Award
| Player
| Team
|
|---|
Player of the Year
| Sherman Elliott
| Baltimore
|
Front Office Bowl MVP
| Trevor Burton
| Kansas City
|
Offensive Player of the Year
| Sherman Elliott
| Baltimore
|
Defensive Player of the Year
| Kelvin Clayton
| New Orleans
|
Offensive Rookie of the Year
| Terry Henderson
| Cincinnati
|
Defensive Rookie of the Year
| Eugene Buning
| Tampa Bay
|
All-League First Team Quarterback
| Sherman Elliott
| Baltimore
|
All-League First Team Running Back
| Clifton Cochrane
| Cleveland
|
All-League First Team Fullback
| Christian Glover
| Carolina
|
All-League First Team Tight End
| Kenny Malfara
| Baltimore
|
All-League First Team Wide Receiver
| Artie Metzelaars
| New England
|
All-League First Team Wide Receiver
| Jake Giles
| New England
|
All-League First Team Center
| Carlos McCormick
| Atlanta
|
All-League First Team Offensive Guard
| Oscar Harvey
| Baltimore
|
All-League First Team Offensive Guard
| Lewis Henson
| Kansas City
|
All-League First Team Offensive Tackle
| Bucky Myers
| Chicago
|
All-League First Team Offensive Tackle
| Leonard Lake
| Minnesota
|
All-League First Team Punter
| Burt Johnston
| Cincinnati
|
All-League First Team Kicker
| Harold Hartman
| Tennessee
|
All-League First Team Defensive End
| Randall Collier
| San Francisco
|
All-League First Team Defensive End
| Alfred Wynn
| New Jersey
|
All-League First Team Defensive Tackle
| Michael Smithnosky
| Baltimore
|
All-League First Team Defensive Tackle
| Ricardo Shaw
| Cincinnati
|
All-League First Team Inside Linebacker
| Kelvin Clayton
| New Orleans
|
All-League First Team Outside Linebacker
| Tony Hartwell
| Minnesota
|
All-League First Team Outside Linebacker
| Richard Wagner
| Detroit
|
All-League First Team Cornerback
| Mitch Carter
| Tampa Bay
|
All-League First Team Cornerback
| Matthew Peacock
| Houston
|
All-League First Team Safety
| Omar Sanford
| Baltimore
|
All-League First Team Safety
| Britt Gaines
| San Diego
|
All-League Second Team Quarterback
| Corey Henson
| Arizona
|
All-League Second Team Running Back
| Doug Hampton
| Baltimore
|
All-League Second Team Fullback
| Shane Shepherd
| Green Bay
|
All-League Second Team Tight End
| Shannon Dennis
| Green Bay
|
All-League Second Team Wide Receiver
| Marc Connell
| Minnesota
|
All-League Second Team Wide Receiver
| Dan Carlisle
| Tampa Bay
|
All-League Second Team Center
| Adam Crouse
| Green Bay
|
All-League Second Team Offensive Guard
| Donovan Astley
| Seattle
|
All-League Second Team Offensive Guard
| Roman Anderson
| Tennessee
|
All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle
| Brant Arnswaldt
| Miami
|
All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle
| Brian Stevens
| Houston
|
All-League Second Team Punter
| Steve Wilton
| Atlanta
|
All-League Second Team Kicker
| Leroy Matsko
| Atlanta
|
All-League Second Team Defensive End
| Kerry Casher
| Philadelphia
|
All-League Second Team Defensive End
| Marcus Pipkin
| New York
|
All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle
| Robert Fenimore
| Kansas City
|
All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle
| Jimmie Harrington
| Jacksonville
|
All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker
| J.C. Botello
| New Jersey
|
All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker
| Allen Fasani
| Oakland
|
All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker
| Rick Freeman
| Seattle
|
All-League Second Team Cornerback
| Winfred Hicks
| San Francisco
|
All-League Second Team Cornerback
| C.J. Bradford
| Dallas
|
All-League Second Team Safety
| Brady Kuehl
| Miami
|
All-League Second Team Safety
| Steven Lane
| New Jersey
|
League's Fastest Man
| William Chapman
| Tennessee
|
League's Strongest Man
| Roosevelt Doyle
| Carolina
|