teams (including Tennessee, the rumored obvious partner) and I'd like seeing that play out, too.

And hell, maybe Cleveland? Buffalo? Chicago? Someone else on the verge of way overpaying a decent quarterback? Or just sit back and let him go to the J-E-T-S, which could be its own brand of hilarity. There are enough possibilities - and when it's at QB it's easy enough for all of us to digest them - that this is great theater.

The only reason I want Mariota on the Jets is to ensure they don't play Geno Smith any more.

At first I wasn't too big on the idea of the Giants taking Amari Cooper with their pick, but the more I think about it, the more I like the pick if he's still sitting there.

Not as big on the other WRs graded for the 1st rd, at least not for the Giants, but I think Cooper is the right type of receiver to flank with ODB. And if Cruz can come back to at least 80% of his old self, could be a really problematic set of options for defenses to cover.

Not a Giants fan but with holes on the OL and the defense I think it would be crazy to go WR with such a high pick.

I want Williams or Cooper at #4

On what little I've read about the draft so far this off season, my personal hope for the Giants is to get OT Scherff. But I haven't really gotten up to speed on the draft yet. I'll look over all that stuff this week.

Don't worry about speculating about the Redskins trading up from #5. Not gonna happen. QB is a mess, but let's build an offensive line and a defense and start worrying about QB next year - or look for a developmental late rounder/UDFA.

edit: I'd like Williams or Fowler at 5, but hope for some trading back.

Yeah if Scherff is there, they probably go with him. And thats a definite need for them.

I just think Cooper seems about as NFL-ready & sharp as any kid coming out at WR I've seen in a number of years. And pairing him up with Becham might be the best thing they could do for their running game as teams will not stack the box on them. I also think he might be the BPA between him & Scherff...so I tend to go with the BPA mentality barring an obvious non-need.

They absolutely need a passrusher and a safety more than anything. I'm just not sure anybody as trustworthy will be sitting there at #9. So hoping they can find the right guys to develop in rounds 2-7 (Shaq Thompson comes to mind for S).

Yep, I wouldnt be disappointed if they go with Scherff.

From what I've read, there is debate on whether he is an OT or a G in the NFL. So that may influence whether teams are willing to take him top 10 or not. The Giants could use both as their line is in need of a talent infusion. Zack Martin was who I wanted them to grab last year instead of ODB, but hard to argue with either pick at this point.

I have heard people compare Scherff to Martin so that would definitely be a nice fit for us.

Is Winston or Mariota franchise-altering? Probably not. Unless you have an Andrew Luck level certainty, I'm trading down or taking best player available.

I think Winston and Mariotta are this draft's versions of Vince Young and Matt Linehart. Not picking either is the wise thing to do; however bad teams are short on wisdom.

I think Winston has the potential to be.
I think Mariota is ultimately a good guy with career back up potential.

I'm all over the place on Mariota. The right situation, I'm wondering if he might be another Aaron Rodgers?

IMHO he doesn't have the arm strength or accuracy of Rodgers.
I think he is at best a very poor man's RGIII. Only after RGIII's injury. I hate it because I want a good guy super star but he is not it.

Yeah thats where I'm at as well. I think Winston has potential to be a Big Ben or Cam type of QB. Perhaps even better potential given his seemingly higher intellect.

But something about going to the Bucs just doesn't sound like a good fit for either side. I'd go with Williams at #1 if I'm TB.

I know that the rumors we hear are only a small slice of what teams are actually doing. But we are hearing nothing about teams approaching the Bucs about getting into #1 to take Winston.

If that is true, and I were the Bucs, it would make me worry a little bit. About half the teams in the league have been linked to "trade up for Mariotta" rumors. And not one team seems interested in trading up for Winston. Are they sure they've targeted the right guy?

dola:

And I certainly have not seen enough games, but when I have seen Mike Glennon, he's looked competent. Are the Bucs sure they want to pull the plug on him? If they get a trade down offer, they could fill in a lot of pieces and hope that Glennon makes a leap.

How much of this is a function of getting people to click on things though? The Bucs have an obvious need at QB and have (essentially) publicly stated they're going to take Winston. What is newsworthy in a Trade Down rumor, especially if it's not substantiated with all the press out there that Tampa is set with Winston at one?

I think Tampa will take Winston. But I think they're also hoping to be blown away by an offer for the first pick.

I think Lovie is comfortable with Winston. Haven't heard from OC Koetter...but I think his style suits Winston as well.

Lovie is able to take a Bucs team that many thought would win 8-9games all the way to the #1 pick, and then is able to lobby for whomever he wants. Doesn't make much sense. Remind me what exactly he's won?

Shane Ray got arrested for marijuana possession this morning. Not a good start to his draft week.

How early can the NFL punish someone for an infraction? I'm not saying this guy in particular needs punishment but I'm just curious.

Do they have to go through the draft? Do they have to sign a contract with a team?

He just wanted to get a heads up on the NFL's discipline policies. What an idiot-I take him off my board no matter how good he might be. Be interesting to see how far he might drop in the draft now.

That, plus his announced need for foot surgery, aren't helping.

Not sure he'll slip that far but I'd take him anywhere in the 2nd rd without hesitation. Probably still take him in the 1st depending on how you view his talent on the field.

But definitely a stupid thing to do right before the draft.

His Sparq scores suggest he's a bust on the making anyways(or so I hear)

Despite all the feel-good hype surrounding Ray in the lead up to the draft, sounds like the apple didn't fall very far from the tree after all.

The over/under to "back on the block" is probably about 3-4 years.

A guy who can't stop smoking when he has every selfish reason to stay clean for a few months does not give me confidence that he will make the sacrifices necessary to help a team.

It isn't about whether weed should be a big deal or not. It is about the fact that for a potential draftee, it is a big deal.

It's like showing up late to a job interview. Or wearing a dirty band t-shirt instead of a coat and tie. It demonstrates an inability to understand and care about the rules and expectations of the place that you hope will soon employ you.

Wasn't this the same dude ejected from the bowl game or title game?

i just want this draft to be over...normally i enjoy the lead in quite a bit, but the morons on Philadelphia talk radio have not shut up about "moving up to get Mariotta" since the draft order came out...they act like this kid (who i like very much) will show up and be Joe Montana on the first day of mini camp, and that they will win the next 5 super bowls if they have him on their team...meanwhile, not one of them can fathom the concept that the Eagles do not have nearly enough depth and talent on their team to make that kind of a trade and still be any good...it has literally made listening to the radio in the car impossible.

If I were the Bucs GM I would also wonder if Lovie Smith is the guy to develop a young QB.

So what's everyone got planned for the draft? I really hate this Thursday night BS, of course it makes more money but it was always nice to wake up on on a saturday morning and watch a few hours of the draft. Roger has really taken a lot of fun out of stuff like that.

Wonder if this causes him to fall.

I must admit that this line amuses me.

"We've tried to rule him out as a suspect."


We just keep trying to rule him out but he won't let us... :)

Great way for me to workout while watching something more interesting than local news and re-runs of Everybody Loves Raymond.