From RPI's post, #177. The first port after my herbalist claim.
Quote:
There are three scenarios I see based on this post:
1) You actually are the herbalist, and instead of trying to make a smart play to avoid being lynched are trying to take the easy way out, and hurting the team majorly in the process.
2) You're a wolf, trying a desparation play as the herbalist. If so, just how dumb do you think we are?
3) You're not a wolf, pretending to be the herbalist. This wouldn't be an awful play, but trying something so opaque early on is just not a good move.
|
Not very much thought here.
1. He calls my claim the easy way out, and says I will hurt the team majorly in the process. I don't see how he can claim this. He later says I will be EXTREMELy valuable. Again, no explanation there.
2. No real analysis here.
3. He thinks that if I'm a normal, villager, pretending to be the herbalist, this wouldn't be an awful play? It's so clearly awful that words don't describe it!
I'm just saying he jumped out immediately against me, and his arguments are too flimsy for such a lack of caution.