Quote:
Originally Posted by Lathum
and my love for Eli obviously clouds my opinion, but someone show me any numbers indicating Peyton is the obvious choice over Eli.
|
It would be easier for you to show the numbers indicating Eli is the better choice over Peyton. Other than 2 rings to 1, the proof doesn't exist. Peyton's numbers across the board put him into discussion of the top 3 or 5 best quarterbacks ever. Are you saying Eli is in that discussion?
I have nothing against Eli, he's a good quarterback. But if we're going to talk about postseason success, let's talk about the times the Giants didn't make the playoffs because of Eli. Peyton has more losses because he gets there.