Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Barkeep49
Ok let me play the role of hoops for a minute.
We're likely to lynch either Dubb or Ardent tonight. There are 4 possibilties between these two:
1. Neither is a Sith
2. Ardent is a Sith
3. Dubb is a Sith
4. Both are Sith
Now for the sake of this argument it's irrelevant what direction we go for the lynch. My question is what do we learn if the person who we lynch turns out to be Jedi. Assuming no new information, do we then go for the other person? This then leads to the risk that it is villager A vs villager B and we're in no better shape.
This is further complicated for me as neither Dubb nor Ardent has, in the posts I quickly skimmed over for each, been particularly vocal about anybody. In essence I think we learn very little from tonight's lynching and are in a terrible situation for tomorrow. I guess what this is saying is that I supprot cartman's move back to qwik. I feel pretty good about him being a villager. But I think FAR more is learned from finding out about him then either of these two.
|
Dola, sorry wasn't expecting things to move this quickly on a Sunday afternoon.