Quote:
Originally Posted by rowech
Would be interesting to do a similar poll for Scott Rolen. My guess is Rolen would get more votes but I think Beltre is the better player. Not 100% sure on that. In any case, at some point people need to realize that the bar is being set ridiculously high and some great third basemen continue to be shutout out of the hall because people seem to think third basement should be more than they usually end up being.
|
I would guess you're right about Rolen polling higher than Beltre, yet it seems hard to argue that Beltre hasn't had a better career.
Based off of HoF standards, both should be elected.