Ok, this is the last argument I can come up with. Dubb, Lathum, and I all claim to be affiliated with the mafia. RPI has not come out and claimed anything (therefore is not mafia). Since all three of us claim to be mafia, if all three of us had the mafia's best interest at heart, we should all be voting for RPI fan. By voting for him, we guarantee a mafia victory one way (if Dubb is mafia) or another (if I am mafia). Now, if it turns out that we vote for RPI fan and I or Dubb turned out to be a werewolf, the mafia would still win. By voting for me tonight (with the chance I could be mafia--which I am) there is a chance the mafia could lose. By voting for RPI Fan there is a no-lose situation for the mafia.
unvote Dubb
Vote RPI-Fan
if all three of you really have the Mafia's best interests at heart, you should be voting out RPI-Fan. If you each believe yourselves to be Mafioso, then that leaves RPI out in the cold, and guarantees a Mafia victory.
|