WW Dukes Versus Hunters (GAME OVER!!--See Post #1387)

[The Jackal]

unvote EF
vote font

[The Jackal]

No shenanigans

[The Jackal]

Unless you count duking as a shenanigan, in which case there may very well be shenanigans

[Shoveler]

ALLAH AKBAR!!!

http://imgur.com/cHYv4JK

[The Jackal]

Um, that's concerning.

[Raven]

^^ if font is a wolf, The Jackal is still likely a wolf, despite his switch!

[britrock88]

highly anxious and entertained all at once

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Raven

^^ if font is a wolf, The Jackal is still likely a wolf, despite his switch!

Based on Shoveler's post it sounds like we may have just hit endgame.

[Chief Rum]

DEADLINE

[britrock88]

Seems early for endgame, no?

[MartinD]

Popcorn-munching zombie watching with interest...

[Grover]

Originally Posted by Shoveler

ALLAH AKBAR!!!

http://imgur.com/cHYv4JK

Hahahahha

[Chief Rum]

FINAL Day Three Vote Tally


fontisian (7)-- cheekimonk (799), Autumn (806), Shoveler (807), Narcizo (885), britrock88 (886), Raven (890), The Jackal (901)
EagleFan (4)-- fontisian (821), Grover (844), timmae (859), MrBug708 (870)


Yet to Vote: EagleFan

[Raven]

F5 F5 F5 F5 F5....

[Grover]

Originally Posted by Raven

F5 F5 F5 F5 F5....

Maybe try Alt+F4 to see if that helps

[Chief Rum]

Writing up lynch results.

[Chief Rum]

The late day shooting of MartinD has the village scrambling.

Everyone, Hunters and Dukes alike, gather in the town square, yelling at each other and accusing nearly everyone else of horrible crimes. You would have thought oil profiteers were hiding behind every door and in every gator pool.

Many villagers leaped to hold EagleFan, the erstwhile killer of MartinD. EagleFan seems apologetic, saying he thought MartinD was an oil profiteer. That did little to mollify his accusers.

But then others stood up for EagleFan, saying he would not do this without good cause. He is not innocent, just wrong! they say.

So attention turns to the one everyone looked at from the start. The one most sure of herself. The loudest. The most opinionated.

The villagers leap upon fontisian and hold her fast, preparing to introduce her to a gator's sharp jaws.

"No! She is not an oil profiteer!" Shoveler cries out. "Don't make this mistake! Fontisian may irritate you all with her confidence and no holds barred approach, but she is on our side!"

The villagers, as always so easily swayed, consider his plea. Voices cry out, "Then who, Shoveler? Who?"

"Him!" Shoveler says, pointing at timmae. timmae roots into place, barely understanding what has happened. A villager steps up before he can start to move and shoots him between the forehead!

timmae falls to the ground, body convulsing. He is shortly dead.

What have we done? the villagers ask themselves. Others kneel down beside his body to search him. In his backpocket, they find some papers.

Pulling them out, the Hunters have never seen papers like these. But the Dukes have. They are stock certificates from British Petroleum!! They are signed over to timmae!!

Timmae was an oil profiteer!!

TIMMAE was a Hunter and the Peacemaker. He was the Cunning Wolf.

SHOVELER is a Duke, and has used his Duke ability.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Grover

Maybe try Alt+F4 to see if that helps

Reminds me of the tyranny of CTRL+TAB being adjacent to CTRL+Q...

[Chief Rum]

Running night actions.

[britrock88]

Whoa!

[britrock88]

(Lol, need to be quiet, sorry.)

[Chief Rum]

All PMs finally sent. Writing up night the night results.

[Chief Rum]

There is much satisfaction throughout the village at the death of timmae. Shoveler gets drunk as snot from all the moonshine sent his way. That just means he got drunk off other people's stuff instead of his own like normal.

Everyone knows there are still oil profiteers in town. But for tonight, it feels like a night of celebration. Everyone goes to bed and sleeps peacefully for the first time in days.

When the sun comes up, it feels like life may be returning to normal. Eggs are gathered, firewood is chopped, yards are starting to be ranked and cleaned.

Suddenly, a villager comes running into the town square, calling alarm!

He calls out from everyone to follow him. Soon, he is at The Jackal's door, hanging wide open.

"We were supposedta go gator huntin' today!" says the villager breathlessly. He almost seems weepy. He doesn't say another word.

You all peek in and see what he has found. The Jackal lies dead, face down on his lone table in his shack. He has been strangled!!

THE JACKAL was a HUNTER with no role, and a normal villager.

[Chief Rum]

Deadline for Day Four is 4 p.m. EST/1 p.m. PDT Friday.

Hunters may commence shooting.

[Raven]

Going back and rereading Timmae's posts, here is where I am at...
I feel good about Grover, cheeki, Autumn and obviously Shoveler.

There just aren't enough combos of people that could be aligned with font, so font is also cleared in my mind.

Likely wolf/cultist remaining...
EF, Brit, Narc, Bug

[Raven]

vote britrock

[Raven]

My reasoning...

Originally Posted by timmae

Here's where I am at.

Good - Font/martin (until proven otherwise with CC or ?), brit (content, hunting tone), ef (responses are similar to good ef weird D1 but more normal now)

Neutral - shoveler (active with content but not sure on reads), narc (pushing font/martin wagon), autumn (mentions looking elsewhere for evil but keeps going back to font/martin)

Slight evil - jackal (didn't like his D1, liked D2, now not sure), raven (looking for more content here), cheeki (seems to be all over the place), grover (need content/reads)

No read/absent - mrbug

Originally Posted by timmae

Ok, long day at work. Did a quick reread to get up to date. I like what I have seen from font, narc, shoveler, Brit, EF and jag. Vaimes seems like normal vaimes. Cheeki, Grover and raven to a smaller extent seem a bit quiet but I havent read them well and/or they have been in tough positions the last few games. Jackal seems the most pingy so far.

unvote cheeki
Vote jackal

[Autumn]

I was pretty suspect of Timmae, though I'm surprised Shoveler was sure enough to duke out of the blue. It was a good thing though, catching the cunning like that is a stroke of luck, leaving our seer a clear playing field.

I felt very good about Jackal, so sorry to see him go. Probably special hunting there.

Font is still my main target. Problem with Timmae being gone is he was my next go-to and I'm not sure who is at the top of my list now. Going to look back later tonight.

[Autumn]

For now...

Vote Fontisian

[Shoveler]

Well I'm honestly surprised to still be alive and kicking.. Odds were that timmae was a duke..

[Shoveler]

Good news is that there aren't many hunters left, so the wolf dukes dont have many safe options. Since we dont think a conversion has happened yet, they likely have 1 duke/1 hunter, or 2 dukes.

[Shoveler]

Originally Posted by Autumn

I was pretty suspect of Timmae, though I'm surprised Shoveler was sure enough to duke out of the blue. It was a good thing though, catching the cunning like that is a stroke of luck, leaving our seer a clear playing field.

I felt very good about Jackal, so sorry to see him go. Probably special hunting there.

Font is still my main target. Problem with Timmae being gone is he was my next go-to and I'm not sure who is at the top of my list now. Going to look back later tonight.

I had been trying to hold myself out as a hunter (perhaps to obviously) since yesterday evening. I was hoping that if font was a duke she would duke to me while I duked to my primary suspect.. 50/50 on the lynch, but font would have died in the process so we would have found out her alignment.

[Autumn]

I glossed over the fact that Timmae was Peacemaker at first reading. So both the faction roles are gone. Makes things slightly simpler at least.

[Grover]

Crap about Jackal, but awesome job Shoveler!

[Shoveler]

Day One


Zinto (7)-- Narcizo (108), The Jackal (283), Vaimes (312), JAG (316), fontisian (321), Grover (326), Autumn (343)
The Jackal (5)-- Raven (106), timmae (154), britrock88 (317), Shoveler (327), MartinD (358)
Vaimes (1)-- cheekimonk (293)
timmae (1)-- EagleFan (82)
fontisian (1)-- MrBug708 (178)




Day Two


MartinD (8)-- timmae (495), EagleFan (500), Raven (595), britrock88 (608), cheekimonk (611), Autumn (621), Narcizo (637), Shoveler (644)
Autumn (3) -- Grover (598), MrBug708 (629), MartinD (632)

No Vote: The Jackal, Vaimes
Unable to Vote: fontisian




Day Three


fontisian (7)-- cheekimonk (799), Autumn (806), Shoveler (807), Narcizo (885), britrock88 (886), Raven (890), The Jackal (901)
EagleFan (4)-- fontisian (821), Grover (844), timmae (859), MrBug708 (870)

[Shoveler]

put myself in green, as technically you cant clear me of being a wolf.

[Grover]

Originally Posted by Raven

vote britrock

Convince me

[fontisian]

Ok. I think the seer should claim now.

[fontisian]

Raven, Bug and Grover are probably town due to their vote placement near timmae.

[Raven]

Originally Posted by Grover

Convince me

Start by rereading post 927, knowing Timmae was a wolf.
If you were a wolf would you be casting your teammates as slightly evil and too quiet and potentially draw suspicion to them, or would it be far more logical to cast them as good/neutral?

So this makes me lean Grover, cheeki, Autumn are all village. We also have to believe Shoveler is pretty much cleared now.

Leaving: EF, font, brit, narc, bug.

EF and font have been at each other's throats all game. Now that obviously doesn't eliminate them both as wolves, but makes it more likely that they are not aligned.

With Day 3 voting being so close (before I voted, EF didn't vote and Jackal switching)
EagleFan (5)-- The Jackal (815), fontisian (821), Grover (844), timmae (859), MrBug708 (870)
fontisian (5)-- cheekimonk (799), Autumn (806), Shoveler (807), narc, britrock

It's most likely that anyone a wolf would not be voting for EF if he was a wolf, because he himself has no Duke power.

So if EF is a wolf - font, grover and bug are not. Leaving narc and brit (since I already decided to favor with cheeki, Autumn, Shoveler). Plus why would timmae vote fellow wolf?

Now that leaves font as a wolf with Duke powers.
font as a wolf Hunter.
font as a villager.

if font was a wolf - narc and brit do not have to jump on the end and could have voted EF, allowing font to remain out of the running (or not force her to use Duke powers, if she has them).
If font had wolf duke powers, and was working with wolf Shoveler, then she could have used hers and allowed Shoveler to save his.

There's probably more that I am leaving out, but this obviously gets very convoluted when you consider all the Duke possibilities.

[cheekimonk]

Autumn leans much more town than she did which, following convos, puts me on Narc (I've had them pegged as non-aligned since D2). Still wary of EF and font.

vote Narc

[Raven]

Since I suspect both narc and brit, I have no issues switching to Narc if he gets another vote. Both narc or brit would be a good vote today imo.

[Raven]

Honestly, I'd prefer one of the hunters just shoot one of them (narc/brit) ASAP, so we can find out if one is a wolf and lynch the other.

[Shoveler]

going to have to take a lot of time to consider everything. hopefully the remaining(?) wolf hunter will shoot me and I wont have to fry my brain.

[fontisian]

I mean, it's extremely likely that either Narcizo or Autumn is scum. I've already shot Autumn (as he's the harder lynch and his flip condemns EF), so hopefully that will hit as soon as Chief is done processing.

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by Raven

Honestly, I'd prefer one of the hunters just shoot one of them (narc/brit) ASAP, so we can find out if one is a wolf and lynch the other.

I actually think Narc and Brit are the two worst options right now, below Shoveler.

[Raven]

The other possibility is font/timmae/grover/MrBug as wolf/cultist.

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by fontisian

I mean, it's extremely likely that either Narcizo or Autumn is scum. I've already shot Autumn (as he's the harder lynch and his flip condemns EF), so hopefully that will hit as soon as Chief is done processing.

I sure hope you are bluffing, as another villager shooting could cost us the game.

[Shoveler]

it's very possible one of the last two hunters is the blank.

[Raven]

Originally Posted by Autumn

I actually think Narc and Brit are the two worst options right now, below Shoveler.

Why?