Alternate history, not a replay? Was going to say that the 4-pitcher team would almost have to be the A's or the Mets otherwise.
Off the top of my head some pitchers who might be on this list:
- Dwight Gooden
- David Cone
- Roger Clemens
- Dave Stewart
- Chuck Finley?
- Too early in their careers for Maddux or Randy Johnson to be big.
- Who else was on that Boston staff with Clemens?
- I feel like I'm missing a ton of people that I should know.