Quote:
Originally Posted by Lathum
It's a bonehead move on D1 to kill an unknown player, the odds are OVERWHELMING that it will be a villager and in a game where everyone has a role it's an even worse move.
|
Actually, there were already four "cleared" people, with the telepaths and dubb. And ntn wasn't going to search himself. And there are four wolves (assuming all roles) and the Minotaur doesn't seem much help to anyone either. That's more than a 35% chance that ntn's "random" choice was a good one, and the odds are good it would not be one of the top villager roles.
Add on top of that that ntn had to make a decision right away and had found the device in you, a person of suspicion, it seems to me it was an understandable call, and not boneheaded at all. And of course it ended up being brilliant.