Kamchatka:
We are an Arctic Mild Winter province with just a 1 tax base and very little production from the fishing industry. The land we live in is mostly plains, and we have one port in the area. Our settlers require little.
Being in the Arctic, with a Mild Winter, hurts attrition, supply limits, and settler chances.
Assuming that you do not have a very good understanding of Kamchatkan Geography, I have taken a picture of the area for you.