View Single Post
Old 10-13-2011, 09:08 AM   #3459
Autumn
Head Coach
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Bath, ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by Commo_Soldier View Post
Day 5

commo votes Chief 2153
commo unvotes Chief 2157
Thomkal votes EF 2187
jackal votes EF 2196
EF votes MrBug 2211
autumn votes Chief 2213
MrBug votes Narcizo 2224
autumn unvotes Chief 2237
autumn votes Narcizo 2237
jackal unvotes EF 2244
jackal votes Narcizo 2244
J23 votes Narcizo 2257
SnDvls votes EF 2285
commo votes Narc 2290
Grammaticus votes Narc 2294
commo unvotes Narc 2344
commo votes MrBug 2354
Narcizo votes MrBug 2368
jackal unvotes Narc 2375
jackal vote EF 2375
mckerney unvotes Narcizo 2387
mckerney votes EF 2387
Thomkal unvotes EF 2415
Thomkal votes MrBug 2415
Hoops guy votes MrBug 2423
autumn unvotes Narcizo 2441
autumn votes MrBug 2442
J23 unvotes Narcizo 2444
J23 votes MrBug 2444
SnDvls unvotes EF 2445
SnDvls votes MrBug 2445
Mauboy votes MrBug 2456
jackal unvotes EF 2457
jackal votes MrBug 2457
SnDvls unvotes MrBug 2489
SnDvls votes EF 2499
autumn unvotes MrBug 2507
autumn votes EF 2507
jackal unvotes MrBug 2511
jackal votes EF 2511
Mauboy unvotes MrBug 2512
Mauboy votes EF 2512
cheif votes EF 2526
dubb votes MrBug 2536
autumnunvotes EF 2600
autumn votes MrBug 2600
Mauboy unvotes EF 2601
Mauboy votes Bug 2601

4 EF - mckerney, SnDvls, jackal, Chief
9 MrBug - EF, commo, Narcizo, Thomkal, Hoops, J23, dubb, autumn, Mauboy
2 Narcizo - MrBug, Grammaticus

Day Five. What comes to mind most strongly here is not hte voting but the in-thread arguments about the reveals. Certainly Commo and Dubb came out poorly there, arguing strongly against believing MrBug. That strikes me as rather forthright for a wolf, but also possibly an act of desperation since it seems two of the last three wolves were on the line to get axed. Leaving the seer with the very last wolf would have been bad.

I don't remember what arguments J23 and Mckerney made in thread, that will take some reading. My vote log must be missing something, but it looks like Mckerney voted Narc early and then switched to EF. A point maybe in his favor since it seems the wolves wnated to save EF over Narc later. J23 votes Narc after Bug's reveal and then switches to Bug himself presumably after Narc's counterreveal. I pushed for EF mosst of the day on the back of Sndvl's reveal, but switched to Bug at the end to avoid any shenanigans. Dubb was a key and vocal voter on Bug. Commo was the ssecond voter on Bug after EF.

Whereas previous days I think Mckerney comes off the worst, here I think Commo looks the worst, trying to push the Bug play early and vocally. It's a rather out front move, but one I can seem from a new player, and/or from a wolf who's just about to lose the game it seems.
Autumn is offline   Reply With Quote