Small game - Return of Werewolf Xtreme (Game over! Result in Post 401)

[timmae]

Grover was around anyways... maybe he's gone now. Argh.

[The Jackal]

Thoughts if you're still around, Autumn?

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by timmae

chief... why would you claim before grover and I, who both are here, have voted???

You guys took too long. There was 30 minutes left. I wasn't going to risk waiting until the deadline to reveal.

[timmae]

unvote chief rum
cote brit

While we talk about this more.

[The Jackal]

It's a pretty risky move to call a wolf bluff with no reveal on death, timmae. CR is in the spotlight either way for the remainder of the game, and you'd think he'd likely be a NK target tonight if we don't lynch him.

[timmae]

that should be...

vote brit

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

You guys took too long. There was 30 minutes left. I wasn't going to risk waiting until the deadline to reveal.

I support this explanation.

Feel free to continue questioning for other reasons...

[The Jackal]

I buy it too, we saw how.. I can't even remember who it was anymore, is my memory that bad? .. got crucified for not revealing earlier in that other game

[The Jackal]

I say we at the very least get a second candidate in the mix, there's plenty of time. Although not sure who will check in during the next 17 minutes.

[The Jackal]

Make people make some decisions rather than just being able to pile on brit because he looks like the only choice

[timmae]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

We have a lot of spread here. Heck, even if you all consolidate on me, get off these individual votes. Killing me does the village no good, but consolidating the vote does and it may prove useful later when the priest and seer reveal their findings.

Why the heck would priest say something like this? Doest't make sense to me.. help me.

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by timmae

Why the heck would priest say something like this? Doest't make sense to me.. help me.

I had to play that like a random villager. Couldn't really come out and say hey don't vote me, I carry a cross.

Usually the candidates change some, but there wasn't really much movement today.

[JAG]

Day 1 vote (as of Post 162):

britrock 4 - Shoveler (36), cheekimonk (76), Chief Rum (129), timmae (156)
Chief Rum 3 - mysfit (52), Autumn (64), britrock88 (132)
cheekimonk 1 -Grover (73)
Shoveler 1 - The Jackal (148)

[Grover]

unvote cheekimonk

[timmae]

If this was full reveal I'd be voting you still.. Not your neck tonight though.

[Grover]

vote chiefrum

[britrock88]

I will say that I've felt like something of a third candidate all day. Then cheeki takes off, Chief reveals, and here I am.

[Grover]

I don't know if I believe Chief.

[timmae]

unvote brit
vote shoveler

[Grover]

I mean, anyone can claim anything. We won't know on his death if he lied or not.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Grover

I mean, anyone can claim anything. We won't know on his death if he lied or not.

Is losing the priest worth unsubstantiated double-guessing?

[The Jackal]

Like I said, the wolves should help clear CR up within a night or two.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Grover

I mean, anyone can claim anything. We won't know on his death if he lied or not.

The thing with this is that the ONE person who can find out is the Priest. So it would be, in a sense, the best false claim to use to avoid a lynch. But it's a terribly powerful role to lose.

[timmae]

Originally Posted by Grover

I don't know if I believe Chief.

I don't but I don't want the real priest to come out. We'll know more by letting him live. If... big if... he is good and brit is VV (I think so) then we have a 1 in 2 shot at evil elsewhere.

[britrock88]

UNVOTE Chief Rum
VOTE Shoveler

Would-be priest preservation.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by timmae

I don't but I don't want the real priest to come out. We'll know more by letting him live. If... big if... he is good and brit is VV (I think so) then we have a 1 in 2 shot at evil elsewhere.

If the real priest is someone other than Chief, don't reveal just because you find out I'm a VV.

[Grover]

unvote chief rum

[timmae]

I think we need to let chief live. No time to waste.

[Grover]

valid points jackal.

[Grover]

vote britrock

[timmae]

shoveler... what say you? I am hating every minute..

[timmae]

vote count??

[Shoveler]

Originally Posted by timmae

shoveler... what say you? I am hating every minute..

Either way we are going to lose our priest I would assume. If CR isn't dead tonight then we lynch him tomorrow?

[mysfit]

I think Chief is Jacking us.........my vote stays

[britrock88]

Brit 4, Shoveler 3, Chief 2

[JAG]

Day 1 vote (as of Post 182):

britrock 4 - Shoveler (36), cheekimonk (76), Chief Rum (129), Grover (180)
Shoveler 3 - The Jackal (148), timmae (169), britrock88
Chief Rum 2 - mysfit (52), Autumn (64)

[mysfit]

Frankly I think a TIE would be good about now

[timmae]

If he is priest then yes... but at least we don't lose our seer then.

[mysfit]

Unvote Chief
Vote Shoveler

[timmae]

LHLV though

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by mysfit

Frankly I think a TIE would be good about now

Seems wolfy.

UNVOTE Shoveler

[JAG]

Day 1 vote (as of Post 191):

britrock 4 - Shoveler (36), cheekimonk (76), Chief Rum (129), Grover (180)
Shoveler 3 - The Jackal (148), timmae (169), mysfit (185)
Chief Rum 1 - Autumn (64)

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by timmae

LHLV though

Good catch.

[mysfit]

Well you wouldn't know but I have always held first day lynches are bad and have worked for ties as a villager before

[britrock88]

I hope what we see--that Shoveler is in the thread--gets a full explanation at some point. Otherwise, his silence could be telling.

[mysfit]

we don't get reveals so we don't get anything from votes

all we do is kill our own

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by mysfit

Well you wouldn't know but I have always held first day lynches are bad and have worked for ties as a villager before

I can get that on some level. My "wolfy" read was really about the opportunity to take out 2 goods at once, which can/does happen on this forum.

[JAG]

Deadline

[britrock88]

:zombie:

Good luck, village!

:zombie:

[JAG]

Final Day 1 vote:

britrock 4 - Shoveler (36), cheekimonk (76), Chief Rum (129), Grover (180)
Shoveler 3 - The Jackal (148), timmae (169), mysfit (185)
Chief Rum 1 - Autumn (64)