Small game - Return of Werewolf Xtreme (Game over! Result in Post 401)

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by britrock88

Does anyone have thoughts on the priest's approach for D2 and forward? (As in, is it more valuable to investigate lynch or NK victims?) ((As in, should he look for dead wolves or dead power roles? ))

Ironically, I don't have a feeling for this, despite being the one that has multiple times forced this role and ruleset on you unhappy FOFCers. I always hoped Hoopsguy or someone would figure out the ideal way to play with priest type roles.

I assume it's best to clear up our lynches, so we know if we hit a wolf, with the exception being if the priest thinks perhaps the wolves hit a seer. But it's going to be hard for them to play.

[mysfit]

Unvote Grover

Vote Chief Rum

for piling on a villager because she's chatty

[mysfit]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

VOTE MYSFIT

Because she has already posted more than everyone, and being OTR (Over The Radar) is way, way wolfish.

(P.S. Welcome to the board lol)

If you followed Bug's and Mug's games you would know I am ALWAYS chatty

Maybe because over half the group is UTR but still

Thank you for the welcome, wolf. Looking forward to games with most people being involved rather than just showing up to vote

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Autumn

I assume it's best to clear up our lynches, so we know if we hit a wolf, with the exception being if the priest thinks perhaps the wolves hit a seer. But it's going to be hard for them to play.

I'm inclined to agree with you. We _know_ which way NKs will count (for parity, at least--they could catch the sorc, hence my modQ). Lynches can run the gamut, though, so I think they're worth more information on the margin.

Then again, we might find that a very interesting day/night sequence makes it potentially rewarding to check the NK... But I'd lean toward the priest viewing daytime targets, I think.

[The Jackal]

Vote Grover

I think he's pretty close to taking my "always a wolf" mantle

[The Jackal]

Fairly busy day at work lined up, will probably have more time later on

[The Jackal]

I tend to lean towards the Priest scanning the lynch victims since without that knowledge it's going to be super tough to do vote analysis

[The Jackal]

So, if we don't hit a wolf (or sorceror) on D1 or D2 it'd look like:

2-2-1 .. still not endgame depending on what the priest has been able to reveal, since the sorceror doesn't know who the wolves are. but it'd be getting tight. this game has the potential for some very interesting scenarios

[Grover]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

Vote Grover

I think he's pretty close to taking my "always a wolf" mantle

So if I'm village this time, that makes you a wolf.

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by mysfit

If you followed Bug's and Mug's games you would know I am ALWAYS chatty

Maybe because over half the group is UTR but still

Thank you for the welcome, wolf. Looking forward to games with most people being involved rather than just showing up to vote

Haha yeah I noticed.

I'll leave my vote on you for now for fun, but assuming you don't do anything terribly wolfish, I'll probably switch to a relevant vote at some point today.

[Grover]

It has been unusually quiet around these parts today.

You're all wolves. All of you. Except me. I'm a villager.

[JAG]

Day 1 vote (as of Post 61):

mysfit 2 - britrock (38), Chief Rum (42)
Autumn 1 - Grover (19)
britrock 1 - Shoveler (36)
Chief Rum 1 - mysfit (52)
cheekimonk 1 - timmae (18)
Grover 1 - The Jackal (55)
The Jackal 1 - Autumn (35)

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

Haha yeah I noticed.

I'll leave my vote on you for now for fun, but assuming you don't do anything terribly wolfish, I'll probably switch to a relevant vote at some point today.

Well, hell, am I supposed to wait on you before shifting off mysfit?

[Autumn]

That is a crazy vote spread.

unvote
vote chief rum

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by Autumn

That is a crazy vote spread.

unvote
vote chief rum

Man I give you a seer role, and you do that to me. To me?!?

[timmae]

Checking in before my commute home. I think priest scanning the lynch/nk victims gives us the most information. Not much content to go on yet but I will be on tonight.

[mysfit]

Originally Posted by timmae

Checking in before my commute home. I think priest scanning the lynch/nk victims gives us the most information. Not much content to go on yet but I will be on tonight.

Since the Priest can only scan the deceased, lynch or NK are the only ones he CAN scan...............

I mean is there any other way to become deceased?

[Chief Rum]

UNVOTE MYSFIT

Okay, done playing around (especially as my random vote was putting misfit in a tie for the vote lead).

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by mysfit

Since the Priest can only scan the deceased, lynch or NK are the only ones he CAN scan...............

I mean is there any other way to become deceased?

I think the point of discussion was whether to scan lynchees or nightkill victims, as it would be one or the other.

As you note, there aren't really many ways to die.

[britrock88]

Yeah, timmae, it's some combination of those two options, and no more.

[britrock88]

Quick tally update sees mysfit with 1, Jackal with 0, and Chief with 2.

I will...

UNVOTE mysfit
VOTE cheekimonk

(Chief and cheeki aren't voting anyone currently.)

[britrock88]

So that's Chief/cheeki 2, Autumn/brit/Grover 1.

[Grover]

unvote Autumn
vote cheekimonk

[Chief Rum]

Insert ChrisTuckerFridayDriveBy image

[timmae]

Darn smartphone... I think priest reading lynch victims is the way to go. That way we will know if our reads are accurate or if we need to readjust.

I will reread when I get to my CPU and get an actual, i.e. Not meta, vote in.

[cheekimonk]

Sorry everyone. Catching up. On a quick read...

vote britrock88

[timmae]

Hey shoveler.. What are your thoughts man!
unvote cheekimonk
Vote shoveler

[Grover]

*crickets*

[timmae]

**waves at grover**

[Grover]

Hi tim!

[Chief Rum]

We have a lot of spread here. Heck, even if you all consolidate on me, get off these individual votes. Killing me does the village no good, but consolidating the vote does and it may prove useful later when the priest and seer reveal their findings.

[Chief Rum]

VOTE CHEEKIMONK

Self-defense.

[Chief Rum]

For the record, my posting leading up to the deadline will be sporadic, but I will be checking in.

[JAG]

Day 1 vote (as of Post 82):

cheekimonk 3 - britrock88 (71), Grover (73), Chief Rum (82)
britrock 2 - Shoveler (36), cheekimonk (76)
Chief Rum 2 - mysfit (52), Autumn (64)
Grover 1 - The Jackal (55)
Shoveler 1 - timmae (77)

[timmae]

We have like 3 hours to go before hitting lynch chaos... Lots of time left. Need to finish cooking wine first! I will be back.. With my reads (however early and/or inaccurate as they may be).

[Raven]

Originally Posted by timmae

My name is Tim so...

I hope that "hi tim!" can become the new "hey brad!"

[Shoveler]

Sorry timmae, I quit checking the thread earlier when nothing was happening. To be honest I was waiting for you to start posting so I could figure you out since you seem to be the only person I can (somewhat) accurately read.

I'm good with my vote for now. There is still plenty of time left tonight before lynch. But I am not seeing much to go off of from anyone right now.

[Grover]

Originally Posted by Raven

I hope that "hi tim!" can become the new "hey brad!"

let it begin!

[timmae]

Hi everyone!

So cheeks... are you saying you are all caught up? Anything else to add? Wolf have your tongue?! Donner party?

[The Jackal]

unvote Grover

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

We have a lot of spread here. Heck, even if you all consolidate on me, get off these individual votes. Killing me does the village no good, but consolidating the vote does and it may prove useful later when the priest and seer reveal their findings.

Hm, I can't decide what I think of this post.

[timmae]

Originally Posted by Shoveler

Sorry timmae, I quit checking the thread earlier when nothing was happening. To be honest I was waiting for you to start posting so I could figure you out since you seem to be the only person I can (somewhat) accurately read.

I'm good with my vote for now. There is still plenty of time left tonight before lynch. But I am not seeing much to go off of from anyone right now.

So how am I reading? I know the answer so your answer could tell me lots. Don't want to fall victim now.

[The Jackal]

But for now, I'll:

vote cheeki

[Shoveler]

Originally Posted by timmae

So how am I reading? I know the answer so your answer could tell me lots. Don't want to fall victim now.

Right now you are in the "no clue" section. I need to see your reads, which I know would be hard to put together right now, but that's how I can figure out if you are on the level or not.

[britrock88]

Back in action. Jackal's revote takes Chief out of cheeki's reach for a self-defense tying vote.

[timmae]

Originally Posted by Shoveler

Right now you are in the "no clue" section. I need to see your reads, which I know would be hard to put together right now, but that's how I can figure out if you are on the level or not.

Working on them... some of you haven't given me much to go on. Into the night we go.

[Grover]

Originally Posted by Shoveler

Right now you are in the "no clue" section.

I'm guessing this is a rather large pool of people at the moment.

[britrock88]

Indeed. If I am at the top of the post leaderboard, we should be quaking with fear.

[Grover]

Originally Posted by timmae

Working on them... some of you haven't given me much to go on. Into the night we go.

but the night is dark...


... and full of terrors!

[timmae]

Grasping for straws here but since we are on a dead end road here goes nothing...

Leaning good: Grover (would a guy who's been wolf like every single game draw attention to himself by posting wierd stuff... methinks not), britrock (wifom is possible but I am reading good here, trying to figure out game)

Neutral: mysfit (chatty back and forth, no bad vibes but have no meta), chief rum (here and posting but not sure on content, wierd mysfit vote, joke maybe, then self protect vote), jackal (afk for a bit, want to hear his thoughts about game strategy)

Slight evil: Autumn (a bit of game strategy posts early, then a quick vote, I almost expect more content here), cheeki (seems reserved, only 2 posts, no humor, is he covering or is this good cheeki), Shoveler (here but not much content, will base his read of me on my reads which seems odd)