WW LXXIV Killer Kittens on Mount FujiMori day (GAME OVER- KITTENS WIN)

[Coffee Warlord]

Originally Posted by Coffee Warlord

This makes even more sense.

Forgot about the double scan. Nope, no it doesn't make more sense.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by Coffee Warlord

This makes even more sense.

The fact that you believe that is pretty damning.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by st.cronin

That would be ... incredible.

Yeah, I'm not trying to say I believe that. Just wondering why RendeR would do that. Seems like a poor play as a wolf.

[Coffee Warlord]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

The fact that you believe that is pretty damning.

Nah, more like the fact that I still couldn't bring myself to trust SL, and forgot about the double scan thing. (Keep in mind, if you are trusting Olie, I scanned good. Which I am.)

HOWEVER.

I still think we have way way WAY too many powers on our side. Something's not right here.

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

You were told KWhit had made the attack?

I was told I blocked Kwhit.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

Or there are two bodyguards, which would explain you seeing two people.

I think the simplest explanation is that the BG was fighting, and two people (attacker and victim) were around him.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

I think the simplest explanation is that the BG was fighting, and two people (attacker and victim) were around him.

Simple explanations are nice. This game seems to be moving away from simplicity though. Wrinkles galore?

I guess we can deal with this RendeR business as we're lynching KWhit, at least we have that going for us.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by Coffee Warlord

Nah, more like the fact that I still couldn't bring myself to trust SL, and forgot about the double scan thing. (Keep in mind, if you are trusting Olie, I scanned good. Which I am.)

HOWEVER.

I still think we have way way WAY too many powers on our side. Something's not right here.

I forgot that you were scanned good -- thanks for reminding me.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by RendeR

I was told I blocked Kwhit.

Cool. So, faced with olie's scan of Sea Lion as good, and cronin vouching that Sea Lion was the one he followed, you're still sticking to your story?

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

Yeah, I'm not trying to say I believe that. Just wondering why RendeR would do that. Seems like a poor play as a wolf.

Show of hands: How many of you out there thought it even the slightest bit odd that I CONTINUOUSLY questioned the BG revealing? that I kept nagging and talking against the idea?

Not the slightest bit of a hint there? =) i thought I was being so ridiculously obvious.

[Coffee Warlord]

We know who we're lynching today. I think that's pretty damn obvious, and it's the safe play.

Now, topic for discussion.

What happens if KWhit is good?

[The Jackal]

I excluded KWhit from the list.

Originally Posted by Lathum

1.Hoopsguy
5.Lathum- claimed fool, scanned clear by olie
6.Mcollins- claimes lolcat
7.Passacaglia
8.RendeR - claims BG
9.St. Cronin- claims stray
10.Oliegirl- claims seer
11.Eaglefan
12.the Jackal - claims duke
13.coffee warlord- scanned clear by olie
14.seolian - claims BG, scanned clear by olie
15.dangarion
17.Chief Rum

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by RendeR

Show of hands: How many of you out there thought it even the slightest bit odd that I CONTINUOUSLY questioned the BG revealing? that I kept nagging and talking against the idea?

Not the slightest bit of a hint there? =) i thought I was being so ridiculously obvious.

Actually, I saw you decide that there was no reason for the BG to NOT reveal, then backtrack on that decision a short bit later.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by RendeR

Show of hands: How many of you out there thought it even the slightest bit odd that I CONTINUOUSLY questioned the BG revealing? that I kept nagging and talking against the idea?

Not the slightest bit of a hint there? =) i thought I was being so ridiculously obvious.

Well I was very much against it as well. That'll be taken into consideration but you easily could've laid traces so you could fake reveal as soon as the real BG came out.

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

Cool. So, faced with olie's scan of Sea Lion as good, and cronin vouching that Sea Lion was the one he followed, you're still sticking to your story?

Absolutely. I was not told of ANYONE else being involved, simply that I blocked Kwhit in response to my order to Protect Oliegirl.

[oliegirl]

[IMG]
moar funny pictures[/IMG]

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

Actually, I saw you decide that there was no reason for the BG to NOT reveal, then backtrack on that decision a short bit later.

I sort of remember that too. Let me find that post.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by RendeR

Absolutely. I was not told of ANYONE else being involved, simply that I blocked Kwhit in response to my order to Protect Oliegirl.

But...how does that make Sea Lion evil? Who was he trying to protect, anyway? KWhit was already going to get lynched.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

I sort of remember that too. Let me find that post.

1125, 1142, and 1168

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by oliegirl

[IMG]
moar funny pictures[/IMG]

I have a real problem with this post. If you had scanned me, you would know this is untrue, so how do you base this?

[The Jackal]

Hm, here.

Originally Posted by RendeR

I'm either not thinking clearly today or there just isn't a lot of evidence to go around.

I'm still not impressed with the idea of anyone else revealing. Maybe I'm overthinking this though:

The unknown role(s) are the BG and the duke, I guess I'm stuck thinking the BG is pretty vital right now, but is it really?

If they both reveal, then we have at most 4 people left unknown and at most 3 dogs in those 4.

Someone with better math skills thans me sort that out, can we control the voting enough to hammer that out and still win with losing the roled players each night?

Help me clarify this in my brain folks =)

Originally Posted by RendeR

See I was thinking along this line as well, thank you for saying it.

What good is the bodyguard after tonight? Tonight he dies if he reveals, giving Olie one more scan, tomorrow Olie dies, they have no choice right?

So what good is staying secretive? who else can he protect that will make a real difference at this stage of the game? I think thats what I want to know. How does staying hidden really help us at all at this point?

[Passacaglia]

Oh, man, RendeR is going to be on the voting block for two whole days now -- maybe three if the board goes down. Get yer popcorn out!

[The Jackal]

And here's 1168.

Originally Posted by RendeR

Sorry darlin', nothing personal =) I'd love to keep you alive for a few more days too so you can scan, but the facts is the facts.

Make tonight's scan a good one =)


And based on what I've just read perhaps it is best if the BG stays hidden, it does at least add a point of confusion for the dogs to deal with that they wouldn't have if he comes out.

Thanks for the help clarifying things guys!

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

But...how does that make Sea Lion evil? Who was he trying to protect, anyway? KWhit was already going to get lynched.

Actually it doesn't, I don't believe he is a BG, I tihnk he's lying and is perhaps a dog that scans light. I really don't know.

He could be yet another lolcat and the 3 faction idea is coming out entirely?

I am the BG, I've put in orders each night except the first when clap had to find me via AIM to make sure I was still around at all.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by RendeR

I have a real problem with this post. If you had scanned me, you would know this is untrue, so how do you base this?

I assume she's just basing it off the fact that she scanned the other revealed BG as light.

[claphamsa]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

Oh, man, RendeR is going to be on the voting block for two whole days now -- maybe three if the board goes down. Get yer popcorn out!

Post of the thread

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by RendeR

Actually it doesn't, I don't believe he is a BG, I tihnk he's lying and is perhaps a dog that scans light. I really don't know.

He could be yet another lolcat and the 3 faction idea is coming out entirely?

I am the BG, I've put in orders each night except the first when clap had to find me via AIM to make sure I was still around at all.

It's possible there's a few lolcats around, I guess. But we already took out the light scanning dog. Two of those in one game would be tough as hell. But then again, it looks like we have a lot of powers on our side..

[oliegirl]

Originally Posted by RendeR

I have a real problem with this post. If you had scanned me, you would know this is untrue, so how do you base this?

Because I scanned SeaLion and he came back with a light aura, and he's revealed as the BG.

If you have a problem being called a liar, you are playing the wrong game...

We need to have nightfall, lynch Kwhit and I can scan RendeR...if he comes back Dark Aura we lynch him and have 1 more doggie to lynch for the win...

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by RendeR

Actually it doesn't, I don't believe he is a BG, I tihnk he's lying and is perhaps a dog that scans light. I really don't know.

He could be yet another lolcat and the 3 faction idea is coming out entirely?

I am the BG, I've put in orders each night except the first when clap had to find me via AIM to make sure I was still around at all.

So, what about cronin saying he followed Sea Lion, and saw him fighting with two people? Practice?

[Seolian]

My orders for the 3 days are as folllows. I protected OlieGirl the first night as she is my wife. Then I did coffee Warlord as I figured he might be a target as he was leading things and had scanned light. and tonight I did OlieGirl again as she came out as the seer.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by oliegirl

Because I scanned SeaLion and he came back with a light aura, and he's revealed as the BG.

If you have a problem being called a liar, you are playing the wrong game...

We need to have nightfall, lynch Kwhit and I can scan RendeR...if he comes back Dark Aura we lynch him and have 1 more doggie to lynch for the win...

I'm not sure it's worth scanning RendeR, but perhaps it's the more conservative play.

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

It's possible there's a few lolcats around, I guess. But we already took out the light scanning dog. Two of those in one game would be tough as hell. But then again, it looks like we have a lot of powers on our side..

My point exactly, there are SO many people with some power in this game, there appear to be at least as many locats as dogs if not more and THEY have powers. Why would it be so surprising to have more than one scan-proteted dog? nothing else seems normal in this supposedly NORMAL game *leers at clap*

I'm sending a question to clap via PM momentarily because I tihnk in ihs haste he's causing some really undo confusion on something, back shortly.

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by Seolian

My orders for the 3 days are as folllows. I protected OlieGirl the first night as she is my wife. Then I did coffee Warlord as I figured he might be a target as he was leading things and had scanned light. and tonight I did OlieGirl again as she came out as the seer.

Thanks, that helps. RendeR, can you give your list?

[claphamsa]

Originally Posted by RendeR

My point exactly, there are SO many people with some power in this game, there appear to be at least as many locats as dogs if not more and THEY have powers. Why would it be so surprising to have more than one scan-proteted dog? nothing else seems normal in this supposedly NORMAL game *leers at clap*

I'm sending a question to clap via PM momentarily because I tihnk in ihs haste he's causing some really undo confusion on something, back shortly.

sorry RendeR ur not my type

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by RendeR

My point exactly, there are SO many people with some power in this game, there appear to be at least as many locats as dogs if not more and THEY have powers. Why would it be so surprising to have more than one scan-proteted dog? nothing else seems normal in this supposedly NORMAL game *leers at clap*

I'm sending a question to clap via PM momentarily because I tihnk in ihs haste he's causing some really undo confusion on something, back shortly.

It makes me feel lame for having a one time power that I didn't even use when I should've.

[oliegirl]

I hate all of you guys for getting me addicted to that stupid lolcat site...

[IMG]
moar funny pictures[/IMG]

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by claphamsa

sorry RendeR ur not my type

Leering is not a complimentary thing, I'm inclined to be pissed off about now and you're at the center of it due to your minimalist style of PM's.



Ok, so Clap answered me, I saw nothing apparently. If there was someone fighting kwhit at the same time I saw not a god damned thing, but I blocked him, oh deaar god yes, I blocked khwit.

Fucking hell, it makes no god damned sense.


lynch me. Seriously, I'm not going to sit here and play the game according to hidden rules and invisible forces at work behind the scenes. The game is hard enough as it is.

I am if not THE bodyguard, then at least A bodyguard.

lynch me, I'll prove it.

[Coffee Warlord]

[The Jackal]

I just wanted to point this out.

Originally Posted by claphamsa

no roll is limited by number....

[Passacaglia]

Originally Posted by RendeR's Battlestar WereWolf rules

This game is going to be what I call a "Dark Matter" game basically this means that you players have the BARE minimum informatoin to start with and must learn as you go. So there will be very little info here beyond the bare essentials.

[The Jackal]

haha well played pass

[Passacaglia]

Now that RendeR's calmed down -- or got himself worked up more, can't say for sure which -- I think we can look past him a little, and go with the idea that they are both bodyguards. I don't see why RendeR would have come out like this otherwise. It makes no sense to point fingers at Sea Lion, when he's been scanned as good, AND his story is corroborated.

[oliegirl]

[IMG]
moar funny pictures[/IMG]

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

At least you were WARNED up front to expect the unexpected.

[Passacaglia]

That said, we still need to look at Coffee Warlord -- he's been scanned as good, but there's no reason he can't be a chihuahua also.

[EagleFan]

I need to take a while to process this. Until then at least one thing is clear, I think.


vote KWhit

[oliegirl]

Originally Posted by RendeR

This would be what I was waiting for. Seolian is not the bodyguard. I am. I protected no one the first night as I was not around at deadline. I tried to protect Purduebrad night 2 because I had given him the benefit of the doubt during the vote.

I protected Olie last night and she was attacked by Kwhit *based on my PM* I was not told of anyone else that I blocked, only that I blocked Kwhit.

Wolves: Kwhit and Seolin

Pass: I switched to Khwit today during the vote that was was I was referring to.

I still think RendeR is a wolf...

We lynched PB day 2, the BG power is against night kills, not lynching...so how does what he said about PB make any sense?

[RendeR]

Ok let me clarify WHY I'm pissed off, if I can anyway.

I'm told I blocked Kwhit.

Seolian says he blocked Kwhit.

Cronin says he followed seolian and saw himfighting two people.

IF this is all true then WHY didn't *I* see a third party?

IF this is true why didn't Seolian see a third Party?

my only explanation is that Seolian is lying, but he scans light so WTF am I suposed to think now?

seriously? What would YOU do?

[RendeR]

Originally Posted by oliegirl

I still think RendeR is a wolf...

We lynched PB day 2, the BG power is against night kills, not lynching...so how does what he said about PB make any sense?

rather simple, my orders went in at like 10am. this schedule falls right in the middle of my nusiest time of day Olie, its not like I have the chance to be here through the morning every day. I put the order in early to make sure I GOT an order in instead of missing it like day 1.

PB got lynched, I got a msg saying PB is dead anyway.

[Coffee Warlord]

Originally Posted by Passacaglia

That said, we still need to look at Coffee Warlord -- he's been scanned as good, but there's no reason he can't be a chihuahua also.

Heh. Amusingly, if Kwhit turns out to be a wolf as scanned, you're real high on my suspicion list.