What about
Gotland?
This Baltic island is also just updated for the Lions of the North. When you start you have three options:
1. Play as a normal Monarchy interesting fun thangs
2. Play as a normal Merchant Republic which means you’ll fight for trade members with Novgorod and Lubeck.
3. Play as a pirate republic raiding people, and then you can choose to raid the Baltic or relocate to the Caribbean.
You have fun powerful things as a pirate republic and relocating to the Caribbean would be fun.
The Monarchy wants to replace Denmark and has missions to help with that:
Here is the Monarchy Mission tree. As you can see it’s pretty military.
Here’s the Merchant Republic:
As you can see, you have the standard Merchant Republic style things like making a trade fleet and making the money.
Here’s the Pirate Republic Mission Tree:
As you can see here you are building up a Pirate Fleet, looting place like London and becoming the Terror of the Baltics.
Basically, this is a Choose Your Own One Province Island Adventure. Military? Trade? Piracy?