Which QB had the better game?

[sovereignstar]

Originally Posted by Synovia

I do, but he'd never do that. The fact that he threw 4 in one game doesn't mean he'll throw 4 in every game.


When I see stat lines like QB2, in the NFL, generally the team lost. <50% for 300+ yards generally means your team had lost the game by halftime.

The point went the other way. You missed it.

[jbergey22]

Id take QB2's game but I have a feeling QB1 is the better quarterback.

I dont think QB2 would be able to put up that kind of 4/0 TD/Int ratio over time being this inaccurate.

Reminds me a a debate baseball people have a lot about runs/rbis as compared to some more advanced stats.

[miked]

I vote Johnstone.

[Koprnkc]

I would have to question where QB1 got his completions and yards. Was a large percentage of completions between the 20's? Once inside the redzone is that when the incompletions and INT occurred?

Everyone assumes that he threw for 2 Tds and a RB punched in additional TDs. But if he threw a Pic, thus costing his team a scoring chance and or failed to convert in the redzone and his team had to settle for field goals, then in my opinion he did not perform as well as QB2.

[Synovia]

Originally Posted by Koprnkc

and or failed to convert

I think its much more likely that QB2, with the sub 50% completion percentage, failed to convert first downs.