I personally think that Joe Smith was a more valuable player to his team and perhaps a slightly better overall player this year for Long Island. Paul Morris was in my opinion the best "hitter" in that league this year. I would think they would be 1 and 1A for the MVP.
I'm not choosing the awards, I'm letting the AI do it because it is much more fun for us to debate the closer awards after the season when I don't feel like everyone is second guessing my opinions.