Anyone have a problem with designated fielders? Why have substandard gloves on the field when better players are sitting on the bench?
If you had the dh in both leagues pinch hitters would be unnecessary so the 4 or 5 current bench spots could be filled with great gloves with all players eligible to play either offense, defense, or both.
This is a bit facetious on my part as I do not like the DH and quit being an AL fan after it was implemented. I like the way the NL does it, so sue me
But really what would be the argument against having the best players on the field at all times whether a "good" hitter in place of the pitcher or a "good" glove in place of a guy with hands of made of stone that can't run or throw but only plays for his bat?
Sure there would need to be rule changes. If one of the 5 DH's (just makes you smile having 5 good hitters doesn't it?) gets injured one of the DF (designated fielders) could be moved into the "batting lineup" or visa versa. A DF goes down a DH could be put into the "fielding lineup". Voila, we have the best team possible on the field at all times.