Quote:
Originally Posted by Crapshoot
The regular season counts as well - players don't just magically show up in the playoffs. and taking this kind of W-L record is akin to saying Luis Sojo won 4 World Series rings, ergo he's better than Ken Griffey Jr. Eli may (may) be as good a QB now as Peyton, but even that is debatable - Peyton has been by far the better QB career wise, Super Bowl wins or not.
|
That is a terrible analogy. You can't compare a utility player the the starting QB.
And I was never debating who was the better QB, I was saying I would take Eli over Peyton. Eli will never have the regular season stats of Peyton, but he is good enough most years to get there ans has now shown twice that he can get the job done.