[Samdari]

Originally Posted by Mizzou B-ball fan

Unbelievably stupid move, but you can expect nothing less from the NCAA. They've implemented the 'Tiller' rule that allows the opposing coach to choose the FT shooter from the players on the court when an injury occurs..........

NCAA changes rule in wake of University of Missouri Tigers' win over Marquette Golden Eagles in NCAA Tournament - STLtoday.com

What exactly is stupid about it?

Your scenario of someone hitting a player hard enough to intentionally injure them just so they get to pick the shooter would result in:

1) Two free throws AND the ball for the injured team.
2) The fouling player being ejected.
3) Sanctions against the coach (suspension) and school (fine) the second time it happens.

Fouling to injure is just not going to be a viable strategy. Lacking that, what's the downside?